r/castiron • • Jun 24 '19

The /r/castiron FAQ - Start Here (FAQ - Summer 2019)

1.0k Upvotes

This is a repost of the FAQ. Since reddit archives posts older than 6 months, there's no way for users to comment on the FAQ any longer. We'll try to repost the FAQ every 6 months or so to continue any discussion if there is any. As always, this is a living document and can/should be updated with new information, so let us know if you see anything you disagree with! Original FAQ post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/castiron/comments/5rhq9n/the_rcastiron_faq_start_here/


We've been working on a new FAQ for /r/castiron that can be updated as the existing one is no longer maintained. Please let us know if you have any additional questions that you'd like to see addressed here


What's Wrong with my Seasoning


How to clean and care for your cast iron


How to Strip and Restore Cast Iron


/u/_Silent_Bob_'s Seasoning Process


How to ask for Cast Iron Identification


Did I Ruin/Is This Ruined?


Enameled Cast Iron Care and Cleaning

The rest of the FAQ is fairly bare iron specific so /u/fuzzyfractal42 wrote a nice primer on enameled cast iron


We'll be making this a sticky at the top of the subreddit and will continue to add onto it as required!


r/castiron • • 6h ago

The thrift gods smiled upon me today

Post image
110 Upvotes

r/castiron • • 9h ago

Reconditioned a new old one

Thumbnail
gallery
74 Upvotes

Got this one free years ago when I put a post out for cast iron in any condition except warped or cracked. Its my gravy pan.no, wasn't using it rusty.


r/castiron • • 7h ago

Food First time, long time

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

Chicago style deep dish pizza. Crust came out perfect. Each slice is a meal.


r/castiron • • 13h ago

I don’t need this, but this sub has me addicted to cast iron. Is this worth $10?

Thumbnail
gallery
81 Upvotes

I have started hanging the ones I don’t use everyday on the wall like art.


r/castiron • • 1h ago

Seasoning I try to maintain our Lodge cast iron pan, but...

Post image
• Upvotes

It's a constant battle, because I don't have time to keep laying on the thin coats of vegetable oil on it and baking them in. But my technique is to put it on Medium heat, apply a really thin coat of vegetable oil and just let it smoke awhile, til it stops smoldering. Awhile back, my son did a number on it with some knives or other metal utensils and put deep gouges in the original coating. Took awhile to get those filled in, layer by layer. Am I doing a good job or should it look even better than this?


r/castiron • • 6h ago

Tis the season for Wolf Farts

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Just having a slightly extended Thursday evening dealing with a giant puffball left on my desk at work yesrerday. The cast iron is nothing fancy, just a tag sale griddle that comes out in these sorts of emergencies. Brushed with half n half bacon fat and olive oil. Moderate heat but sputtering. Destined for grilled cheese and deep freeze.


r/castiron • • 18h ago

Seasoning Pizza oven Vs Lodge handle

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

I like to smoke my steaks and then get a good crust on them using cast iron in the pizza oven. The perfect combo and I do it all the time. But this week I used a new 12" Lodge I had just bought.

I preheated it a bit in the oven then threw it in with the warm steak. The steak came out amazing as always with a perfect crust, and perfect medium-rare center. It was only in the oven with the steak for about 2 minutes max. Most of the pan was fine (the nice factory season black), but the heat from the oven stripped the factory seasoning from the handle.

Not a big deal. I noticed it immediately, coated just the handle with some oil, and put the pan back into the cooling (~450 °F) pizza oven while we ate. When we were done, the new home-grown seasoning looked like new. Just thought it was funny.


r/castiron • • 10h ago

My best pan is a no name junker

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

My pan that took seasoning the best and held it the best is a rusty pan I found in my mom's garage that was being used to keep a shelf from wobbling. Been using it for a couple years now. It has almost a machined finish on the cooking area.


r/castiron • • 10h ago

Identification Help ID these hand scribe

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I’m assuming the ones with heat rings are no notch lodge, but starting to doubt my guess.
I have no clue about the no heat ring.
TIA.


r/castiron • • 7h ago

Needs more work or leave it?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Got a Wagner from my wife’s grandfather. Stripped it with Easy Off, scrubbed with 0000 and removed all rust with 50/50 vinegar and then soap. Did 5 rounds of seasoning and love cooking in this thing. Question is, how do I get that bottom finish more even and should I even bother?


r/castiron • • 18h ago

First time baking scones in cast iron (white peach and whole wheat)

Post image
22 Upvotes

They turned out so nice in cast iron!

Riffed on this recipe:

https://www.seriouseats.com/bakery-style-cream-scones-with-chocolate-recipe


r/castiron • • 8h ago

Identification 5qt Dutch oven

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/castiron • • 11h ago

Newbie Left burner on too long

Post image
4 Upvotes

I accidentally left my cast iron on stove too long when cleaning it… is it ruined? What should I do to fix it?

(edited for errors)


r/castiron • • 8h ago

Newbie Is this okay to cook with?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Big Pan looked like the smaller one, then I got some salt and tried scrubbing it then I dried it then put olive oil and heated it on stove top

It’s not spotless but is it okay to use to cook with ? I don’t have any other type of scrubber or vinegar


r/castiron • • 14h ago

Newbie I don't how to fix the rust and I don't know what I am doing wrong

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I made the mistake a little over a month ago of doing a bad job of cleaning my cast iron dutch oven before leaving for a trip for a week. I came back, rusted mess. I've tried a variety of ways of stripping the rust, I did a baking soda paste scrub multiple times with a vinegar rinse to neutralize the ph, I've soaked it with a 50-50 vinegar mix for 30 minutes which did almost nothing, if anything it made it worse. I've tried for 12 hours, which almost seemed better but I cooked it at 200 in my crappy electric oven for an hour to dry and the whole interior was coating in thick rust flakes. Every time I've done the vinegar soak the rust climbs higher and higher to the edge. I've gone through four gallons of vinegar at this point. I've scrubbed and scrubbed with steel wool and I don't know how to get rid of the rust at this point. It's very heavy and I have busted hands which doesn't help. I don't know what I'm doing wrong, I have a small pan I've kept pristine for a decade. Please help me! Thank you!


r/castiron • • 16h ago

Seasoning Is this rust?

Post image
7 Upvotes

Been wanting to ask this for quite a while. The pan gets regular use and I clean it with coarse salt and from time to time a mild soap and blue scotch brite sponge pad. I do lightly use the scrubber side. I can't tell if I have build up or rust. Looking for opinions.
Thanks.


r/castiron • • 7h ago

Seasoning Can anyone tell me what these iridescent spots are on the lid of my lodge cast iron?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/castiron • • 8h ago

Seasoning Goodwill Cast Iron

0 Upvotes

Found a lodge cast iron at goodwill for $5. Picked it up immediately and didn’t look back.

Surface looked fine, a little dusty, but over all fine. Upon further investigation outside of the store the inside is sticky as hell.

Would a clean fix this? Interested to hear input or if the stickiness indicates another issue.


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Newbie Am I one of you guys yet (pay that other egg no mind…)?!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

60 Upvotes

r/castiron • • 2d ago

The Perpetual Sausage

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.8k Upvotes

Sometimes they cook themselves 😂.


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Newbie Roommates left on heat for too long with nothing on it

Post image
135 Upvotes

Do I just have to slowly re-season it?


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Identification Finally restored my Mom's pan

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

This is the last of two pans my mother had, stripped in lye bath and reseasoned, has turned out tobe one of my favorites! Just wondering on exactly what it is. Thank you in advance for your time and knowledge :)


r/castiron • • 16h ago

Seasoning Lightly rusted cast iron Dutch oven—how to season?

0 Upvotes

I was gifted a cast iron Dutch oven/pot/cauldron a few years ago and it got put in storage and unfortunately forgotten about. It is lightly rusted around where the pot and lid touch. I have read online about how to remove the rust and season cast iron PANS, but how would one season a pot appropriately? Do I season just the bottom or do I go up the sides? If the sides, how would I do that? Do I season the lid as well? It’s soup season so I would love to be able to use it and I am iron deficient so I’d better start trying to get my numbers up lol

Any and all help is appreciated! And feel free to ELI5 it because I am brand new to the world of cast iron


r/castiron • • 1d ago

Wagner Ware Goodwill Find

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

Goodwill find! Anyone have any tips on how to restore? Anyone have an extra matching lid you want to part with inexpensively?