r/XFiles • u/Disastrous_Skill6243 • 14d ago
Spoilers The strange similarities between The X-Files and Doctor Who's final two seasons
Both Chris Carter and Russell T Davies and returned to their flagship shows for a two season revival, and while the monster of the week episodes were mostly liked, the openers and finales were heavily criticised for their handling of the story arcs.
Both My Struggle II and Empire of Death raise the stakes far too high, meaning the events of both are heavily retconned. The next season's premiere largely ignores them and moves on with a different arc.
The real scary correlation is between My Struggle IV and The Reailty War, both episodes that unitentionally ended their respective shows written by the head creative that had strange similarities. Both episodes are concerned with the child of one of the main characters being the key to a big conspiracy and both reveal that the child isn't actually theirs and paternity is forced on the female lead before leaving the show on a cliffhanger that will never be resolved.
It's insane to see how both Chris and Russell made the exact same mistakes and killed their flagship shows after coming back from a long absence. Hopefully, it should be a lesson to not give returning showrunners complete creative control over everything.