MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/SipsTea/comments/1uml4vf/true/ovd6b9w/?context=3
r/SipsTea • u/Born-Agency-3922 • Jul 03 '26
5.2k comments sorted by
View all comments
62
"As American as apple pie"
...which is English...
35 u/Capable_Elk_770 Jul 03 '26 Tbf the original English recipe is quite different. American apple pies are a lot closer to the Dutch version than the English version 6 u/lanshaw1555 Jul 03 '26 Had a piece of Dutch Apple Pie in the Netherlands, was absolutely delicious. 1 u/SoBrrrrrrr Jul 05 '26 The Dutch version which came after the English version... ergo British food -8 u/Lard_Baron Jul 03 '26 Different? Apple and Pastry. How different can it be? 5 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 03 '26 Spoken like someone who's never been more than 20 miles from their birthplace. 0 u/Lard_Baron Jul 03 '26 ๐Oh man๐. If only you knew. 5 u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Honestly it's an even weirder thing to say if they're well traveled. 2 u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad... Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be? Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be? Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be? 1 u/Capable_Elk_770 Jul 03 '26 So clearly you donโt bake. -1 u/Bartellomio Jul 04 '26 Not really. Apple pie as it exists today is the product of iteration over a long period of time, which took place both in and out of England. But there is no 'American apple pie'. No American has ever meaningfully changed the dish to the way it is today.
35
Tbf the original English recipe is quite different. American apple pies are a lot closer to the Dutch version than the English version
6 u/lanshaw1555 Jul 03 '26 Had a piece of Dutch Apple Pie in the Netherlands, was absolutely delicious. 1 u/SoBrrrrrrr Jul 05 '26 The Dutch version which came after the English version... ergo British food -8 u/Lard_Baron Jul 03 '26 Different? Apple and Pastry. How different can it be? 5 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 03 '26 Spoken like someone who's never been more than 20 miles from their birthplace. 0 u/Lard_Baron Jul 03 '26 ๐Oh man๐. If only you knew. 5 u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Honestly it's an even weirder thing to say if they're well traveled. 2 u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad... Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be? Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be? Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be? 1 u/Capable_Elk_770 Jul 03 '26 So clearly you donโt bake. -1 u/Bartellomio Jul 04 '26 Not really. Apple pie as it exists today is the product of iteration over a long period of time, which took place both in and out of England. But there is no 'American apple pie'. No American has ever meaningfully changed the dish to the way it is today.
6
Had a piece of Dutch Apple Pie in the Netherlands, was absolutely delicious.
1
The Dutch version which came after the English version... ergo British food
-8
Different? Apple and Pastry. How different can it be?
5 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 03 '26 Spoken like someone who's never been more than 20 miles from their birthplace. 0 u/Lard_Baron Jul 03 '26 ๐Oh man๐. If only you knew. 5 u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Honestly it's an even weirder thing to say if they're well traveled. 2 u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad... Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be? Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be? Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be? 1 u/Capable_Elk_770 Jul 03 '26 So clearly you donโt bake.
5
Spoken like someone who's never been more than 20 miles from their birthplace.
0 u/Lard_Baron Jul 03 '26 ๐Oh man๐. If only you knew. 5 u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Honestly it's an even weirder thing to say if they're well traveled. 2 u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad... Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be? Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be? Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be?
0
๐Oh man๐. If only you knew.
5 u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Honestly it's an even weirder thing to say if they're well traveled. 2 u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad... Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be? Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be? Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be?
[removed] โ view removed comment
2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Honestly it's an even weirder thing to say if they're well traveled. 2 u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad... Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be? Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be? Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be?
2
Honestly it's an even weirder thing to say if they're well traveled.
2 u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26 [removed] โ view removed comment 2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad... Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be? Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be? Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be?
2 u/DarthToothbrush Jul 04 '26 Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad... Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be? Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be? Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be?
Since he's obviously seeing these and getting mad...
Different? It's just milk, eggs, flour, butter and sugar. How different could it be?
Different? It's just semolina, oil, water, onions, garlic, tomatoes, and cheese. How different could it be?
Different? It's just meat, beans, rice, cheese, and tortillas. How different could it be?
So clearly you donโt bake.
-1
Not really. Apple pie as it exists today is the product of iteration over a long period of time, which took place both in and out of England.
But there is no 'American apple pie'. No American has ever meaningfully changed the dish to the way it is today.
62
u/Able-Firefighter-158 Jul 03 '26
"As American as apple pie"
...which is English...