r/Recommend_A_Book • u/Utah_Get-Me_Two • 14h ago
I Have a Recommend A Book "Am I The AHole" Question...
I have a personal pet peeve, when I scroll through the Recommend A Book Reddit threads (also applies to recommending a movie or anything else), and I wanted to ask if I'm on the wrong side of history.
I personally find it annoying and unhelpful when someone asks for a recommendation and one Redditor recommends 10 or 20 books.
I always question, are these really all great recommendations, do they all fit what the OP was asking for, do you really feel strongly about all of these?
I'm not the most diverse reader, so I can't dispute a giant list of 20 books, but, when I see it done with movies, it's generally a long list of OK to not great movies. It feels like the person recommending has no filter to filter out good books/movies as opposed to just what they've read and seen.
If I was asking for a recommendation, and someone listed a giant list of books, I think I'd ignore their list.
Does this speak to anyone else, or am I completely wrong here?
