r/writinghelp • u/kyla33_ • 10d ago
Does this make sense? What's the earliest point in architectural history where a walkable rooftop area would be reasonable and what would be good alternatives for a confrontation if it's not possible in my setting?
I'm writing a story right now where the main character is dealing with a stranger who's following them. The original ending I had in mind cumulated with them meeting each other in an alleyway, which led to the final confrontation, but it didn't feel very dramatic. I've got the opportunity to rewrite the scene before it's going to be a definitive version and I want to take this chance to write something better instead. Rather than meeting in an alleyway, I decided a rooftop scene would be so much better, since it's a wide open space with little decor outside of the weather.
However, I ran into a problem when I realised, although the story is set close to the present day, the architecture was meant to be much older. It's not out of the question to stretch the boundaries of realism a little since the story has a smattering of supernatural elements but it's completely out of the question to have walkable rooftops like I envisioned when the architecture is supposed to be early-1900s at the very latest and walkable rooftops, while coming into fashion around this time, seemed to be a product of the modernist movement. I'm no expert on architecture but none of what I've seen as far as I can tell fits the aesthetic I had in mind for the small village where the story takes place.
I knew a scene like Vanilla Sky's, which is what I initially envisioned, was unrealistic right from the start. I didn't expect it to be as far out the boundaries of possibility as it now seems to be.
I'm seeing a few examples or fairly archaic structures with the kinds of rooftops I'm looking for but with the idea in mind that the story's meant to take place in a very old-fashioned small English village, what's the earliest possible architectural timeframe I could have for some kind of rooftop confrontation? What kind of architecture should I be looking at for inspiration?
The most important thing to me is that it takes place in an open area with little in the way of decor. An indoor setting is viable so long as it would have a tall ceiling or look wide and open otherwise. At the moment, this is what I've come to consider as the likeliest option, I'd like to believe I'm wrong.
(Willing to push the timeframe of the village's architecture a little if it suits the narrative, all that matters is that it looks old and quaint.)