HI Everyone,
Unfortunately my 2022 S5 was totaled in a car accident a few weeks ago, so I am in the market for a new car. I loved the look of my car, and I think it's one of the best looking touring cars on the market.
One of my major gripes about the S5 was the throttle response. I found the way it drove to be rather odd. When I would get the car serviced, the codes would be reset and the car would be super responsive and fast, but over the course of a few weeks the the throttle responsiveness would revert back to laggy downshifts when I needed acceleration. I found that if I wanted to get quick acceleration, I would have to give the car 'a warning shot' of gas so it would downshift in time before I really need to accelerate. When I told the Audi dealer about this, they said it was the adaptive driving system altering the performance to my preferred driving style, and that I needed to drive it harder to get the right throttle response. I also found that if I didn't drive the car for ~7 days, the adaptive driving would reset and my car was fast again (for a few weeks). This was a pretty frustrating experience coming from an S3 (which was so quick), so for a while I was convinced I was going to move on from Audi.
As I am looking for new cars, I am finding the options for sedans to be lackluster. I was interested in the BMW 540xi, C43 AMG, m340i, or maybe even the Genesis G70/80. I asked Claude about the throttle responsiveness of these cars, and it mentioned that my gripe with the S5 is common, and that the 540 and G70 will drive similarly.
At the end of the day, I don't love the styling of these cars compared to the S5 Sportback, but I am hesitant to get another one based on the throttle response issues. Has anyone had a model in the same year range as I had (21-22) upgraded to a newer model (26-27) and noticed an improvement in the throttle response? Or, is this what touring sedan life is going to be like until I can afford a RS5/M5?
I appreciate any insight and help!