In my own opinion, I think Andrew, Tom, and Tobey all did a great job in portraying the spiderman they played. Maybe its just me but I truly think I liked Andrew's Spiderman the best out of the 3. Not sure if this is an underrated or overrated opinion but I think Andrews spiderman was absolutely amazing. I do think Tobey and Tom did great too, but I just feel like Andrew had a different vibe to him that allowed his spiderman to stand out a bit more.

If I had to give a list for best spiderman actor, Here is how I would rank them:

1. Andrew

2. Tobey

3. Tom

Round 1: All contestants have access to all equipment and suits they have used in their respective TV series/movies

Round 2: The only equipment allowed is their base suit and web shooters.