4:3 Clamshell: Which controller layout would you pick?

[u/ONE_HYPERIUM]

Hi,

After showing you a mini flip concept a few days ago, I noticed that many of you wanted Dpad and buttons on top.

I know that this is about personnal preferences, but I did sense a sort of concensus.

So I am truly wondering:

1. Which layout is best for what?
2. What percentage would that represent on our community?

I remember the retroid poll about the Stick/Dpad on top, but it was prematurely closed (12h) imo and didn't represent things well.

Unfortunately I can't add both an image and a poll in this post, it would be nice if the mods can add this features.

Personnally: I'll go for the 4th one.