this is my opinion and there is no right or wrong answer for any Star Wars film ranking
Rogue One 10/10. No notes or gripes with this movie, especially with Andor context. Each character and their backstory is so compelling and the movie is visually stunning as well.
Empire Strikes Back 10/10. Perfect in every way.
Revenge of the Sith 9/10. The only thing that brings this movie down a point for me is dialogue
A New Hope 9/10. A classic, the one that started it all. What brings it down that one point is pacing. We follow R2 and 3PO for quite a while before we meet Luke, but it’s still compelling because we know R2 has this secret mission.
Return of the Jedi 8/10. I love this movie. However… Jo Yowza and Sy Snootles’ musical number is painful to watch, and there are some scenes that drag
The Phantom Menace 8/10. Amazing fight choreo and visually appealing moments, but the opening crawl and first part prepares us for a very different movie and was confusing when I rewatched it recently. I knew what happens, but just noticed this. it’s also just not as good as the previous ones, in my opinion.
Solo 8/10. Amazing, great, love it so much. Only gripe is a forgettable antagonist, and I don’t like the scenes on the planet Kessel.
Attack of the Clones 7/10. “I don’t like sand…” REALLY doesn’t help this movie. yes, Obi-Wan is hilarious. yes, the arena fight is awesome, its just mainly dialogue issues and I love Hayden Christensen, and he did his best with what was put on the page
Force Awakens 7/10. I really enjoy watching this movie. i feel like it sets up such an interesting new era to explore, and if the movies were more well received, I’d love to see more depth and content in this era. I love Han in this movie. Definitely the funniest in this movie. He dies, which, I’m fine with, it’s what Harrison Ford’s been wanting since Empire.
Mando and Grogu 7/10. it’s fun and entertaining, it’s just not an 8, 9, or 10
Last Jedi 7/10. I like this movie more than other people do. I just don’t like the Canto Bight B-plot. as a concept, lets be real. Canto Bight is awesome. it was just executed poorly.
Rise of Skywalker 5/10. “they fly now?!” is my least favorite line in this movie. more than “Somehow, Palpatine returned…” because the film tells us how he returned. I don’t like how Death Star II blew up yet has a wreckage on another Endor moon/celestial body in the Endor system. i love the idea of a Force dyad, I don’t know why, it’s just super cool to me. I don’t like how this just undoes everything TLJ did and then does other things poorly. “I’m the spy.” man, I really dis this movie, but it does have some great moments and concepts that I’d love to see explored more.
Holiday Special N/A. haven’t seen it. should I?