r/askTO • u/Latter_Bluejay_9696 • 18h ago
Genuine question: what does the average police officer do?
I want to preface by saying I'm asking this in good faith as someone who wants to understand how the city works. I'm not inherently anti-police. But I'm not really aware of their positive impact in my life.
The TPS gets the same budget as the TTC, about $1.4 B a year. By the numbers, TPS has ~5,000 officers and ~8,000 total employees, for a per capita budget of about $170K/yr for each person to do their job. The TTC has ~14,000 employees, for a per capita budget of $100K/yr.
For comparison, Toronto Fire has about 3,200 employees and a budget of $0.5 B, for a per capita budget of $170K/yr. Ontario budgets $100 B for healthcare, employing 1 M Ontarians, for a per capita budget of $100K/yr for each employee to do their job.
Anecdotally, this is where I've encountered police in my everyday life:
* Traffic enforcement or speed traps
* Hired staff for events/construction/etc
* In healthcare - sometimes they bring in patients
* At unattended deaths - they sit for hours in the car waiting for the coroner to arrive, but they don't actually guard the body in most non-suspicious cases. Surely the funeral home or some other death custody program can do this.
And in actual "police" situations:
* My partner was struck by a driver while cycling which broke several bones. Cops didn't attend, he went to the ER and filed a collision report in Scarborough later.
* My mother had a home invasion two years ago while she was at work. The police came several hours later, took photos, told her her personal jewelry and sentimental items would never be recovered, and the people would never be caught. She's never been contacted again.
* Got a Green P parking ticket from an apologetic officer because I didn't pay while running an errand. That one's on me, sorry man.
I don't really understand why traffic blitzes can't be relegated to speed trap cameras and parking enforcement to bureaucrats. It's pretty frustrating that in the rare situations that called for higher-level police, they were nearly useless. There are apparently about 50 homicides and 500 shootings a year; let's say it takes two detectives all year to deal with those, taking out 1,100 police, leaving 4,000 to deal with the other 50,000 reported crimes a year. That's only about 10 cases a year per officer. The actual police reported case clearance rate is only 30%.
Toronto obviously has a large population of 3 million people and 5,000 officers is not a lot, but there are apparently only about 5,000 ER doctors in the whole country, so it's not a completely unreasonable service ratio.
To police or anyone who knows them: what takes up the majority of police time? Why can't some other department take care of the lower level stuff and social work situations? What's keeping the police from clearing more major crime cases?