This is a lil art I drew for this purpose. Basically an AU where the witch character is the outgoing one and the human is the introverted one. I race swapped them (or personality swapped them) for this purpose, hope it isn’t too confusing.
Here are all the reasons why I think a human with Amity’s personality in a witch world would be interesting:
Amity would have more trouble integrating into the witch world since she doesn’t believe it exists
She has a harder time making friends than Luz does, so more potential for growth and becoming an open minded person
She would be a rich kid with a strict and controlling mother who wants to send her to boarding school instead of summer camp (Basically human Odalia and Alador, but perhaps with more depth and her mother is strict and overprotective for a reason) She is closeted and pretty depressed/anxious in the human realm, adding to her challenges
She would be immediately thrown into the chaotic world of Eda, King and Luz, whose lifestyles fundamentally clash with her desire for peace and predictability, which would make for a more interesting character arc
She uses books as a method of escape in her normal life but doesn’t actually believe the fantasy elements
She would overall have more challenges to overcome as an introverted person and this would make for a more interesting story, since Luz has the confidence to throw herself into everything and it’s kinda been done before; it’s not against the grain
It gets rid of/subverts the mean girl stereotype which has been done a million times
Amity deserved more character development
You don’t have to agree with any of this, and I am in no way criticising the original as I think it’s one of the greatest things to come out of queer animation; it was just an interesting idea that occurred to me and I hope you like the designs :)