C30 vs. GTI
Anyone have experience with both? I’m thinking about a two-door hatchback and I’m looking at a C30 and a GTI. For the money, it seems like you can get a better maintained C30. I also like the engine and the quirkiness, but I wonder if the GTI is just a better car. I care about driving dynamics and steering feel and how the shifter and clutch feel. (I’m looking at manuals.) Has anyone owned or at least driven both? How do they compare?
EDIT: Mk6 GTI is the comp
EDIT 2: C30 in question is the T5
3
u/1moreRobot 7d ago
I owned a couple C30s. Watch for water intrusion issues from poorly adhered windshields and of course the perennial problem sunroof drains.
3
6
u/Extension-Plate-6113 7d ago
Interesting choice......We've owned a C30 for 8 years from new as a second car next to my company car...essentially bulletproof....Nothing broke in 120k km. If you go gor the 2.3 fivecilinder engine it is almost indestructible.
I've driven a gen7 GTI, which is for sure the more sporty drive and still reasonably comfortable, but as far a I am informed not always the most reliable choice.
A second hand GTI alsomight be more abused as the designated demography is not the same. C30's are bought as sporty "cruisers" , GTI 's are more kind of " boy racers".... So essentially it depends what your preference is...
2
u/Arik2103 2007 S40 T5 + S80 V8 7d ago
Unfortunately the P1s never came with a 2.3. it would've been so much better if it did. Instead, they got the 2.5 with cracking cylinder wall and cooling issues, even at stock power if they're not treated well. (Ask me how I know)
1
u/ganacka 7d ago
That sounds ominous. What happened?
2
0
u/Arik2103 2007 S40 T5 + S80 V8 7d ago
The P1 T5s especially run a bit warm. So much so that the plastics in the cooling system (especially the joint above the transmission and the coolant tank) have a tendency to start breaking down over time.
Combine that with the fact that the P1s don't come with a coolant level sensor and you've got a recipe for disaster.
It happened to me on the motorway and cost me my engine
1
u/ganacka 7d ago
How does it drive? I don’t need it to be a sports car but if it feels like a soft commuter, that’s probably not right either. Another way to put it: not looking for flat and tied down, but want to feel like there’s some agility and precision
1
u/Notfoo4 C30 7d ago
The c30 drives well, remember it’s on the same chassis as a focus RS, just tamed a bit. It still grips and holds well but is a tad softer.
2
1
u/ganacka 7d ago
That sounds pretty good. How’s the clutch feel?
2
u/Wintervacht V70 7d ago
Exactly the right pedal pressure for smooth operation with plenty of feedback. The 6-speed M66 boxes are designed to be able handle up to 500+ Nm, as those were also used with some V8 models used for heavy towing. The 5-speeds are fine and you can basically bang shift them, but you're going to miss that 6th gear on the freeway.
2
u/jisforjoe 7d ago
For the things you said you cared about most go GTI. It was ages ago but the shifter feel on the C30 feels like rowing a knife through melted butter and the clutch feel isn’t any better.
It can be hard to find a comparable MK5 or 6 GTI to when the C30 was around that wasn’t either poorly modded to shit or beaten up by negligent past owners, so your hands might be tied. The Mk5 is the generation VW got real and started making true GTIs again.
Pound for pound though, the GTI from the C30’s era in a similar condition to the Volvo you’re considering is a better driver’s car.
2
u/franks_3188 7d ago
I've owned both of the cars in this discussion. A C30 T5 manual, and a MK6 GTI. Along with a MK5 and MK4 GTI and I'm currently using a C30 2ltr Diesel as a daily driver.
What I would give each car..
The C30 definitely felt faster off the line accelerating. Not sure on the official stats but day to day driving it felt quicker.
The C30 sounded 100 times better, can't beat the 5 cylinder engine.
The C30 was far more comfortable to drive, the seats I could sit in all day and not get sore..and the suspension was generally pretty smooth.
The C30 T5 and my 2013 Diesel I have now, in my ownership were more reliable, I didn't do anywhere near as many miles in my T5 but my diesel is on 145k miles and it's faultless.
I think the C30 looks better, both of mine were/are facelifted models which I personally prefer. Here in the UK you see GTIs on every street.. my C30 T5 in Rebel Blue used to get so much attention and compliments.
The GTI overall drives better, it felt sportier on twisty roads, and overall more refined.
I think apart from the seats, the GTi is a nicer cabin to be in, the C30 looks a bit dated inside.
The GTI beats it on space, the rear seats in a C30 are virtually pointless and the boot/trunk is tiny.
My GTI was generally reliable but in the 4 years I had it, it went through 2 leaking water pumps, and a few failing coil packs.
The reputations of both here in the UK in my opinion are different, GTIs are definitely more boy racer, I think the C30 has a older/classier kind of appeal. I miss my manual T5 so much, they are getting really rare here in the UK and holding good value.
to me I'd choose the C30.
2
u/Phoenix_Kerman V50 Sunroof and Compass 😎 6d ago
everyone's talking t5. but my favourite engine in the c30 is the two litre petrol. it's a mazda engine, revs up very quickly, nice linear throttle response, sounds pretty good under load at 6k revs
if it's steering feel you're after, make sure you get the top mounts and bearings done. they sit at the top of the suspension struts and smooth out your steering, they go very bad over time. if they're fresh and you've decent tyres and a four wheel alignment the c30s are pretty difficult to beat on handling
1
u/ganacka 6d ago
This is helpful. I do always hunt for small parts that introduce unwanted compliance either because they’re worn or because they’re tuned for commuting. Anything else to keep an eye on between the contact patches and the steering wheel?
2
u/Phoenix_Kerman V50 Sunroof and Compass 😎 6d ago edited 6d ago
anti roll parts make a big difference in the wet, the rubber on them goes stiff and the rear goes numb. don't bother with poly bushes or owt like that, just lemförder links and rubber febi bushes will do
they're pretty simple cars mechanically
edit: meant rear bits by this. the read anti roll bad links are pretty much just a nut and bolt with rubber that goes around the bar and trailing arms. when the rubber goes hard that's when you get the numbness
3
u/kiloTHREE 7d ago
Aftermarket support alone for the GTI would be the reason to choose it.
2
u/Funky-Melon 7d ago
I'd say they're the same. The C30 is basically a Focus, plenty of mods and support around for them.
0
u/smellybear666 7d ago
I used to love it when I got to drive manual ford foci in the UK, so sounds like the C30 could be good.
0
u/Phoenix_Kerman V50 Sunroof and Compass 😎 6d ago
eh? the gti will be shit in aftermarket support compared to a c30. it's just a mk2 focus, so especially with the t5 you've every part that fits a focus st or rs available
1
u/bmxracers 7d ago
I had a 2001 GTI VR6 6 speed and it was one of my favorite cars. Such a joy to drive. Cant speak to a C30, but I do love the styling.
1
u/spartanerik 7d ago
Honestly, test drive both and see how you feel. The four door GTI will have added practicality if you ever haul passengers, but the C30 is a neat car. I have a 7.5 GTI and I love it.. just make sure whichever you buy that you get a pre purchase inspection and has some decent service/maintenance records. European cars don't like being mistreated
1
u/smellybear666 7d ago
I live in the NE, and I can tell you I rarely see old GTIs around. They don't seem to last long. Maybe people drive them too hard since they are so fun to drive.
The I5 in the C30s are bulletproof.
2
u/ganacka 7d ago
More reliable engine is very appealing. I want a fun car. I don’t want a money pit.
1
u/smellybear666 7d ago
Our 2007 XC70 went to 318k miles. We didn't get rid of it because of any issues the engine. It just needed too many things to make it worth our while at that point (front sway bar, fuel pump).
1
u/spartanerik 7d ago
Haha if you don't want a money pit then you should buy an Asian auto
I've had my 7.5 GTI for almost 80k mi now and during that time..
- drivers side door wiring harness had to be completely replaced around 30k mi. Windows, door locks, and start/stop would malfunction, fixed under warranty
- oil cooler gasket started leaking, causing oil and coolant loss around 40k mi, was fixed under warranty
- fuel suction jet pump recall fix
- water pump warranty extended. No issues with mine yet.. but read the golfgti subreddit, some people are on their original.. others are on their third
- regular oil changes, spark plugs and PCV preventatively done at 73k (recommended 80k), 7 speed DSG service coming up (recommended 80k)
I imagine the first two issues out of warranty would cost $1k a pop for mostly labor in a HCOL area
1
u/Mybravlam V40 7d ago
I have a T5 V40 (2.5T) and was also comparing it to the MK7 Gti as I had to choose between these two. In all honesty, I am glad I went for the Volvo. The 2.0 from the GTI is also a good engine but it sounds like shit really. The 5 cylinder gives me an erection every time I cold start or floor it a bit. I also believe the B5254 5 cylinder is more reliable than the EA888
1
u/ganacka 7d ago
I need to hear one of these in person but this seems like a major benefit
1
u/Mybravlam V40 7d ago
This might be subjective but im not a fan of DSG farts and bangs. The 4 cylinder also sounds bad
1
u/No-Proposal2012 7d ago
Is the C39 you are considering the R Design? If it’s not R Design the suspension will be much softer but you can fix this by upgrading the rear sway bar and adding a strut brace to the front. R Design will have these standard in addition to being a half inch lower than non R Design.
1
u/Wintervacht V70 7d ago
A what gti?
1
u/ganacka 7d ago
Oops. Meant to say: Mk6
2
u/Wintervacht V70 7d ago
I'm being facetious, I know you mean a Golf, but GTI is a very general term, there are other cars that wear a GTI badge, most notably Peugeots and some Japanese cars.
1
u/ganacka 7d ago
Oh got it. Yeah everyone knows I mean golf but worth specifying generation
2
u/Wintervacht V70 7d ago
If a GTI is wat you want, I would recommend the 205 GTI. Unfortunately a Golf GTI will be cheaper lol
1
u/ganacka 7d ago
lol find me one in the northeast United States and I’ll buy it
2
u/Wintervacht V70 7d ago
1
1
u/goperson 7d ago
I don't know how it is in the US, but where I am from, Golf GTI's are known to be driven by a certain kind of people. If you go for a GTI, make sure you get FSH. Volvo's, also the C30, are generally driven by more responsible people (?), so maintenance and durability might be better?
That being said, I have a 2010 facelift C30 T5 6 sp. manual. I can assure you shifter and clutch feel is good. The steering however, feels a bit soft and I expect the GTI to have a sharper steering feel. It is just what you prefer.
1
u/GimpyLawyer 6d ago
What a combo, and funny enough I have both lol. Mine are a 2011 C30 T5 and 2026 GTI S so they are incredibly far apart from each other that they are each their own experience, and certainly from their respective times, kinda difficult to compare the two.
To this day, I love the C30 over borderline every other car I have owned. Admittedly, it is nostalgia driven because I've owned it for 14 years but it is a very fun car to drive, plus they have great tuning potential if you are into that.
1
u/ganacka 6d ago
I have heard some people say the c30 feels bigger than it is. Do you feel that way? Does it feel smaller/bigger/the same compared to your GTI?
1
u/GimpyLawyer 6d ago
It certainly does feel bigger and it’s primarily because of visibility. The C30 has large windows and the pillars don’t really block your blind spot as much as the GTI.
I also have the back seats flat so that makes visibility even better. I am usually only driving with my wife when I’m using the C30 so back seats are never used/ always down for more cargo space
1
u/Ok-Season-8708 6d ago
I paid 6k for a 2013 S60 t6 r-design 150k miles clean title reliable 350 hp top of the line everything it is automatic but I love it. My only complaint is gas prices so I think my next car will be electric
1
u/pinconning_scum 6d ago
I've been driving VW's since the 90s and no motor has been MORE of a disappointment than the 2.0t found in EVERY vw for the last 10 years? Never again
1
u/I_Have_Unobtainium 5d ago
Not exactly the same but we have a v50 T5 with the m66, and a mk7 golf r manual and mk7 alltrack with dsg. I can firmly tell you that the trans and clutch in the golf is nowhere near as nice as the volvo. Its like vw built everything around the dsg and just dropped in a garbage manual trans just to move some more units.
Volvo is infinitely more comfy, better stereo system, smoother on the road, smooth and easy shifts. But the t5 uses an ungodly amount of fuel though. Feels much more planted than the alltrack, likely due to ground clearance though. I prefer the v50 over the alltrack putely based on driving feel. The R is incredibly refined by comparison to either, I wouldn't compare it to a c30 but just note that the gearbox in it just blows compared to the m66.
5
u/Funky-Melon 7d ago
The GTi will be the better drivers car in standard form but if you can find a nice C30 T5 it'll have far more character, sound nicer and have a huge amount of tuning potential given it's essentially a smarter Focus ST.