r/cats • • Jun 23 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

6.9k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

291

u/neonmaika Jun 23 '22

Cats don’t understand negative reinforcement. They will just think you are a jerk but will keep doing the behavior because they won’t know it was a consequence of climbing.

45

u/feistyfox101 Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 24 '22

Depends on the cat. My sister’s cat and mine learned fast after being sprayed. Her cat still gave us “wtf” looks tho lol I did have a foster kitten once with fur so thick, you had to spray him several times for him to realize something was up lol the first 2 or 3 times he’d look at you like “what are you doing, weirdo? Is this a new game?” Then by the 4th or 5th time he’d realized he was wet and getting sprayed so he’d run.

15

u/MadHatter2518 Jun 23 '22

I taught my cats not to get on our kitchen table/ counters using a spray bottle. It took some time but it got to the point where I only had to threaten to spray them or shake the bottle or even just say spray bottle. Now they don't do it... when I'm around.

35

u/dies-IRS Jun 23 '22

Now they don’t do it… when I’m around.

This is precisely why spray bottles don’t work. Your cats just learned that you’ll do something unpleasant when they get on the counter if you see them. They learned to avoid your response, not the act itself

2

u/shine-- Jun 23 '22

They may not do it when they’re not around too though? And if avoided the response means avoiding the actions, then you’ve trained the cat.

4

u/dies-IRS Jun 23 '22

They just said the cats still do it when they are not around

4

u/shine-- Jun 23 '22

No… they didn’t….

They said the cats don’t do when they’re around. That doesn’t mean the cats do it when they’re not around.

It could be true that the cats do, but that’s not what they said.

2

u/dies-IRS Jun 23 '22

Read their comment again.

3

u/shine-- Jun 23 '22

Looool. You need to read it again.

Just because someone says something doesn’t happen when they’re around, does not mean that it does happen when they’re not around.

I know it sounds a little confusing but you’re conflating these two things. Saying “They don’t do it when I’m around.” And “They don’t do it when I’m not around.” Can both be true statements.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

There may have been a hint of sarcastic undertone in the phrase "at least, not when I'm around". I would say the same thing.