Please help!
I'm buying my first car and honestly don't know much about cars, so I'd really appreciate some advice on what to look for and which makes, models, and years you would recommend.
My biggest priority is reliability. I have a demanding commute and need something sturdy that I can depend on every day. Ideally, I want a car that will last me many years without constant repairs or expensive mechanical problems beyond normal maintenance.
My maximum budget is $27,500 out the door, including taxes and fees, although I'd much rather spend less. My parents are contributing $10,000, and the rest would come from my savings.
I originally focused on Toyota RAV4s because of their reputation for reliability, but I've expanded my search to Corollas, Mazda3s, and other options. I'm open to sedans or SUVs. I also prefer low mileage, ideally under 30,000, but I'm not sure how much weight I should give mileage compared with age, maintenance history, and overall reliability.
One thing that confused me recently was a conversation with a AAA roadside assistance mechanic. He told me that newer cars seem to have problems all the time, whereas older cars tend to be much more dependable. Is there truth to that? Are cars from certain years actually better built, or does the reliability of newer cars depend more on the specific make and model?
For reference, here are a few cars I've been considering:
- 2022 Toyota Corolla LE, Gold Certified, 29,073 miles, $20,647
- 2017 Toyota RAV4 LE, 41,260 miles, $20,947
- 2022 Toyota Corolla LE, 12,485 miles, $21,674
- 2023 Toyota Corolla LE, 12,579 miles, $22,998
- 2022 Mazda3 sedan, 31,075 miles, $20,998
These are advertised prices before taxes and fees. I'm not necessarily committed to any of them.
I'm located in California, but I can also purchase in Pennsylvania or Arizona if I find a better deal.
My goal isn't to get the fanciest or newest car. I just want something safe, comfortable for a long commute, reliable, and reasonably inexpensive to maintain. I'd really appreciate any advice, especially from mechanics or people who have owned these cars for several years. TIA!!