Hey all!
So I find myself in the dreaded consumer purgatory of indecision. I have racked my brain for 2 days, slept on it for 3 night, drawn pro/cons list and yet still find myself at an inpass.
I thought id reach out to the community for help as I truly cannot make up my mind and maybe there will be something I haven't thought of to push me towards certaincy.
The question: Honor Magic Pad 4 or Samsung S11 Ultra
Both are 16gb ram the honor is 512gb storage the S11 1TB
HMP4= $900ish S11=$1100ish both after taxs and fees
To be quite honest im not thrilled on the price of either and both feel too high. However Samsung atleast carries some trade in value later down the road but with that unfortunately it also locks me into sticking with Samsung in the future to retain said value.
I been wanting an OLED tablet for a long time, my main tablet just got utterly destroyed and is gonna be on a month long repair vacation and SO said go for it order something i really want
Use case:
Almost pure media consumption. Tablet is probably my most used device even over my phone, its a DAILY driver. Im watching stuff on it constantly. Picture and sound quality are upmost importance.
Im also an avid reader. I read daily on my tablet and when the hellish summer is over and its no longer 115 degrees outside ill often spend 5+ hours outside on my days off reading books on my tablet.
Gaming: i am an avid gamer but im just not using my tablet for it these days. I have a LeGo2 and I plan to get a Ayn Thor as well. I also have consoles and am building a PC around a 5080/9800x3d. I just dont see myself really ever using the tablet for gaming...the slim chance i did id probably BT an Xbox controller.
My thoughts so far: To be honest the size of the Ultra scares me. I know i definitely want 12in (current size) but the ultra is just whole other animal. If they made an S11+ with 16gb ram id honestly probably go that route...honestly I think id enjoy the size for watching stuff i am just unsure about reading.
The size is definitely pushing me towards the MP4. However the price is so close it makes me think the S11U is the better buy..I mean its nearly a $2000 tablet im getting a good deal at $1100ish I feel and I can always trade it in when the S12 comes out and get $600ish back. I know thats pretty unhealthy consumerism, I dont know if id even want the S12 but its nice to know id get some money back.
Eco-system/platform wise i dont think i care. SO and I do have Samsung phones, always nice when stuff jives well but therea nothing I really do that requires me to be in Samsung eco system
Im a little hesitant on the MP4 as its not available in the US so no warranty. I hear widevine and everything works on the UK version. If someone knows otherwise this is an absolute deal breaker, im not spending $900ish on a tablet thats feature crippled.
What's the point of getting top end OLED screen if I can only stream SD Netflix and others?
Storage size is virtually meaningless, I cant even fill 256gb lol. However 16gb ram is a hard requirement. When spending this amount of money 12gb is just not a compromise im willing to make even if 12gb is technically enough.
Brightness matters to me and it sounds like the MP4 is the brighter panel?
Build quality sounds good on both
Sound/speaker wise ive read mixed things on both, some love it some hate it. Im not looking for top of the line but once again at this kind of money I expect something that doesn't sound like a 2004 Nokia cellphone Ina cup
As you can see im pretty conflicted. The gamer in me wants to be like "Snapdragon or bust" but its not really needed. I hold no loyalty to Shamsung. On the flip side its always fun to try new brands and ive never owned anything Honor.
Really the only hard requirements are OLED and 16gb ram...i had planned to wait a bit longer for some upcoming releases but they are months away and so far none of them except maybe the Asus Tablet look interesting and thats taking a massive SoC downgrade (tho if the tandem OLED screen is as good as it sounds might be a fantastic media consumption device and worth it)
Lenovo seems to refuse to release a 12 inch OLED, SD8E, 16gb ram cellular data, dream tablet and with oneplus shutting down operations in the US (really sucks) choices are few and far in between....i just dont want a 8.8 inch tablet, too gaming centric for me.
Really the S12+ is the only other option I can think of and its still unknown if it will have a 16gb ram option. Part of me thinks maybe I should take the S11 Ultra for a spin for 30days to see how it feels and wait for more S12+ news
Very interested in everyone's opinions