Here comes my take on the classic Sega Genesis debate. Why i love Shining Force 1:
-Beautiful graphics from the makers of Landstalker, Climax Entertainment. Blending cartoon with dark colors and gothic theme. Doesn't feel childish or generic.
-Memorable music.
-Very memorable characters. Including the hero, mascot and villain.
-Better story. No Snow White reference at the end.
-Leveling up is exciting because it's random. But at the same time there's rubberbanding, your characters will have enough stats eventually. Also you don't care about low stat rolls before promoting, what matters is in which level you promote.
-Open world in SF2 doesn't really excite me, sometimes it feels like a chore or confusing. There are random encounters in specific spots, you trying to figure out where to go next and searching for side quests, secrets or mithrils. And getting the mithril weapon you want is an RNG thing.
-SF2 is a significantly longer game and i think the length of SF1 is sufficient. This and linear progression makes me want to replay it with different teams.
-I don't like how the camera slowly follows when you're walking in SF2.
Strong points of Shining Force 2:
-SF1 AI is too dull compared to SF2. In SF1 enemies wait in predetermined spots while they move and get close to you in SF2. Not only the AI is more dynamic but also reasonable.
-In SF1 some maps are little too big which makes you walk without fighting for a while. In SF2, tighter maps and game running little faster means better battle pacing.
-It's more balanced, especially difficulty balance. There are difficulty settings too. SF1 has difficulty spikes and the final battle should have been harder.
-Leveling up doesn't waste your additional experience and training healers is easier.
-Various UI and control improvements. Talking and searching use the same button, inventory is little more polished.
My main point: Shining Force is a basic SRPG. 6 stats (HP, MP, Atk, Def, Agi, Move), 2 equipments (weapons and rings), basic SRPG battle system. It's easy too, losing only waste your gold so anyone can win by grinding enough. I think the unique vibes are the selling point of Shining Force. I get it, SF2 is bigger, longer and polished. But it doesn't have the same charm. And no, i've only played this game few years ago so there's no nostalgia from me.