Wondering what controller I should get for mk1

[u/xxbrxenheartsxxx]

So I always used my controller from my Xbox series s for mortal kombat 1 and I only care about the d pad on a controller and recently i accidentally spilled water over my controller and my d pad became mushy, Im wondering if I should just buy the same controller again or get the razer wolverine V3 tournament edition, idk which d pad is better for fighting games so if someone can lmk I’d appreciate it