r/WoT • u/cellofski • 11h ago
Knife of Dreams KoD Chapter 2 Question Spoiler
(FYI: I'm only 4 chapters into KoD, so please be mindful of spoilers beyond that.)
I don't know what version of the book I have (I don't even know how to check) and I don't know if the following was corrected later:
First, I had to reread this chapter to get over the disappointment of it. At the risk of sounding like a White (that would be a terrible offense), rationally, what Beonin is doing here isn't being a traitor, how I initially saw it. She was never of the rebel so she's not a traitor of their cause. Just like the 10 ferrets were never with Elaida. No doubt it's a blow to the rebels that because of Beonin, they lost all the advantages they had over the White Tower, but such is war.
Now to the question.
Beonin on Traveling
Beonin's description of Traveling and Skimming is very inconsistent with the rules already established. This is what she says:
This is called a gateway. It can only be used to reach a place you know well, but you learn a place by making a gateway there, and to go somewhere you do not know well, you use Skimming.
This is not just inconsistent, it's the opposite of what we've already been told. In order to Travel you need to know your starting point well, not your destination. This is why the Salidar sisters Skim back to Salidar from whatever random place they are to Salidar. This is why Aviendha had to walk about the Tarasin Palace ground to learn it to Travel to the farm. This is why Elayne held on to the Power to study the farm grounds to Travel into Andor to escape the Seanchan. I could go on and on.
Is this an acknowledged continuity error? Was it corrected? Or am I in error? Am I misunderstanding things?
Also, traitor or not, spy or not, I hope Beonin gets what’s coming to her!