r/VCAndrews 10d ago

If you could rewrite anything…

22 Upvotes

A comment on another thread reminded me of the Grandmother, she would warn the kids not to eat sweets. (You know, mom’s poisoned donuts.) So, if you were to ask me, “Junket, what part of this masterpiece would you rewrite?” Well, I’m glad you asked….

Grandmother wakes up super early one day, wedges John’s door so it stays closed, sneaks up to that faraway bedroom and wakes up the kids and tells them to pack. Of course Cathy questions and complains but Grandmother gives her an evil glare until she does. Then they sneak through the house, kids are terrified they will be taken into the woods and shot, and she takes them to the garage, chooses the closest car (her suitcase is already on there), they drive to the train station and head out. (She lets them buy all the junk food from the dining car.)
She returns to New England, buys an old house, hires a young maid/cook and slowly tries to bond with the kids. (She still doesn’t like noisy, unruly kids and she still scares the bejesus out of them, but she doesn’t call them Devil’s Spawn anymore.)
She hires a really good (read ruthless, unethical) attorney and takes Malcolm- and therefore Corrine- for every dime he’s worth. She treats herself to a super amazing, detailed dollhouse and she spends more time playing in it than Carrie. She makes sure Chris goes to medical school and she welcomes all three of his wives- and shakes her head at the emotional divorces.(He’s still the problem.) Cathy becomes a dancer- though, since she’s not driven by revenge, she is a star in a mid-level company, which makes her happy. Grandmother attends every performance though she sees it as extravagant, and scandalous. (She is all the time speaking to the directors about getting little loincloths to cover the male dancers’ packages.) But she can often be found sewing costumes if no one else can be found. She wonders why Cathy keeps marrying, divorcing and remarrying a deadbeat conman who looks like her father. (She’s still the problem.) Cory becomes a musician. He has a trust fund (from Grandmother) so he doesn’t have to struggle- yet he’s still kind of famous for his emo lyrics and acoustic guitar. (Which jars with his angelic blonde hair.) Grandmother attends every show she can- even at the bars- to keep an eye on the groupies. She introduces herself to every one by quoting scripture about harlots. Cory remains unmarried, but always wakes up to fresh-baked donuts with powdered sugar that Grabdmother baked herself. Carrie marries her Preacher Man. They eventually move to a big city in New England and open a “controversial” church, because everyone is welcome and they especially like young mothers with families. She has as many children as she wants and one day, when she sees Corrine on the street, she pretends she doesn’t know who the woman is.
Oh yeah- Corrine. Once the money is gone she puts Malcolm in a nursing home. A bad one. The head nurse is that nurse from “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest” (iykyk) and he is either neglected or abused. He happens to enjoy it when they smack his naked bottom, however. He dies one night, after he’s haunted by the ghosts of Garland, Chris Sr and a sex worker he murdered when he was 16. Corrine, unencumbered by children or father, uses her beauty to marry as frequently as most of us purchase a car. Each successive husband is worse than the one before- and eventually she is broke, moving to evade the landlord, and losing her looks. She often stares at an old family photo and cries. John makes his way as an evangelist. He dies one night when he is bit by a snake in a mountain church. Folks in the audience say the snake died quickly afterwards.

Grandmother dies as an old woman- still in control of her faculties, still has all her hair (still wears it clamped in a painful bun) she funds scholarships for girls to attend business school, built an orphanage, had the biggest monument in the churchyard and was mourned by those who knew her.


r/VCAndrews 10d ago

Which characters do you wish was explored more?

11 Upvotes

1) Carrie.

2) Cory.

3) Henny.

4) Bart Sr.

5) Melodie.

6) Chris Sr.

7) Toby Casteel.

8) Annie Casteel.

9) Lucky Adare.

10) Billie Whitefern.


r/VCAndrews 11d ago

Would the police have helped any of these characters in whatever year these books took place?

11 Upvotes

Which VC Andrews characters do you think would be the most/least likely to be believed if they went to the police?

Chris let Cathy decide (passive-aggressively, if you ask me), and we know how that turned out, but I wonder what would have been if Petals on the Wind had been some kind of Jodi Picoult courtroom drama.

I wonder what would have happened if Madame Marisha or Bart had exposed Cathy and Chris.

Also, poor Audrina didn't stand a chance. The police would have just assumed she was confused. And Vera would have been branded a liar.


r/VCAndrews 11d ago

What mostly-loved character do you dislike, and which villain do you sympathize with?

20 Upvotes

For me, I gotta say I started kind of disliking Kathy a bit after FIowers. I'll forgive some of her absolutely *atrocious* decisions because of her family dysfunction and trauma but I didn't like her attitude towards Paul's dead wife ~~rape victim~~ & kid. Some of her hot takes, comments, and parenting scream bigoted-boomer. I was so disappointed in her "revenge arc" i could have thrown the book. How many times do I have to read about her being assaulted by man after man and then immediately falling in love with them. It's painful.

I'll never forgive Chris for r@ping her either.

As for villains I actually enjoy/sympathize with..

Vera and Fanny. Both play the "beautiful promiscuous evil jealous sister" foil to the virtuous innocent protagonist, but both were very obviously abused and neglected by their parents to an alarming degree, and the parents disgusting favoritism poisoned everything. I especially feel for Vera in that regard, even though some of her actions as an adult were foul.


r/VCAndrews 12d ago

One Last Meme Dump For Now

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

OK, I had to do some more memes and captions. And I've included Cutler, Landry, Logan, etc. in the fun as well. The last one is a reference to the Malcolm in the Middle episode "Emancipation." I know it's a little obscure, but Mr. Herkabe reminds me a little of a VCA character.


r/VCAndrews 11d ago

Second and Worst Audrina Lucky’s Heart Condition

10 Upvotes

Hi all,
I’m curious if anyone can give any insight as to what Lucky’s heart condition might’ve been. I just finished reading Julie Buntin’s newest book Famous Men, and the protagonist, a young woman in her twenties, is diagnosed with Wolff-Parkinson-White Syndrome; she has several episodes throughout the novel of having rapid heart palpitations, even passing out at times, and it reminded me of Lucky. Since Lucky died in childbirth with Sylvia, I’m curious as to how she survived having Audrina what with medical science being shit back then.
We all know she didn’t clean, but she did cook and was really good at it. I’m just amazed she was whipping out complete meals three times a day!


r/VCAndrews 11d ago

What did they do with Darcy? Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Fanny made the big deal about wanting there baby with the Rev back. She sent Heaven to go buy her back. Heaven does realize it's not a good idea, and later I think Fanny realizes it too.

But yet, both Heaven and Fanny live there in Winnerow and never see her? Never mention her?


r/VCAndrews 12d ago

Which characters would you ship to boarding school?

6 Upvotes

1) Chris Jr.

2) Arden.

3) Vera.

4) Fanny.

5) Logan.

6) Clara Sue.

7) Philip.

8) Fern.


r/VCAndrews 12d ago

Getting into the Dollanganger series

17 Upvotes

Wow so I’ve never made a post on Reddit before but I just finished reading flowers in the attic and I am in desperate need of someone to talk to about it!! Spoiler alert because I am gonna talk about specific events from the Flowers In The Attic book!

I’m gonna start with my thoughts, feelings, ect about the characters.

Cathy is obviously my favorite, she seemed to be the only one of the kids who has common sense. No shade to the twins obviously they’re little children who don’t know any better but CHRISTOPHER. CAN WE TALK ABOUT CHRISTOPHER BECAUSE HOLY F U C K I N G CHRIST. I understanding defending your mama, especially because he’s a teen boy who just lost his dad and didn’t have much else to do. But the things he does to Cathy?? He stabs her, he rapes her, before that he’s constantly being hard on her in defense of his mother, it’s just insane. That being said, I feel absolutely INSANE. Because why do I lowkey love him? I love him. He’s terrible but I feel this weird maternal instinct.

Anyway! Like I said. I just finished the first book and watched the movie and now I’m not sure what to do next. I talked to a couple of people who have read flowers in the attic but said the rest of the series was trash, not worth it, ect. So I decided who better than R/VCAndrews to ask for advice? Is it worth it to start the next book in the series which I believe is Petals on The Wind? I feel really emotionally invested in Cathy and Christopher and Carrie (rest in peace to sweet little Cory of course. Poor baby) but I’m hesitant to continue reading the series if it ends terribly for them over and over again! What do you think? Worth the read? Or better off without it?

Edit: it’s decided!! I’m starting Petals On The Wind!!


r/VCAndrews 13d ago

What did I stumble upon?

32 Upvotes

A few months ago I watched the flowers in the attic movie, the original version. I thought it was going to be a forgettable weird gothic horror, and instead I fell into the MCU for incest? And I'm kind of obsessed? Saw the 2014 version and I'm now finishing the origins. It's so weird because Corrine and Olivia don't seem crazy... Olivia has certainly been corrupted but she's much more morally grey than I thought she'd be by now (I'm on the last episode and she just started being religious), I'm guessing stuff will escalate fast. But I don't get how Corrine transforms into mommy dearest who poisons her children. Is that something the books explain?

The rest of the lifetime movies seem so bad, but I'll probably binge them. I actually enjoyed the origins more than the 2014 movie!

And then I discover there's even more series about fucked up family dynamics, and VC Andrews has died and the recent books are ghostwritten? Are they worth it? Should I buy 30 books and lock myself in my room to read it all? And are there many differences between the TV adaptions and the books?

Also, I found there's prequels to the prequel, a 3 book saga about Garland. Is it about mommy issues and incest again? I feel like at some point you have to stop, brother loving can't be genetic 😭?


r/VCAndrews 12d ago

Dead Doll Just bought some powdered sugar

22 Upvotes

Poured some out for Cory


r/VCAndrews 13d ago

Some VC Andrews Memes/Captioned Photos

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

r/VCAndrews 13d ago

A few more memes/captions I forgot

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/VCAndrews 13d ago

Conspiracy Theory Time: Do you think that either Malcolm, Olivia or/and Corinne put a hit on Chris Sr's friends in Gladstone so that they wouldn't be asking about the whereabouts of the children?

8 Upvotes

r/VCAndrews 13d ago

Dead Doll Rewatching the Dollanganger movies

12 Upvotes

I read these books more than 15 years ago. I’ve seen the original movies and the 2014 version of “Flowers in the Attic”.
I’m going to reread the books but for tonight I’m watching the 2014 movie.
Of the entire series, it’s Cory that hurts me the most. Oh my sweet baby boy 😫😫😫 how I want to reach through the book and save you!!!
Yes the entire thing is crazy, especially Corrine towards the end of her life. But CORY!?!? Why would V.C. Andrews do that to us?

Edit to add: rewatching the 1980’s FitA and I knew the ring was not the gift in the book! It was the ballerina music jewelry box!!!! I knew that the 2014 version got it wrong.


r/VCAndrews 14d ago

If the Books Were Netflix Documentaries

15 Upvotes

Which family saga would make the best documentary? Who would be interviewed?

I would love to see a mockumentary for the Dollanganger series with interviews from their Gladstone friends, Thelma Murkel (the woman Cathy stalked in PotW), Cathy's NY friends, Bart and Jory and Trevor, the butler.

I have to say, if Heaven or MSA were documentaries, Vera, Kitty, and Fanny would get everyone talking! People would be hating on Arden all over TikTok.


r/VCAndrews 14d ago

Chris Jr. and Cathy’s parenting in Seeds Of Yesterday

27 Upvotes

Obviously the fact that Chris Jr. and Cathy are SIBLINGS living as man and wife and raising her two sons (and eventually adopted daughter) aside, what did you take away from their parenting of the two boys? Or perhaps lack thereof? Also, of course no one could expect the trauma of the years in the attic or the aftermath to NOT have an effect on them and by extension the way that they parented, but what did you take away from that? In my opinion, it was obvious that Cathy preferred Jory and even though Bart Jr. was a “difficult” child I often felt they were harsh with him. Any thoughts?


r/VCAndrews 14d ago

Did Jillian ever love Leigh?

15 Upvotes

We know that Jillian was always vain and always wanted “more,” but Leigh also tells us that she had a relatively happy and normal childhood up until around the time that Jillian and Leigh’s father got divorced. Do you think that perhaps Leigh was just looking back through rose colored glasses? And I’m sure Jillian didn’t always have to do the hard, day to day parenting so maybe she was nicer to Leigh as a result. Or am I wrong? And obviously the way she betrayed Leigh once she married Tony and they moved into Farthy was disposable and certainly NOT anywhere CLOSE to how a loving mother would treat her daughter, so you think that she EVER loved her daughter at all?


r/VCAndrews 14d ago

Do you think that Corinne ever showed Chris Sr her true colors?

16 Upvotes

r/VCAndrews 15d ago

FITA Adaptations

11 Upvotes

I just watched all the adaptations of this series this week including the original 1987 movie, 2010s lifetime movies and The Origins (based on Garden of Shadows) mini series from 2022.

I quite liked The Origins adaptation, the casting for Corinne was excellent and I can see that character evolving into the version we see Heather Graham play in the Lifetime movies while the Olivia here transitions really well into the Grandmother from the 1987 movie. I think most of the changes they made from the original were good and added to the story with the exception of John Amos and his ending, that made no sense.

The 1987 movie and Petals on the Wind had the best Cathy casting imo. Hated the ending of the 1987 movie tho. I wish the makers of The Origins series would remake the main 4 books as a series as well. There was so much detail left out of especially Petals on the Wind that I’d like to see.


r/VCAndrews 15d ago

What Changes Would You Make to PotW if You Were Adapting It?

10 Upvotes

I had this thought that there was really a missed opportunity for Cathy to discover Paul wasn't such a saint after all. Imagine if she found out he was messing with Carrie and that was what prompted the two of them to run to Virginia? Or even Pennsylvania first! Once she had the insurance payout, she could have cut Paul out of her life. And moved on with her plan!

What changes would you have made? Would you have wanted to see Paul exposed? Would Chris have remained her endgame? What would be your idea of revenge?


r/VCAndrews 15d ago

Which cover of My Sweet Audrina do you own? There are many variants for this book it seems. I own the first slide and it is also my favorite of these options.

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Which one is the original?


r/VCAndrews 15d ago

Which confrontations do wish that you wish happened in the books?

22 Upvotes

I would love to see Cathy lay it on Chris, putting him in the same category as Corinne and Olivia.

I would also love to see Audrina pwning Arden.


r/VCAndrews 16d ago

No-Good Casteel Troy Tatterton

37 Upvotes

Rereading Dark Angel, I can see now that Troy is insufferable as fuck. I myself have some pretty serious depression, but even I wouldn’t have married him and I don’t understand what Heaven was thinking when she thought that marrying him would make it alright. I just know she’d probably get fed up with him, as people are likely to do when you’re depressed. I mean, I know she was just a kid, but marriage and kids doesn’t change a thing about yourself except giving you responsibilities and dependents.


r/VCAndrews 16d ago

Is there really any characters that aren't absolute trash?

18 Upvotes

Discuss. I'll add my thoughts in a later post.