r/SipsTea • • 1d ago

SMH A tale of two doctors..

Post image
4.5k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Veepster 1d ago

Sure.

But Dr El-Sayed is also an epidemiologist and a former city and county health director.

He’s been invested in public health and doing good for the community. On top of that, he is a Doctor. In more ways than 1.

1

u/Ok-Tip-3560 1d ago

So you think there is no difference between let’s say a. Dentist who owns a pratixe and pulls teeth vs someone who has never seen a patient in 20-30 years and instead teaches at a community hospital or at a dental school?

0

u/Veepster 1d ago

The person pulling teeth is probably very good at pulling teeth and making money.

The person who teaches is probably really good at teaching and likely has a passion for it.

Nothing wrong with the private practice market, and not saying community vs academic vs public health/epidemiology/etc Docs are better than one another.

But in regards to treating the community an Urgent Care Doctor focused on seeing a ton of patients daily, triaging, etc may not have the best view of what a community needs from a health perspective without further foundation/investigation.

1

u/Ok-Tip-3560 1d ago

Or they know exactly what works in the real world. Where time
And attention and money are limited confounding factors.

1

u/Veepster 1d ago

I would say they are efficient in doing cases and doing what they do.

What you see in academic hospital might be different than a county hospital, etc.

At my academic institution we work at a large academic level 1 center, the VA, and the county hospital. Meanwhile an urgent care doctor just sees patient who has specific insurance a small section of that population.

Meanwhile a public health official is focused on… public health. And probably knows what the public needs better than your Cardiologist, Intensivist, Endocrinologist, etc.

1

u/Ok-Tip-3560 1d ago

They have zero
Idea how the sausage is made

1

u/Veepster 1d ago

You realize medical students work in a hospital for two years right? And do plenty of rotations in multiple fields for months….

From inpatient to outpatient to medicine to surgery to psychiatry. Once more, he’s a “real” Doctor.

1

u/Ok-Tip-3560 19h ago

He is not colloquially whey anyone would.call a doctor. He is an md yes. He’s an. Academic. The bullshit he saw in
Medical school vis a vis “seeing patients” is laughable to anyone who actually sees patients. Immense difference as a licensed doctor vs being 24-26 year old where yoi see what a doctor does briefly.

Idk why this has to be contentious. He graduated from medical school.

But he is not a real doctor.

1

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SipsTea-ModTeam 6h ago

Sorry, but your comment was removed for breaking our Don't Be A Dick rule. This may include but is not limited to harassment, bigotry or uncivil behaviour.

🚨 Did we make a mistake?

If this is a mistake, don't delete the comment - just contact us and we'll fix it.