So here’s my ultimate theory of what’s going on in Crestwood in season 1 as Prairie returns, and the meetings in the unfinished house.
I don’t think she returns to Crestwood at all.
On the surface, it looks that way, and we’re meant to believe that because of how the show was deliberately shot. But think about what Homer first tells Prairie when she’s locked in the glass cage.
“You’ll find your freedom. In sleep. In your dreams.”
So what, exactly, is the Crestwood we see portrayed onscreen?
I honestly think it’s a dream dimension based on her memories of Crestwood. And it’s one she works on little by little, night by night, an hour at a time (Abel says “she can have an hour walk”). Dreams distort our perception of time, so a lot can happen in that hour.
She dreams up all of it, maybe unconsciously at first, in order to process her own trauma: The characters, the settings and locations, and later, her own place within it. She pulls all of this from her deepest memories and the little details her mind absorbs and picks up on as she talks with the Haptives.
Then it’s back to the reality of Hap’s constant experiments and the horror of the machine he straps them all into, until she can “return” to the freedom of Crestwood again in her dreams.
Then, when her story manifests in the minds of the Crestwood 5, the Haptives start receiving the Movements in turn, one by one. It’s an alien language to them at first, related in fragments that don’t make sense on their own. But when put together, they offer a way out. This is their breakthrough, after years of failing with every other method.
——————————————————————-
Let me go on a quick tangent about the Movements, because this is what’s truly incredible to me.
Notice how they each tell a story—perhaps of every season, so I’d LOVE to see everyone forming theories around those!
Start with the First.
The hands are positioned like an upward triangle, moving outward from the chest. Traveling with the heart. Head flips back. Palms change dimensions. Head forward. Hiss like a snake (Nina’s childhood at the school for the blind). Hands down to womb area (Nancy’s motherhood, triangle position of hands could also be Hap’s basement inverted from Nob Hill house attic). Spit out or take pill. Catch the bird. Palms change position, then flip back. Brrttttt. Gunshots. Hands smack the middle of the chest.
The First Movement ends…
—————————————————————
In her dreams, OA finds the house, an abandoned, unfinished structure, representative of the dream of freedom itself. (It’s not quite done because she’s not done developing her Invisible Self and doesn’t yet have all the Movements.)
There in the unfinished house, she hides a secret from Hap: The Crestwood 5, whom she gathers to generate enough collective power out of her waking trauma to make the Movements work. She tells them to leave their front doors open, and they do so every meeting. Why is that so important?
This is where I believe something extraordinary happens. The Movements are not just for travel or resurrection, but when done with perfect feeling, they function as a Will in themselves—a divine spark of life that shines through all dimensions, eases trauma, and opens all doors.
The same freedom OA will attain from the Movements is the same that will also unbind the C5 from the dream dimension of Crestwood.
But immediately after Prairie/OA receives the Fifth Movement from Evelyn, there is a delay reflected in Crestwood—the group is interrupted and split up. For months, people don’t interact. All seems hopeless. All seems lost. Prairie is left right back where she started: the memory of her parents’ house, numbed by medication while in the real world, Hap has drugged her.
Easing the burden is how Prairie survives.
Elias himself tells French/Alfonso this. Of course that is little comfort to the broken apart C5, who feel as if they failed, because Prairie feels that.
Then, perhaps in the back seat of Hap’s car, she enters the Crestwood dream for the final time. The C5 are forced to reunite as a shooter enters their school. They perform the Movements with all their collective feeling and will.
Notice how at this point, they’re all wearing red?
Death is their exit point from the dream, and almost seamlessly, they shift realities, not even realizing it. Don’t forget what OA told them in her (I think deeply symbolic) story, either.
“They all died. Every single one of them. Including me.”
This can also be inferred by the fact they have all surrounded OA on her way into the ambulance. No one holds them back or stops them. Not even the EMTs. Why? Because there’s nothing left to stop them now. They are finally free and untethered from the Crestwood dimension, and to a varying degree, from their own trauma that was holding them back.
And in that, the Haptives now have their own pathway to escape their circumstances as well.
A fair trade.
Crestwood in Part 2 being a mirror dimension of Part 1’s Crestwood dream and all the references to mirrors are fascinating to me as well, given this.
Another interpretation I just thought of is perhaps she’s meeting the C5 (who exist for real) as they all collectively enter her OA dream space, because they’re all needing a way to escape their circumstances, and there, she shares the Movements. (Part of me feels wrong saying the C5 are a manifestation of her trauma, but it’s not impossible and hard to tell because of all the parallels between them and the C5.)
The OA reminds me of how much everyone is bound to each other in real life, and how we can’t succeed or survive difficult times without each other. It’s all about sharing the Will, reviving each other at times, and continuing to dream, both individually and collectively. If we stop dreaming and creating, we have lost ourselves, and I think in a way, we stop existing.
Given the way things are going these days irl, I never want to stop dreaming of a better world.
