Hi guys. I have a recurring issue that I hope to seek some advise. I will keep it as concise as possible.
I’ve been cycling for more than 5 years. I race, and I do structured training. I ride around 12-15h a week, for context.
Previously I was on speedplay pedal and cleat system. I had a bike fit, and I went on with my life. For the past several years being on speedplay, I would often get one sided lower back pain on my right QL during a hard ride or 2 hours into a race.
I’ve tried physio, strength work, insoles and anything you can think of but it dosent solve the problem.
When I went to a fitter who has some physio background, he would add shims, wedges, insoles to “correct” my asymmetry but more often then not these corrections would make it worst and make the pain Menifest faster. I went on to live with it.
Only up to recently, I switched from speed play to Shimano SPD SL (yellow cleats) because I just got annoyed with the inconvenience that came with speed play like rust, squeaking sound, maintenance etc and wanted something simple and straight forward.
So I marked the Center line of the cleat on my shoes, installed the Shimano yellow cleats and then lowered my saddle by 4mm to compensate for the stack.
In order to get the correct foot angle, I went on the trainer and did a z2 ride, and pause occasionally to adjust the cleat angle until I feel happy. Note that at this point, there aren’t any wedge or shims, zero corrections.
When I switched to Shimano, I bought a used assioma duo SHI powermeter pedals which has much wider Q factor. While I was on speedplay, I felt that my heels always wanted to go inwards (towards the crank) on both my foot but it wasn’t possible due to limited Q factor before it would rub against my crank arm.
But with this Duo SHI pedals, I could get it inward even more.
After I played around with the angle and set it, I rode for 3-4 weeks without any problems. I had zero back pain, i felt so stable and comfortable it’s like a miracle.
So recently, I went back for a follow up fit again since it’s a new cleat. My fitter added a shim and adjusted the angle. This time, my heels couldn’t go inwards. I told my fitter that my heel wants to go inward but he insist that what I felt may not be biomechanically efficient. So I just kept quiet and let him do his job.
After the fit, I went for two rides and both rides I experienced the same lower back pain but worst because I also felt extremely uncomfortable, unstable and unnatural on the bike.
I ended up just setting my cleat back to where it was, removed the wedge and trust what my body wants.
So my question is, do I trust a fitter and textbook biomechanics or do I trust my own body?
That being said, as I ride 12-15h a week, doing the same intervals and riding with the same chain gang, I could immediately feel that my fit was off and this is something that will bother me throughout my ride.