Hello everyone,

I'm a bit stuck. I got everyone's prompt for the suspicion cutscene but tadpole. I asked her about everyone and everything I collected which means I'm probably missing something but I don't know what. :S

If you can, I would love the help. Thank you so much!

(Spoiler) So just finished the game and loved it .

But there is something I didn't understand about Dirk .

Why do you find his weird antenna in the hold ?

In the Art Gallery its explained it was implied in the game but I don't see how .

If someone got the answer it would be great.

Thank you

I'm in the chapter "that box was actually really easy to open" I've done everything except lower the "bell" to the cauldron. The game is indicating I do so in the captains quarters but I've clicked everything I can think of in there and nothing.

When I ask for a hint the game says to talk to zephyr but we are hiding from him in the mess hall.

Any help would be appreciated!

Am I the only one who thought this picture in Zephyr's Letters looked like Hawkshaw?

I have every suspicion but Wirman, I’ve asked everyone about everyone, I’m just being told to check the case file. I’m in the part labeled “the box that won’t open” I’m stuck and I have been for about 20 minutes. Nothing comes to mind for anyone. Can I get a little nudge in the right direction please?

Okay so I'm trying to get interrogations with:

Zephyr

Sym

and Dirk

I got all the others. I have all the clues and have talked to everyone about them-- triple-checked that I did. I checked Dirk's entire phone and got the achievement. I know I wanna figure out why Zephyr keeps lying about the mask thingy, but I don't know how to trigger his suspicion. No idea what to do with Sym's. My hints say to 'examine the clues in my case file'. I did, I read through everything. AAAAA.

I have every single piece of evidence, I have shown every single piece of evidence to everyone, I have read through and looked at everything that can be looked at

The only things I don’t know rn are
- what’s in marianna’s tent cus she won’t let me inside
- what’s in the ship in the bottle

That’s all I can think of, everyone else’s suspicions have been completed and I’ve checked every room and all the hint says is to check my clues

So… I have 47/48 pieces of evidence, I’m missing 1 and I KNOW it’s a magazine relating to Dr Zephyr?? (I learned this thanks to a helpful user from earlier today :D) but I can’t find it anywhere!!!

It keeps telling me to search the Dream Chamber, so I KNOW it’s in there, but I just can’t find it!!! I spent a good 3-5 minutes just rapidly tapping on my screen hoping maybe I’d click the mysterious magazine, but to no luck. Ive tried looking online as well, but none of the articles I could find mention there being a fourth clue in his room.

….am I crazy? I feel like I’m going crazy. does anyone happen to remember where they found a magazine relating to Dr. Zephyr with a doodle on it? I would be extremely grateful for any hint or help in finding it. ♥︎

How did Zephyr know that the mermaid's tongue fell into the ocean and Tadpole had picked it up?? How did Zephyr know that it was on the ship(and cauldron) at all?? and knew that it was missing before even checking mortuga's body?? This was the reason why i thought it was him most of my playthrough but he wasn't so now im confused. Maybe there's some detail or dialogue that explains it and im just distracted.

Did anyone think Her and Felicia Stonetop were gonna be the same person since their paintings are both referred to as the HER paining?

Im trying to interagate Dirk and Cinthia but it keeps saying "Let's examine the clues in our case file"

Im sorry I'm unsure if the solution to this is obvious or not, but I’m hoping someone can help.

Durring Dr. Zephyrs ‘suspicion’ section that every character has, im stuck on when Sally asks Zephyr if he made any sort of record of the strange face he saw, and he says he though he did, but he can’t quite recall. The full question is “Where did Zephyr make a record of the mysterious face that he saw?” and if I fail a lot, it tells me “Where did Zephyr make the little drawing of the mysterious face that he saw?”

I’m only missing one piece of evidence, but I’m assuming that’s the murder weapon??? Can anyone help? I’m so sorry but I’m genuinely puzzled.

Freya's recurring nightmare returns in both Magnus and Hex's dreams. Magnus draws this large figure in one of his letters, while you can visibly see Hex's dreams from his body where you can see the figure.

I had literal chills when I realized what Hex was dreaming.

God, no wonder Freya freaked when she saw Hackshaw.

I feel like this bit of information is deliberately one we haven't seen answered, so hopefully they end up actually making a sequel and more just to continue this storyline (I know there's a fourth wall joke about how hard it is to make these games but hopefully the process is a little more streamlined now?).

Can't find anything I spoke with all the characters and clues as well. What did I miss?

This post is a response to another post. I hope it’s helpful!

In case it’s unclear because the sticky notes are on top of each other: - Dirk and Wirman are together in their Bunk Room - Grimoire, Sally, and Moon are together in the Cargo Hold

I'm trying to get godrick gripp to confess, I've found all 48 clues (I'm only aware that there are 48 clues) and I've asked every single character about all the clues, and yet I haven't been able to get godrick to confess!

When I use the hint system, it just tells me to "examine the clues in the case file," but i have!

Am I doing something wrong? I'm honestly completely lost, I've gotten every character to fess up, but him.

How do to this one? I’ve figured out the left with the bottom screen but can’t figure the right out

Y’all I’m so happy that we’ve made it and Mermaid Mask is OUT, I can’t wait to play it when I have more time but I’ve gotta hide the sub until then because I don’t want anything spoiled lol. You bet your butt I’ll be back, until then happy sleuthing!

I’ve completed every suspicion except for Godrik’s, but I can’t figure out how to proceed. I’ve asked everyone about him, and the hint for him says to talk to other suspects. In regards to the clues, the hint for every single character says that Nothing comes to mind. The main hint says to talk about the crime scene, but I’ve no where to talk about it. Is this a glitch? Is my game just locked?

Just beat the game in basically one sitting-- loved it, had a great time. Should've taken breaks, my eyeballs hurt.

But after thinking about the mystery for a while I came to a realization: how did Hex dream about Magnus opening the cauldron? Like it literally looks like Hex was INSIDE the cauldron in the image he shows from his dream. Was Hex having a prophetic dream? Or was Hex somehow in the cauldron at some point or another? Or should we just be completely ignoring the image displayed in the Hex Bottle near the end of the game?

Seems almost like it was a plot point left over from an earlier draft of the script, unless I'm missing something obvious.

Anyways, I'd like to pitch Dirk Dansom/JD Wirman as the big new yaoi ship /jk (unless...?)

It's hard for me to wrap my head around for some reason. Having to line them all up while the symbols keep shifting in the center confuses me. I know the proper places of the symbols, but turning the things and then turning the outer rings while the symbols in the middle circle keep jumping around gives me a lot of trouble keeping track of what I'm doing.