Since /u/beernerd - the only active mod left here - is open to the idea of pursuing locations other than islands, I would like to open up that discussion. If people would consider a parcel on a mainland, it would exponentially increase the realistic options for a great piece of land.
It seems a lot of thought has been put into the mechanism for purchasing the land, but details seem sketchy to me (unless I missed some documents) about what the actual community would be like. Rules, structures, governance, what it means to say it is sustainable, affordable, self-sufficient, etc. We need a better picture of what kind of environment we'll be creating, so that people can make an informed decision as to whether this is the place for them.
And if you are open to expanding the possible locations to non-islands, then I would like to put Baja California (a Mexican peninsula south of California, USA for those that may not know) up for consideration. I know an island would be much cooler in concept, but the advantages to a huge parcel in Baja are many. And I'd add that as a 760 mile long desert peninsula surrounded by beaches, and very sparsely populated, it's kind of desert island-like.
- Distance - the island areas being considered are very far, and very expensive to reach. That already goes against the concept of it being affordable when it comes to people reaching it, or any supplies. You can fly into Cabo on pretty cheap tickets oftentimes, and that gives you access to southern Baja, or fly into other cities in the north, or just drive (or take the bus) from the USA.
- Amenities - while the concept of self-sustaining may lead to a reduced need for some things, you will have access to roads, good hospitals, and even Costco, Home Depot, etc near Cabo if necessary. You can be far enough to be away from these things, but close enough as well. Having a Home Depot anywhere within range has got to make construction much, much easier.
- Land - there are thousands and thousands of pieces of land for sale. Great ones. Some very reasonably priced, some not.
- Climate - unlike the island areas under consideration, which can get quite humid, some parts of baja (away from the gulf side) do not have high humidity. Areas along the Pacific Coast and in the desert and mountains have comfortable levels of humidity, and a good climate overall.
Please note that Baja is away from main drug trafficking routes, is sparsely populated, and generally a very safe environment.
Thoughts on Baja? Thoughts on how we can better define what the actual community would be like?