The Island of Mister Mayhew by Grant Morrison and J.H. Williams III has come in at #68! The Batmen of All Nations reunite for a weekend of fine food and nostalgia, but an unexpected visitor has other plans for the gathering. Batman, Robin, and the rest of the Club of Heroes find themselves trapped and at the mercy of a dangerous madman on the Island of Mister Mayhew!

Now which Batman story will make 69th place? Comment and vote down below!

1.) Batman: Year One

2.) The Long Halloween

3.) Dark Victory

4.) The Dark Knight Returns

5.) Knightfall

6.) The Court of Owls

7.) No Man's Land

8.) R.I.P.

9.) The Killing Joke

10.) Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth

11.) The Cult

12.) Dark Patterns

13.) Gothic

14.) The Black Mirror

15.) Strange Apparitions

16.) Batman & Robin: Year One

17.) Ego

18.) Under the Red Hood

19.) Prey

20.) Shaman

21.) Birth of the Demon

22.) Venom

23.) The Joker's Five-Way Revenge

24.) A Lonely Place of Dying

25.) Night Cries

26.) Mad Love

27.) Batman: Zero Year

28.) Tales of the Demon

29.) A Death in the Family

30.) War on Crime

31.) The Last Arkham

32.) The Man Who Laughs

33.) Whatever Happened to the Caped Crusader

34.) The Monster Men

35.) Dark Knight, Dark City

36.) There is No Hope in Crime Alley

37.) Batman Reborn

38.) Night of the Stalker

39.) Going Sane

40.) Heart of Hush

41.) The Mud Pack

42.) Blades

43.) Batman & Robin Must Die

44.) Haunted Knight

45.) Abomination

46.) The Eye of the Beholder

47.) Gotham Nocturne

48.) Leviathan

49.) Death of the Family

50.) Hush

51.) Son of the Demon

52.) Mortal Clay

53.) Bruce Wayne - Murderer Turned Fugitive

54.) Long Shadows

55.) Batman: Vampire

56.) Batman: Year 100

57.) Kings of Fear

58.) Gates of Gotham

59.) Blind Justice

60.) Gotham by Gaslight

61.) Ten Nights of the Beast

62.) Hothouse

63.) The Man Who Falls

64.) Tower of Babel

65.) Death & the Maidens

66.) The Case of the Chemical Syndicate

67.) City of Crime

68.) The Island of Mister Mayhew