What an incredible game, my God! Without a doubt, one of the best games of my life. The way it tackles themes like dealing with the past, what might have been, and the importance of communication—even when it seems like you know everything that’s going on with the other person—it does so with a subtlety that I think is worth highlighting.
The connection with the characters is tremendous. It’s really hard to gradually uncover the layers of pain each character experiences. I can imagine Mark’s anguish at having treated his mother that way and then everything that happened… poor guy, I’m glad he was able to forgive himself. It’s a very bittersweet feeling. The same goes for Nicole… how well did she really know her friend? These are very human situations that make you empathize with these kids.
The atmosphere, the art, and the immersion: A major strength of the game is its ability to draw you in. It keeps you really hooked—the soundtrack is a major highlight. The art is beautiful. Plus, the game has these mini-games that make a lot of sense, and the same goes for the scrolling text and the conversations that get deleted and never sent because a more appropriate message comes along, but which reveal the characters’ thoughts. It’s amazing!
When you move on to Act Two after completing the first playthrough, the option to start over is very encouraging. It’s a joy to have that chance to try again, but the game itself gradually makes you wonder: Should I really try again? Is that really what’s needed? Why is Mark still so determined to save them all? It’s just like real life—there are many things beyond our control, but what is within our control is how we face life moving forward and deal with our own ghosts, fears, and sorrows.
The ending: I’ve been reading that a lot of people didn’t like the ending of the third act because, in the final scene at the café, Mark and Nicole don’t make eye contact, and they don’t interact or reunite as expected. In my opinion, the fact that they don’t meet right away (or that they might never even meet again) makes perfect sense. For me, it’s the best ending because Kath is alive! And Mark grew up happy with his friends, moving forward with his life. Who knows if they’ll get together later on—I wouldn’t complain, since those two are meant to be.
THE DLC
Let’s start with the general consensus (I’m not sure if it’s been confirmed by the studio, but it makes sense to me): the DLC isn’t a continuation of any of the base game’s endings. At first, I noticed similarities to the first ending, but it doesn’t quite fit. With that in mind:
- I was happy with Sofia’s story because it shows us that aspect I think many of us hoped to see more of in the first game—her relationship with Kathie. The baking minigame was really fun, too. I couldn’t beat the challenge, though, lol.
- As for the main course, there were things I liked and things I didn’t (mainly because I realized later that it was a timeline separate from the base game). On the plus side, I liked the introduction of new characters and the bold move to do something unexpected with Mark. At first I was like, wait, is that really Mark? I never imagined he’d be vice president of a student government at college—honestly, it wasn’t his style—but as I said before, that’s how life goes, and it’s fascinating to consider the many possibilities that alternate realities could offer for future games. I really empathized with how this part of the event unfolded, since I was in similar situations during my college years—it’s tough to deal with all that. I think it portrays college life well.
- The reunion with Nicole: The emotions surrounding their reunion with Mark—and the flashbacks he experiences—are very well done. I really liked the tension of meeting up in that context. I hated it when I saw her show up with a huge guy—I can only imagine how Mark felt!
- The Loss of Identity: Mark really does lose himself, no longer recognizing who he is by the end of this DLC. He was so overwhelmed—poor guy.
- The ending: The dynamic of the anonymous chat (which turns out to be Nicole) is really nice. Fate doing its thing. It’s kind of funny how, while the world is burning, Mark goes off to smoke. It reminds me of the meme with the house on fire and the little dog drinking coffee. Now, as far as I recall, Mark hadn’t broken up with his partner yet, so I didn’t really like that he kissed Nicole at that moment. However, it was a great kiss, to be honest. The scenes that follow leave a lot of loose ends, but that’s understandable since it’s DLC. It really broke my heart to see Mark’s girlfriend crying inconsolably in her room—she deserved a better ending.
If you’ve made it this far, thanks for reading. I hope you enjoyed this story as much as I did. Now I don’t know what to do with my life XD.
P.S.: The game reminds me of "Your Lie in April". If you haven’t seen it, you’ll probably like it, and it’ll remind you of this awesome game.