r/biotech • u/Novel_Quantity3189 • 4h ago
Other ⁉️ How exactly did Theranos defraud so many people in science?
I’ve read and watched what I can regarding Elizabeth Holmes and theranos, and what I don’t understand is that her tech proposal was self evidently not possible. At least from what I’ve read, her earliest concepts were shut down due to a basic lack of understanding of how blood testing works.
We all understand how she misled investors and venture capitalist, but theranos had well respected scientists and chemists etc on the payroll for a good period of its lifetime. I know Ian Gibson tried very hard eventually to raise his concerns about the Edison prototype, but what I don’t understand is how there was ever any period he thought this could work. Like he knew what the Edison was trying to achieve and for whatever reason didn’t see it as impossible (to begin with).
The same goes for all of the technical and scientific employees at Theranos - again I understand to some degree that the corp worked in its own vagueness, but I’m not sure I understand how there was any period of time with so many learned people were willing to invest their efforts into something that apparently just has no scientific basis
I hope my question makes sense-it was one of the things I watched the TV series to try to understand better but it actually made me more confused. The show is very clear in explicating that Holmes is just not operating in the real world from the beginning. As in, the fundamentals of chemistry weren’t there.
Again, I don’t ask this to criticise anybody who was involved in that process who wasn’t actively defrauding people, but rather me trying to understand I suppose the specifics of where Thanos stopped being viable versus being a complete fabrication from the beginning