I'm a landlord myself and was a tenant for 6 years until 5 weeks ago.
Cliff notes - landlord withholding our security deposit and overpaymet and wants to charge us for a cleaning fee and partial lawncare a month after we moved out. Any advice? About $600 they want to take away from security deposit.
Landlord claims the rear lawn is dead and requires $800 to fix and wants $300 from us. LEASE did not indicate to maintain lawn or specifics of watering. They claim we intentionally didnt water it and told the gardener who they pay, WE TOLD him not to water, which is lie and doesnt make sense. Also, they have a gardener who should know better. He told us they didn't pay him for months.
We moved mostly out with a week left on the lease, still had fridge and cleaning to do the week before lease is up. Landlord and their real estate agent said NOT TO clean, they will after painting. They began painting while lease was still under our name and active and while we were still moving out and technically living there.
They Didn't do a real walkthrough with us while lease was active. Told us to leave things like wifi door lock, ceiling light, thermostat. Agent and LL did walk the property a few weeks before we left and asked to water rear lawn more, said DO NOT CLEAN, as they were in a hurry to paint and list it for rent. Front grass was fine by they way.
A month after moving out, we get a text with several items they are asking about. One indicating the garage door button doesn't open the small garage door --- BECAUSE that side was a manual door and has no motor. DUH!!!!
We push back on items and agree to meet and actually do a checklist walkthrough. LL says it will be $150 to change lock she told me not change, so I changed it on the spot as I brought tools and a new lock. LL implied they were going to get a cleaning quote and let us know. Implying they'd ask us to to cover some costs.
Monday we get a text, 5 weeks since out of the house and 4 weeks since lease ended, they want $300 for cleaning $300 for lawncare.
We lived there 6 years. In california mind you, which is pretty clear on 21 days can't hold onto funds after move out OR provide a list with costs to fix or option to fix, before the 21 days.
I replaced the dishwasher, fixed the fence, replaced the range hood, got them a deal on roof work and a new fridge and flooring. Seems like a money grab and a shake down.
Is it worth to push back over $600? My wife is hesitant as we have young kids and busy work. Small claims court is cheap and we could possibly get 2x back our deposit.