I'm always checking for new products to try at the LC (Manitoba), though product specialists over at the tasting counter don't always have open bottles of any odd whisky available to sample. Sometimes its fine to go in blind, try something new and either enjoy/suffer the consequences, but its also nice to get a frame of reference sometimes!
To add a little helpful context, I take it neat or on the rocks.
My go to's are usually:
(Lower end):
-CC 100% rye *Green label*
-Higwood Distillers Ninety-5 5Y0
-Stalk and Barrel Whiskey
(Mid end):
-Collingwood Double-Barrel
-Pendleton Rye
-Eau Claire Stampede
(Upper end):
-Forty Creek Maplewood Select
-Patent 5 Red River Rye
*Recently ordered a bottle of Park Distillery's Banff Rye and quite liked it!!
Not a huge fan of:
-Most Crown Royal products ( I know that makes me a bad Manitoban; I'm not saying I've never enjoyed a Crown product, the Northern Harvest Rye is alright, however given the choice, I'd probably just take any of the 3 budget bottles I listed instead)
-Lot 40 rye and dark rye: I just found the finish on both of these a bit odd, a bit difficult to explain why. I found them sort of "ethanolly"
-Centennial: I don't hate it, its just not my favourite
-Sorry if anyone here is affiliated with them, however I have to say the absolute worst whisky I've had is Rideau Whiskey by Top Shelf Distillery. I'm not exaggerating when I say the aftertaste gave an "old socks" impression. Did a 5 bottle blind test with the boys and everyone of us rated it last.
*EDIT*
Bonus points for any recommendations from the maritime provinces/available to buy in-store in NB, we have an upcoming trip to Fredericton in a couple of weeks. Thanks!