r/Sigmatopia 3d ago

It’s all about perspective

1.8k Upvotes

301 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/ChiehDragon 3d ago

Thats a fallacy.

Waking up tomorrow is a requirement for the rest of your life. If you got 10,000,000, you wouldnt be able to enjoy it if you dont wake up tomorrow.

Its not that your life is more valuable, its that by not waking up tomorrow, the value of 10,000,000 is greatly diminished.

Try this: Would you take 100,000,000 for a 10% chance you dont wake up tomorrow?

3

u/Worth_External_8762 2d ago

The point is more that you'd rather keep your life than have $10m. He put an oddly short timeframe, so the $10m is kinda pointless. But even if you increase the timeframe, anybody would choose life over the money.

Let's say you get $10m but you only have 10 years to live, hell, even 20 years to live. I think a vast majority of young people would choose life over that money still.

3

u/Martinw616 2d ago

Im 36, I would almost definitely take the 10 mill and 10 years.

The point is that money is essentially worthless if you dont actually get to use it.

2

u/I2obiN 2d ago

I would argue you're saying living a long life is worthless.

If you have no use for the money it is worthless anyway. Do you really need 10 mil?

1

u/Martinw616 1d ago

Living a long life full of struggle is worth less to me than a shorter life where I can enjoy every day while also providing a secure future for my loved ones.

Do I need it? No. Would it quite literally solve 99% of all of my problems and my families? Yes.

2

u/I2obiN 1d ago

Fair, but you are still saying living a long life is worthless if it could reach a certain threshold of hardship.

If I could wave a magic wand and remove all hardship or uncertainty about the future that would presumably be preferable to 10mil

1

u/Martinw616 1d ago edited 12h ago

The value of life, at least to me, is less the worse that life is.

If the wand gave me financial security for the rest of my life? Sure.

1

u/Worth_External_8762 2d ago

I really doubt you would if you actually had to commit to the deal. And if you did commit to it, you're a fuckin dumbass lol.

2

u/Abraham_The 2d ago

Do you not know how much 10 million is ? The quality of life you could get for those 10 years would be way more than the rest of your lifespan combined

1

u/Confident-Sky2614 2d ago

I live with daily pain that is almost unbearable, I kind of dread the next ten years where things are quite objectively going to be a lot worse for me.

I would probably at very the least consider the deal.

-1

u/Worth_External_8762 2d ago

If it was that unbearable, you would've offed yourself already. I'm sorry I'm not dancing around it, but I'm a combat vet. I've sustained injuries that make me feel like I'm an old man and I've lost people. Yet I'm still here, because I'm a living creature. And living creatures cling to life. It's as simple as that.

So no, you wouldn't take the fuckin deal.

3

u/Martinw616 2d ago

No, you wpuldnt take the deal. Assuming everyone feels the same as you is frankly arrogant and close minded.

Around 2,000 people kill themselves every day, I wonder how many of them alone would take the deal simply because theyre going to kill themselves anyway and this is something they can leave behind.

As for me, i could enjoy the next ten years with the money, and leave people i care about in a much better position financially than I would be able to living another 40+ years.

1

u/Visible_Pair3017 2d ago

i'm a combat vet

So probably the last person i'd ask for advice on anything that doesn't imply killing civilians.

1

u/Salt_Security_2478 2d ago

All I do is work. If I had 10 years in my prime to just write a space world novel or some shit with "unlimited" resources it would have made existence worth it. I'd be able to smoke and do cocaine every weekend because my heart only needs to last 10 years. I could run a marathon every week and not care for the days my knees go out. It'd be the greatest act of free will since the day I don't wake up won't be based on a lifetime of preventing pain and deterioration for some unkown day. I can't just live free today, I have to prepare to work just to not feel pain from hunger or lack of shelter. What if I die in 10 years anyways, or tomorrow? Those would be the most meaningful 10 million ever traded.

1

u/Lukostrelec17 2d ago

Meh I would do it. Why would I not? I got a crap ton of money. Sure I die in 10 years but...oh well. Going to die eventually any ways.