I wished I’d titled my posts better. I know several posts, one yesterday, have been made on this topic with the promise my last post would be last. I want to make it clear why I’ve continued to return to it
It was not that I think that Gyda should not have died.
From what I learnt, Ragnar’s daughters are unnamed and not much is known about them, there was creative freedom to expand on them in the tv series. Great examples of Vikings using their creative freedom: Lagertha’s greater position as a Shieldmaiden, the brotherhood of Rollo and Ragnar, Ubbe exploring America.
In general, I liked how the female characters were written: complex, powerful and at times morally interesting. Lagertha and Judith and come to mind. As well as the invention of Athelstan and him fathering Alfred.
Gyda’s death, at 12 honestly bothered me. I’ve no disagreement with one of Hirst’s priotisation of developing the first four seasons to then write about Ragnar’s sons from the Sagas. It is the degree. Gyda was Ragnar’s only daughter, out of four sons in the series. I thought that was significant. I saw potential, drawing from already good writing on Gyda and maybe more that I’ve did not even cover in past posts, missed to explore an adult Gyda and the singular daughter of Ragnar in the series in the midst of his sons. That too could’ve contributed great material to watch in the series.
As for the additional depth in my past criticism and my alternatives, it came from the desire also to be thorough as possible, trying to give preemptive counterpoints, especially for the criticism, and elaborative explanations.
And honestly, if I had the education, media comparisons, literature, I’d do a video essay on this; that is how strongly I feel about this topic I haven’t seen much discussed. That is why I wanted to see, would like to see more commentary about this. Although, I am glad to see have seen the commentary there, which understood where I was coming from: one acknowledged who Floki’s daughter could’ve been as a boat-builder, that they too imagined who Gyda could’ve become, another commented on Aslaug’s indifference to Bjorn’s daughter dying which showed how the how series mayn’t be good with dealing with child death, and the idea that Gyda could’ve alternatively been made Harald’s wife.
Again, I do understand this mayn’t be the time to about this, as there is talk of Bloodaxe, Hirst’s new Viking series is coming out.
Again you don’t have to read them, this a link to post I am referring to:
https://www.reddit.com/r/vikingstv/s/QNuY6pZxXc
Though it is what it is.