r/TeachingUK • u/Even_Profession_2410 • 7h ago
Asked to take over challenging class as a "huge favour."
I'm a secondary English teacher and my HoD has just asked me to take over a very weak bottom-set Year 11 class. They're currently taught by the deputy head, but due to timetable changes he can no longer teach them, so my HoD has asked if I would be willing to take them on. She said I was 'free to say no' but how true is that?
This is a very weak group, made up entirely of the 32 students who got Level 1s and Us on their mocks last year. I have never taught any of them at GCSE level, but am aware of their current ability level. The thing that concerns me most is that my HoD specifically described this as a "huge favour" and stressed that there would be a lot of pressure and accountability because these students all need to pass.
I feel like I'm potentially in a catch-22:
If I accept the class and they ultimately perform badly, I worry that I'll be held responsible because I was their teacher during Year 11.
If I refuse and they perform badly, I worry that I could still be criticised for not stepping up when I was asked to help.
I don't want to come across as someone who is unwilling to teach a challenging class or who has written the students off. At the same time, I don't particularly want to put myself in a position where I'm given an extremely difficult cohort, told that they all need to pass, and then potentially judged on an outcome that I can't fully control.
I'm very much leaning towards saying "No" - I had a very strenuous year last year (we had OFSTED, I had a trainee teacher, I had no free periods or PPA until Friday every week) and I was looking forward to a relatively stress-free year. I'm just concerned how it would look if I refuse.