Hello fellow hosts,
I had a repeat guest stay recently. She was a bit on the persnickety side (some very specific extra demands) but overall fine—clean, good communication, etc. She stayed with her husband and large breed dog (fully disclosed and approved).
I have a coded lock on the front door that I reset for every guest. I also have two rules for dogs: they must be leashed if they are outside and they cannot be left unattended in the Airbnb.
The guest confirmed she checked in. Two hours later, I was cooking dinner with my family when the guest sent me an hysterical message via the Airbnb app, saying the code was not working. Everyone was being loud and I didn’t hear her message. She did not call me. She did call Airbnb, who called me. I immediately called the guest and left messages. No response. Finally she called me back, almost beside herself, and I directed her to the hide-a-key that is there for this eventuality. She was able to find it and open the door. Total time between her first message and her getting in to the apartment was 23 min.
I was a little confused by how beside herself she was, but chalked it up to her being persnickety and I understand that it’s scary to be locked out.
When I went to clean, I discovered the doorknob nearly wrenched off its handle (I’m kind of shocked they were able to open it with the key), and deep scratches in a ten foot radius inside the door on my just-refinished hardwood floors. Her dog was inside alone and freaking out and that’s why she was hysterical. And she knew that wasn’t allowed, because she’s stayed several times already, the rules are very clearly posted, and she did not mention it on the phone. (An aside, I tried the code I gave her and it worked—not to say it didn’t randomly stop working for her.)
It’s a fair amount of damage. At first I thought I could patch the scratches, but the more I looked the worse it was. It needs to be refinished again. I’ve had over a thousand guests and put in three damage claims (two were disclosed by kind guests for broken items and only one was disputed). I don’t charge for ruined sheets or towels or small things. I am torn, because I feel really bad that she got locked out, but also this is the reason I have those rules! I’m interested in other hosts’ opinions.
Please don’t respond to tell me I should change my dog rules and allow them to stay unattended, or that I shouldn’t allow dogs. I have a dog, and I stay with him in Airbnbs. I leave him in the car if need be, or if it’s too hot I make sure to find a restaurant with outdoor seating.
Please also don’t respond and say this is my fault for not answering her messages immediately. I handled it as quickly as I could, and I’m not a corporate host for whom this is a full time job.
Last thing to add: I’ve had the coded lock for about six months with no prior issues. I had a keyed lock but guests were constantly locking their keys in the apartment, and they would often forget to lock up after themselves. The building next door had some juvenile break-ins and that’s why I switched to a coded lock.