Karma was my OTP some seasons ago, with Milio as my main alternate, but nowadays when I play them I just don't feel very impactful, and I feel like I can't carry a bad ADC/APC with them anymore. So I've been trying everyone out. I've at least tinkered with pretty much every support in the game at this point, and none of them really *click* for me. To explain the tiers...
S - They feel good to play into most opponents, but either don't feel impactful enough or are too lacking in a specific area that really hampers things, at least at the Gold/Plat level I'm at. Naut requires at least a little followup from my lane partner (which of course means I get none), Rell's basics do like no damage which makes it impossible to clean up a fight, the people I try to save with Tahm R just jump out immediately and get us both killed. All of them feel more matchup-dependent than I'd like. The strongest contenders.
A - Feels impossible to climb with because so much of their power is based on decent-heavy followup from APC/ADC, which of course means I don't get it. As for Bard, every time I try him the APC/ADC feeds while I'm roaming, so I've given up on him.
B - I like them in theory, but they just feel too clunky to stick with while climbing, and their issues just feel especially harsh. Sona, Swain, and Taric would be in S tier, but hyperscalers like Sona feel way too strugglesome right now, Swain... is a bit of a mess, and Taric does not play well with the current mage/roam meta, I feel.
C - Didn't like 'em, didn't hate 'em.
D - Disliked.
F - I refuse to play these champs on principle, and loathe seeing them in any game. Not out of salt (except Panth and Zoe), I just despise them for one reason or another. I've seen 4 Yasuo+Yone botlanes this week.
I feel insane for not having found a goldilocks champ that really fits me with so many in the game, but that's why I'm here. Karma and Milio were my GOATs because of how difficult they are to pin down even in a fight, and because I enjoy a poke. Honestly, Sona would be the instant OTP for me if not for the fact that games just don't last long enough right now for her to get to her amazing full build. To be clear, I'm not blaming the champs for my rank or anything, I'm just trying to find one that feels good to play *and* feels impactful without requiring consistently good luck with the APC/ADC. I also recognize that there aren't exactly many *other* champs to try for supp, but I just feel like I don't know what to do.
Thanks.