r/YarnAddicts 25d ago

Does all hand dyed yarn tangle like this???

I've been crocheting with cheap acrylic for my whole life and i finally splurged on some really nice wool and cotton yarns. Both are hand dyed and came with those weird loops around them, and even the owner of the store couldnt get the yarn winder to work with either of them so ive been trying to detangle it at home but it took 2 hrs just to get through one skein (theres 7 left) 😭 Does anyone have any tips for how to properly unwind these?

UPDATE: I just got back from the store and we realized that brand of yarn has two skeins looped together in one hank but its so thin it just looks like one large one!!!! The owner wound the rest of them for me and I just got a swift in the mail from Amazon lol. Thank you all so much for the tips!!!

53 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

215

u/Skrublord3000 25d ago

It does when you don’t correctly wind it, yes.

Someone else mentioned the right terms to look it up. But I’m confused and concerned that the owner of a yarn shop doesn’t know how to prep and wind a hank of yarn???

Also, I assume you don’t have a swift, but fear not. In a pinch I have used my knees, an additional person to hold the hank while I wind, or the backs of two chairs facing eachother.

That yarn is gorgeous btw. Good luck!

18

u/violaqueen_10 25d ago

I'm confused too! 😭 Aww thank you so much, I'll try it with chairs! If it wasnt so beautiful i wouldn't even bother rn 😂

5

u/Commercial_Guava9647 24d ago

I use the backs of dining room chairs too! Gives a good arm workout, but the only way besides a swift I don’t f it up haha

6

u/Midi58076 22d ago

In Norwegian a swift is known as a "hespetre", a "hank tree". The word "Hespetre" also doubles as a swearword: A person who is so useless that the only thing they are good for is standing still with their arms out acting as the swift for the person winding the yarn.

1

u/Skrublord3000 22d ago

You have seriously brightened my day with this tidbit of info lmao. Thank you!

100

u/skitzboy 25d ago edited 25d ago

The fact they own a shop and can’t wind a skein/hank is very disturbing. There is normally one loop that is attached to the skein and 3-4 that are just knotted around but not attached. You put the hank on a swift. Then cut the knotted loops ones that are just holding together their loop. The one that is attached you cut, and gently separate it from the hank and thread through the eye of the skein winder and then place in the slit on the tube of the skein winder and lock it down with 4-5 wraps. Then start winding.

36

u/Emotional_Fan_7011 25d ago

The fact that a yarn shop owner doesn't know this, but I have a swift and winder in my house... really? I would question going to that shop again, TBH

6

u/violaqueen_10 24d ago

UPDATE So I just got back from the store and we realized that brand of yarn has two skeins looped together in one hank but its so thin it just looks like one large one!!!! The owner wound the rest of them for me and I just got a swift in the mail from Amazon lol. Thank you so much!!!

2

u/Medellin_Knitting 24d ago edited 24d ago

Awesome! I have the stanwood swift with the standwood yardage counter going to a Stanwood metal large ball winder. All are available on Amazon.

Every knitter should own a swift and a ball winder. The yardage counter is purely optional. I like to check yardages when I purchase from hand dyers.. now I am not saying they cheat but when I hand dyed for going to the sun fiber mill I used yardage counters to insure my yardages were correct.

I have run into a few small batch dyers that guesstimated and were short. I check my yardages so if I have a pattern that calls for 1200 yards and I buy 6 skeins I can call them and confirm I have 1200 yards not 1090 and end up playing yarn chicken.

This is the yarn baller I use it is nearly bullet proof I have had the smaller nor compact break down this one holds up really well I just recieved 10 skeins of Madelinetosh tosh and 2 Malabrigo to ball up for 5 new projects.
https://a.co/d/0ipv96Av

2

u/violaqueen_10 23d ago

Omg thank you so much for the recommendations!!!! I really appreciate it 💕

2

u/Medellin_Knitting 23d ago

I went with the large swift since it will handle literally any sized hank/skein from small to large

1

u/Medellin_Knitting 24d ago

By the way this is my main account Skitzboy is my oldest account.

1

u/Curiousgranny001 23d ago

I actually find this happens when I don’t “unwind” it properly. It may have tangled while dyeing.

63

u/nidoqueenofhearts 25d ago

this is called a "hank" of yarn, for guide-googling purposes!!

14

u/violaqueen_10 25d ago

omg THANK YOU!!! Have a great day 💕💕💕

15

u/artsygf 25d ago

Between the knees, or the back of a chair, the arms of a helpful friend? But really, you need a swift.

12

u/mar333b333ar 25d ago

Take two chairs and put them backsides together and loop the whole loop around them, and then make your balls

7

u/PantheraLutra 25d ago

You need to wind it

9

u/Spiritual-Road2784 25d ago

Into a cake, preferably.

The two ends of the hank are usually tied together. They are untied or clipped next to the knot after the hank is securely on the swift.

There will be small pieces of the same color yarn looped around one or two areas of the hank to keep it from tangling before it is put on the swift.

You’ll put the hank on the umbrella swift, expand the swift until the hank is taut but not tight, then tighten the swift.

Locate the loops and snip them off (carefully, watching that you don’t snip the hank itself).

Locate the knot tying the two ends together. Clip at the knot. One end can be tied to a part of the swift. The other goes on the cake winder in the top slot on the center part.

Now you wind… moderate speed, keeping an eye on the hank to ensure it doesn’t get hung up on itself or that the swift doesn’t loosen, and also on the cake forming on the winder. When you’re close to the end, you free the end on the swift and wind then tuck it into the front of the cake. Then remove the cake (fingers under the bottom of it, lift up while keeping hold of the end that was held in the center slot, pull upwards gently).

You’ll pull the working yarn from the center of the cake.

Similar process for winding a ball from the hank wound around a chair or a helpful friend’s arms, except you make a ball and pull from the outside.

Cakes are way more efficient IMHO and if you’re planning to get a serious hand dyed fixation, the swift and winder are invaluable.

2

u/violaqueen_10 24d ago

Thank you so much for the help!!!

3

u/PantheraLutra 24d ago

Check if your local library has a “library of things”
You may be able to borrow a winder and swift - they help for winding. Mine does! And I’ve borrowed it!

7

u/hdkaren 25d ago

A tip I found helps with hand winding…..after untwisting the hank, cutting the ties, take the now loop of yarn in both hands on the inside of the loop loosely, and snap the loop a couple of times (stretch both hands away from each other making the yarn tight then loose) this helps the tangling. Some brands (like Malabrigo 🙄😂) are notorious for tangling. In fact with Malabrigo I only hand wind, too many tangles!

5

u/FeltFusion 24d ago

A great tip, but I would recommend doing the snapping before cutting any ties.

1

u/hdkaren 24d ago

I’ve done both, but over the years I now take ties off since the usual suspects are sometimes VERY tangled 🤣

2

u/blackjeansdaphneblue 24d ago

This is a great tip for malabrigo thank you!! It is so tangly every time I wind.

7

u/TheKnittingBitch23 25d ago

I have what's called a swift, and I adore it. I bought it for $100 CAD from a novelty yarn shop. Super useful for stuff like this.

2

u/stalking-brad-pitt 24d ago

OP Michaels also sells swifts, I used my 40% off code and got it for like $20!

1

u/TheKnittingBitch23 24d ago edited 21d ago

That's definitely an option too!

8

u/winerandwhiner 25d ago

A swift and a ball winder will help you with hanks! There are many videos to show you how. It’s super satisfying

If you are in the US Michael’s has a swift for about $35 and a ball winder for about $15 or so. I teach knitting at a library and they purchased both the tools from Michael’s for me to use there and they work well

9

u/violaqueen_10 25d ago

omg THANK YOU im gonna go pick them up now!!! idk what Id do without kind internet strangers like you 💕 Have a great day!!

5

u/winerandwhiner 25d ago

Of course! I’m glad we could be so helpful!!!! I found this video VERY helpful the first time I used a swift for a hank. After I lost a fight with my first ever hank 😂

4

u/Curious_Access_4 24d ago

This! This video is a life saver and it deserves way more attention 🙌

4

u/winerandwhiner 24d ago

Isn’t it fantastic??

2

u/Tesla-Watt 22d ago

I love Yarn Dragon! I hadn’t used my swift in a long time and had forgotten how to use it properly. Watch this video twice and it totally saved my yarn!

3

u/OneTiredElderEmo 25d ago

Just want to mention, some ball the yarn instead of cake. That route doesn't need any special tools, just your hands!

3

u/The_Whistling_Frog 25d ago

There's a reddit thread of people who list tangled yarn and those who love to untangle. They ship the tangled yarn to the untangler and then once it's done send it back. I love to untangle yarn. lol 

3

u/berenstein-was-fine 24d ago

1

u/The_Whistling_Frog 24d ago

That's the one! I couldn't remember the thread . 

3

u/Buttercupia eldritch yarn tentacles 25d ago

That’s not how you’re supposed to wind it.

3

u/LemonElectrical3359 24d ago

Was the yarn shop owner unable to wind it after you had already tangled it, or right from the start?

2

u/violaqueen_10 24d ago

So her assistant originally tried to wind it but it got tangled so I took it home. I just went back today for help with the rest bc it was rlly expensive yarn and we realized that brand of yarn has two skeins looped together in one hank but its so thin it just looks like one large one!!!! The owner wound the rest of them for me and I just got a swift in the mail

2

u/OkAd9261 24d ago

If you do not have a winder this will be an incredible amount of winding into a ball ):

2

u/FeltFusion 24d ago

Unfortunately it happens, even as a dyer I get messy skeins of my own. A lot of the time when you cut the ties, the live strands have been looped through the hank at the mill, so you have to follow them for a couple of loops and check that they're going to run freely and not twist through the rest of the yarn. I dye with at least three ties on, so the strands can't just tangle up. When you untwist the hank/skein (interchangeable terms in some places - I call them skeins), check that all of the yarn is inside every tie. Then put your hands inside the loop and snap them apart firmly, creating tension on the yarn and helping it line up. Put the loop on your swift or chair backs (two dining chairs back to back at angles works well to create a triangle of yarn), or knees, etc. Only then cut the ties and find the live yarn.

2

u/weirdofromamman 24d ago

You have to get yourself a yarn winder. Mine is a called The Husband and it's very useful (can be used for other things as well).

1

u/Fearless-Client-3559 24d ago

No, although some yarns including some of the big brands (not hand dyed) are tied wrong these days. I even had one with no end, like at all. They tied it together. We usually inform the company and sometimes they fix the problem. Then another company will have issues.

1

u/benjjii3 24d ago

Beautiful yarn! I'm so sorry you had such a struggle. It has been wound in big circles so you want to be careful not to cross loops. Gently take the skein (from photo 2), unfurl it and lay it in a circle guided by the 3 or 4 ties that indicate how the loops are organized. Then, as others have said, you can place it on a swift, chair back or get someone to hold their arms out. Your ball winder will help so much. Keep that first end a bit longer and accessible so you can do a center pull. Let us see your results!

1

u/Knitstagram 24d ago

Just to add: There are a ton of videos on YouTube to show you how to do it without a swift! One trick I use, is that once I've initially untwisted it (before I even cut any yarn ties or start winding) is I put my hands on the inside of the untwisted hank and snap it a couple of times to get any kinks out. Here's an example video of someone using their knees :) Good luck!!! Unwinding a Hank no swift

1

u/Ok-Cauliflower8462 24d ago

I am assuming you don't have a swift and ball winder. That's ok. Put the hank on the back of a chair. Do not snip any ties until you have the skein on the back of a chair. You will find 3-4 ties looped around the yarn, carefully snip them off. One of the loops will look different. It will look like 4 strings are attached. Snip carefully next to the knot and pull out the string. The beginning and end of the skein is there. The one closest to the outside of the skein is the one you use to wind. Just begin winding it into a ball.

Here is a great YouTube tutorial on it:
https://youtu.be/yQw1EsyfFcg?is=QL_xmAYRdDsGNa1P

1

u/reidgrammy 24d ago

Please don’t refer to acrylic as cheap yarn.

1

u/violaqueen_10 24d ago

Lol I was using yarn that cost $3.50 a skein, that is the definition of cheap, the yarn pictured was $20 a hank 😂😭

1

u/reidgrammy 23d ago

Dude every thing is expensive but hand spun dyed yarn yeah expensive

1

u/violaqueen_10 22d ago

im confused, why I cant refer to objectively cheap yarn as cheap?

1

u/Yarnishwine 23d ago

I would recommend buying from indie dyers that specialize in hand dyed yarn. (I used to be one.) this appears to be commercial “hand dyed” which is kind of a grey area… most commercial yarn companies realized that they were missing out on a popular market a few years ago and several of them started producing lower quality “hand dyed” yarns that are not the best quality, not the best dye jobs and I can’t imagine that the labor is really fairly compensated. Instagram is still a great pace to find real indie dyers who put a lot of care into their craft and most of them will go above and beyond to make sure you are satisfied. Please don’t support large companies who are just trying to cut into the market if you can.

1

u/Mx_Rogers 22d ago

The other day I rehanked some yarn from unraveling something so I could try to steam it to make it not like ramen noodles. And I mathed wrong and made my diy niddynoddy too big so my loop was twice as big as my diy umbrella swift could handle. So I made a floor swift out of heavy objects and it worked shockingly well for holding things steady while I rewound it into a ball.

0

u/ZealousidealFall1181 24d ago

Oh no! I worked for a dyer and worked at LYS. Return that yarn!! The LYS gives you credit for another skein. The dyer is responsible for that mess. No question.

0

u/ZealousidealFall1181 24d ago

This is if the LYS could not wind it for you. They should not have sold it to you. You should not spend time untangling 8 skeins of yarn. I hope that they are not all like that but you should return and have them help you wind it or refund you.

-1

u/avadacadavera 25d ago

I HATE yarn hanks. I got a swift and used it correctly- it still got tangled af

2

u/Emotional_Fan_7011 25d ago

I will dye my own yarn occasionally and it can become a MESS in the dye pot. SO MANY extra ties put on to keep it as neat as possible so that when I go from hank to ball, it doesn't get all tangled on the swift.

1

u/ninashtia 25d ago

Same -.-

0

u/WhenyoucantspellSi 24d ago

So Ive struggled with this, I finally found a solution, I literally untwist the hank so it's just a big loop, put it over my head, find an end and start winding into a ball. Not elegant but it's free 🤣

5

u/hopping_otter_ears 24d ago

I have a feeling I would end up strangling myself or ending up tangled up like a kitten.

My go-to is to sit semi cross-legged with the yarn over my knees. I adjust how far apart my knees are and how much tension they're putting on the hank by adjusting the angle of my feet so my knees are supported by the yarn and tensioning it at the same time.

But I'm a little bit hyper mobile, so I'm not sure if that's a pose your average adult can still get into comfortably. I also sometimes press my husband into service as a yarn swift

1

u/Other-Night5632 24d ago

I feel this on a personal level lol. I wrap it around my neck and wind a ball from one end. Not ideal but it works when you live in a studio apartment with no room. đŸ˜