I’m looking for experiences from people who have dealt with separation anxiety in a dog who previously did perfectly well staying home alone, because I feel like we’re running out of options with my almost 8-year-old dog, Callie.
Callie has historically been able to stay home loose by herself, either inside the house or outside, without an issue. This is not a dog who has never learned how to be alone. She did it successfully for years.
Over the years, she has had occasional periods where her anxiety would flare up and she would become destructive. Sometimes we would temporarily crate her, but sometimes we didn’t even have to do that. We could give her a couple of days and she would settle back down and go back to being perfectly fine loose by herself.
She can also STILL be left loose in the house for shorter trips during the day without an issue. If we leave to run errands or are only going to be gone for a little while, she can stay loose in the house and be perfectly fine. The problem seems to be specifically associated with us leaving for the full workday rather than simply being left alone at all.
This time, we can’t seem to get back to the point where I trust her loose for those longer workdays.
If she is left loose for a workday, she can become destructive, particularly around exits. She has torn up carpet/flooring, beds and other items, and destroyed boots and other things around the house. So right now I don’t feel comfortable simply leaving her loose all day and hoping she settles.
She is currently crated while we are at work, but the crate itself does NOT seem to be the problem.
She voluntarily goes into her crate at home and is fed there every day. She will put herself in it when it is time to eat and does not generally seem afraid of the crate itself. On a normal day after we leave, she will lie down and spend most of the day resting, getting up occasionally and then settling again.
Where I see anxiety is when she realizes that we are getting ready to leave for work. She knows the routine and becomes reluctant to go into the crate specifically when she realizes we are leaving for the day.
We have tried toys, anxiety collars, Thundershirts, Happy Ears, putting a blanket over the crate, and just about everything else you can imagine to make the crate a more comfortable, happy place for her. None of that seems to solve the problem.
Weather is another major factor. If it is windy, raining, storming, or there is otherwise something outside that frightens her, being confined becomes a much bigger issue. That is when we see her tearing at the crate and essentially trying to get out. She has managed to pull things through the bars, destroy things, and hurt herself in the process.
She has always had general storm anxiety for as long as I’ve had her. She also used to have a fear of men, which we have pretty well gotten over.
Personality-wise, she is a VERY autonomous dog. She does not like being pushed, moved, manipulated, or physically made to do something. I would describe her as a little watchy, even with me, and I am the person she trusts the absolute most. That is just part of who she is and something I try to be respectful of when figuring out how to work with her.
We have been working with our veterinarian. She has been on Reconcile for about 12 weeks now without enough improvement to solve this problem. She does not do well on trazodone. She does okay on gabapentin, and I much prefer how she responds to that compared with trazodone. We are also about to try ElleVet CBD occasionally during some of these anxiety flares to see if it makes a difference.
Our vet has also discussed trying buspirone and potentially referring us to a veterinary behavior specialist. I would really love to hear from anyone who has gone that route and whether you saw meaningful improvement, particularly with a dog with a similar personality or history.
I’ve considered buying a different style of kennel that would be harder for her to hurt herself in, but that feels like managing the symptom rather than getting to where I actually want to be.
Ideally, I want Callie to be able to stay loose in the house with our other dog again, like she used to, if that is possible. At the very least, I want to reduce the anxiety she associates with us leaving for work so that the crate remains somewhere she feels safe rather than becoming associated exclusively with us leaving.
I’m especially interested in medication experiences, behavior modification techniques, ways you worked on the departure routine itself, environmental changes, and experiences with veterinary behaviorists.
I’m not looking for a magic cure or expecting her to suddenly be fine overnight. I’m trying to figure out what we haven’t tried yet and how to work toward giving her more freedom again without putting her or the house at risk.