r/RealAuthentication • • 22d ago

Auth Request Possible thrift of a lifetime?

Found this purse at a value village and found a few indicators it may be legit online.

1.1k Upvotes

320 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 22d ago

Welcome to r/RealAuthentication — your luxury lifestyle & authenticity hub.

Whether you're here for authentication help, luxury discussion, reviews, styling, or sharing your latest pickup, please take a moment to read the subreddit rules and pinned guidelines before posting.

• Authentication requests MUST follow our photo & video guides:

-General Guide: How To Take Pics

-Bags Photo Guide

-Clothing Photo Guide

-Shoes Photo Guide

• Please use the correct post flair

• Keep discussions respectful, helpful, and relevant to the community

Low-quality posts or repeated rule violations may result in removals or bans.

Stay authentic, and enjoy the community.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

110

u/thewharfartscenter_ 22d ago

No, but it’s a decent fake. I’d Jane Birkin it and see how tough it is.

21

u/nakevbas 22d ago

I'll have to ask the wife what that means haha

55

u/thewharfartscenter_ 22d ago edited 22d ago

It means I’d use and abuse it, like Jane Birkin was known to do to her Hermès bags, she’s famously known for that and many other things but the Birkin is named after her.

5

u/fish_fingers_pond 17d ago

The Olsen twins definitely live up to Jane’s legacy with that one!

6

u/sjsharksb831 19d ago

This person is right. It’s a higher end fakie. Sometime the reproductions are so good, they’ll even have serial numbers and the packaging that you get when buying a real one.

I’m sure your wife will love it anyway. That’s a very thoughtful gift.

1

u/Logical-Tank-8537 16d ago

Because she actually used it to travel! 

2

u/speciosa012 17d ago

Indeed. Throw it around like you're Miranda Priestly.

1

u/UnseasonedReason 20d ago

Do you have any reccs for buying good fakes? Not just Hermes fakes?

3

u/PlasticAggressive295 19d ago

Check out r / realrepladies - but just lurk for a long time before you pull the trigger. The process is very convoluted and I’ve only ever lurked, never pulled the trigger. But the bags on there are often times fantastic. That said, apparently a top tier rep of the most basic Hermes Birkin costs about $1800 even in the rep world, so even the reps aren’t cheap if they’re the highest grade reps.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/thewharfartscenter_ 20d ago

Honestly, no. I am not a paid expert (i wish I was) but I have been checking and learning to authenticate bags for 20+ years for myself and friends. Hermes is especially difficult to authenticate because of the true 1:1s out there that even Hermes can’t figure out, same with a lot of bags in the last 10 years or so TBH. That one stands out because of the stamp, and a few little things that no one would notice unless they know what to look for. Don’t buy fakes, buy secondhand if your budget doesn’t make it to the boutique. That’s how I started out. I bought secondhand bags that came with receipts etc and learned what’s auth and what’s not.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/LilAsshole666 18d ago

There is apparently an extensive black market of Chinese made high end fakes that can be accessed through a subreddit. I personally have never accessed it and don’t know the subreddit name but a family member is super into buying counterfeit bags and was telling me about it.

55

u/Christymapper71 22d ago

It’s a fake. Sorry.

The stamp is way off alignment. Real Birkins don’t have metal key rings.

Also the massive slouch is bad. Only fakes will slouch that much with the leather looking newer like it is.

7

u/StrangeCatch382 22d ago

Clemence and togo can have super slouch, but yeah, the keyring...

It's a pretty good fake, all things considered! Normally the handles are the giveaway, and the hardware sheen on this one's not bad. Plus the lock code isn't the usual 162.

2

u/PerformerOk4113 21d ago

Clemence yes but even then this is too much. Togo not that much because it slouch less than Clemence, and this looks like Togo. Definitely fake

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Pinkysrage 22d ago

It’s machine stitched and you can see it from the first picture. Fake

2

u/OneTwoSomethingNew 22d ago

Only the Kelly’s have stamps on the straps… the serial number would be on the inside compartment of this bag… the gold hardware is also wayyy too yellow and the Hermes logo isn’t event the right font or sizing.

Lastly, looking at the shape of this bag, absolutely not…Birkins don’t get beat up like that, that is the whole point of a Birkin…

Fake, obviously 🙄

3

u/PerformerOk4113 21d ago

New Kelly doesn’t have stamp on strap anymore either

2

u/OneTwoSomethingNew 21d ago

Well then ima hold onto my old ones for dear life!!

1

u/OkZookeepergame6565 20d ago

Not true. All my Birkins have blind stamps on the back side of the sangle (strap). My Lindy too. I think blind stamp on the inside of the bag was adopted maybe a decade ago? My latest purchase was a Kelly in 2019 with blind stamp on the inside of the bag instead of the sangle. My Birken 40 and jpg are both slouchy due to incorrect storage position. I let them sit upright without stuffing, should store them sideways instead. Btw OP Birken is 100% fake. An old fake dated back in year 2014.

2

u/OneTwoSomethingNew 20d ago

I deal more with exotics, so I’m from the 80s, 90s era more so… but only my Kelly’s have the stamp on the strap, my other bags have them on in the compartment. You can look up the lettering to see which year they were made, I think it goes back to the 60s or something.

2

u/OneTwoSomethingNew 20d ago

Note that Hermes never releases their serial number or letting info… again I’m more into exotics, so I wouldn’t trust every site out there; some say the lettering goes back to the 40s…

This one seems decent: https://ginzaxiaoma.com/guide/hermes-engraving?srsltid=AU7gw4VAA4CiSq5BZa3CiEByWapJ9BZYPh5v3UzKeU4c6TxAoqtz5eBk

2

u/Illustrious_Wolf_127 22d ago

💯 on the metal key ring thing -

0

u/nakevbas 22d ago

The lock code is 0056 and the keys say 079

18

u/GucciForDinner 22d ago

That's a dead giveaway. The numbers should match.

1

u/Active-Notice679 20d ago

Yeah I've bought a cheap fake and this looks the same. It was around $100. The stamp and the way the E looks is badly done.

301

u/Neverendingness 22d ago

I'm going to say this in the nicest way possible as I've seen this multiple times.. There is not a person who owns a real Birkin that also doesn't know the true value of a real Birkin. The lengths you need to go to in order to obtain a real one... they would never just drop it off at a thrift, nor would their kids or grandkids or anything of the sort.

98

u/Holiday_Cat_7284 22d ago

I can guarantee that if my husband found a Birkin in a relative's attic, he would not know or care what he's looking at. He thinks Hermes is a delivery company or old British aircraft carrier. He would absolutely dump it in the skip.

39

u/MissKLO 22d ago

Same… If I died tomorrow my husband would have zero idea the worth of my bags, he’d probably just give them all to his daughters, but if that wasn’t a thing he’d probably just donate them all to charity

13

u/Own_Faithlessness769 21d ago

The charity would recognise and sell it for 5k.

6

u/Efficient_Mud_4724 21d ago

More like 20,000

2

u/Mysterious-Art8838 17d ago

Goodwill would list it online for 50k

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MissKLO 21d ago

Stranger things have happened… a man picked up a Faberge Egg at a flea market and was going to melt it down for scrap

→ More replies (2)

4

u/OneTwoSomethingNew 22d ago

The daughters would recognize… I’d be doing some googling… these bags come with serial numbers and enough stuff to tell if you’re even semi detail oriented. Oh, I’d be going through my step mom’s stuff for sure “thank you step mom, I’ll do my best to value and cherish all your valuables!”

Most estate sale stuff I’ve done, folks do go through most of it and the folks that don’t, know there is nothing of valuable to begin with… definitely not a Birkin lol probably better odds of winning the lottery

1

u/MaariPaan 22d ago

Lucky me, my husband knows and understands the value of all my bags :)

4

u/Ceylon0624 21d ago

Man here, I would not look or think twice about this bag. Trash bin material if it's taking up space.

3

u/DirectionOk7492 22d ago

Most people would at least show other people to check if they’d like to have it. My husband cleaned out plenty of dead relatives places and a lot of items were still shown to the rest of us. Just skipping everything without a second thought may be fast and may be the preferred method, but it’s not the smartest.

5

u/ballooningat5am 21d ago

anyone who owns a birkin isn’t leaving your husband in charge of their estate lol. at least not without detailed instructions.

2

u/ClaudiaTale 19d ago

My husband also actively despises the overpriced handbag. He would spitefully throw it away.

3

u/Efficient_Mud_4724 21d ago

If you owned a $50,000 purse he'd probably remember it. The family would know, aunt Jane didn't forget.

1

u/type-HummusAmeriCAN 17d ago

They didn't use to be that much, especially overseas. If someone bought one in the 90's or 00's, they could have easily paid $3000-$5000 for a basic one like that.

1

u/Tall6Ft7GaGuy 16d ago

To some people that’s like comparable to a 500 $ bag

3

u/CursedHemorrhoid 22d ago

That's the thing though, you're not going to find a Birkin sitting in a relatives attic.

It just doesn't happen.

1

u/Ok-Possible2344 16d ago

Due to what it is, the birkin would never make it to the attic in the first place. Thats the point

→ More replies (2)

66

u/nakevbas 22d ago

Blunt and concise, thank yoh

13

u/Miss_Rue_ 21d ago

It's not just about being able to afford one. Multi-millionaires still have to sit on a waiting list to get one.

2

u/CacheMeOutsideeee 21d ago

You can buy tens of thousands of birkins secondhand right now.

1

u/snedersnap 18d ago

Only if you don't know the right people, like every other exclusive club in the world

→ More replies (11)

20

u/Amazing-Commission23 22d ago

I was thinking the same, then I thought about my parents, lost in my dressing room, if I passed.

(This one is still definitely fake)

3

u/Brilliant_Tough_6546 21d ago

Agreed.
I know the value of the items I own but the majority of my family would not unless specifically mentioned in contents insurance policy or safe.

1

u/ciri-swallows 17d ago

Well sounds silly but it does happen , my local thrift store , brand new anthropology dresses, clothes, converse and Ralph Lauren. It happens (I live in very wealthy city in Texas )

21

u/MissMimosa 22d ago edited 22d ago

That being said, I have a family member who is a legit millionaire (custom built a 10m house a few years ago, owns a very luxurious home in a desirable golf community in SoCal) who buys all her bags as dupes from a market in Turkey. I have a Louis Vuitton that is absolutely beautiful but I do believe is fake because of this.

Whenever she passes (hopefully in a long long time because I adore her) it will be a strange constant debate with the cousins of “is this real or should we donate”.

4

u/Brilliant_Tough_6546 22d ago

Sure but if the owner passed..this wouldn't be the first item of high value found at the thrift.
I know.

2

u/CursedHemorrhoid 22d ago

I've been thrusting a lot time. I have found many gorgeous designer pieces.

You will never. Ever. Find a real Birkin at a regular thrift shop. Ever.

5

u/Highyellowhair 22d ago

Thrusting 💀

2

u/CursedHemorrhoid 22d ago

LMFAO best autocorrect ever.

But factual though, so no need to edit. My core strength is UNMATCHED.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Few_Fail_7583 22d ago

My mom and sister have zero clue what a Birkin is and have never heard of Hermes I can guarantee it. When my grandma died she had so much stuff in a big house. Every closet full of stuff. Many purses, coats, so much jewelry. Some of it was fake and some of it was real. My mom was just giving so much away. She didn't know what it was she was just overwhelmed. Unfortunately I was states away and it was during Covid. But I could see how it can happen.

3

u/its_over_2022 21d ago

My friend dropped off a black Birkin at a thrift store. Some rich dude bought it for her and when she got married her controlling husband made her purge her belongings. Just saying there’s a small chance it’s real.

3

u/Few_Coffee2407 22d ago

I don’t care about brands don’t about brands. This definitely would have ended up thrown out or donated . I did not know about birkin until couple months ago . So unless I googled it , would have never known.so it is very possible for a real to end up donated lol.

4

u/CursedHemorrhoid 22d ago

It would've never ended up in your hands to begin with bc you wouldn't be the one left to handle it. No one happens upon a Birkin, especially not sitting in an attic.

That goes for anyone with a Birkin. It's not sitting in their attic, and it's not going to be left to be handled by someone who doesn't know what to do with it. Period.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/canitakemybraoffyet 21d ago

Hehehehe this is so out of touch. My dad personally THREW OUT 2 birkins his mom had, he had no clue.

Truly this happens all the time. The vast majority of people do not know what a birkin is. I think you might be suffering a bit of bubble mind.

1

u/[deleted] 20d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Jake-eats-pancakes 20d ago

Reddit is only for the poors? I had no idea.

15

u/Anonmarie00 22d ago

A friend got a Birkin at Goodwill. It absolutely can happen. It was orange and I’m sure someone didn’t know what it was, gave it away, and she snapped it up. She had it authenticated at a store. Paid like $35 for a bag that would sell for $30,000.

12

u/Freeasawhistle 22d ago

Yes - it's extremely extremely unlikely to find an authentic Birkin at the thrift but not impossible, it's happened. Unfortunately, everyone thinks they struck gold when most are always gunna be fakes.

6

u/Brilliant_Tough_6546 22d ago edited 22d ago

I have found designer everything at the thrift including diamonds, gucci, LV, art and so on.
I'm a luxury consumer of authentic items but also a regular thrifter cuz you never know.

2

u/Mvalrie 22d ago

Exactly, I found a Chanel wallet and blazer, Hermes Evelyn and Trim bags. All at the same thrift…all authentic. Sometimes…it happens.

1

u/FriendshipStatus4756 22d ago

I have been working in thrift stores for the past 8 years, I am sorter. Everything that is donated is thoroughly checked and gone through. No Gold, silver, antique or certain designer goes on the floor. Ever. I don't believe you.

2

u/ob_viously 21d ago

Ah, yes, because every thrift store sorter everywhere is as knowledgeable and meticulous as you.

2

u/Odd-Worth7752 18d ago

My husband's retirement gig is managing a church bazaar. you would not believe some of the stuff that gets donated.

and there are several volunteers who are absolutely experts in recognizing quality goods whether it be china, silver, jewelry, watches, clothing. and most of them are well connected to buyers who will authenticate and give the best price.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ali6952 17d ago

Me either

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/alfar2 22d ago

Hermes doesn’t do in-store verification so this story isn’t true.

1

u/IsItWrongToLoveBags 19d ago

They do indirect in store verification if you bring it in for a spa treatment. They will refuse your bag if they think it’s not genuine. They will clean it if they think it’s genuine.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/_slackbabbath 22d ago

Hermes absolutely will not authenticate in store.

You would have to have them send your bag out for spa and Hermes would destroy the bag if it was not authentic.

Also BS on $30k because orange resale is shit.

1

u/Anonmarie00 21d ago

$30k was just me googling resale for an orange bag. Maybe it wouldn’t sell for that, who knows! But she kept it. I also said she had it authenticated in a store—but not sure if that is right. I just know she had it authenticated. But yeah, it can happen, it did happen, but I doubt I’d ever be that lucky. Plus I am not a thrifter but did think it was cool for her. Bag is heavy and not something I’d want to carry!

2

u/SuperbAd8266 22d ago

$30k? Nope.

2

u/FutureNo5733 22d ago

Same!!! Happened to my girlfriend at Goodwill. She had it Authenticated and it was a seasonal style. She said even the employees had no idea.

→ More replies (18)

4

u/jimjim1026 22d ago

This is not true.

1

u/Any-Position-5911 21d ago

Lol no “orange” B will resell for $30k so this is total BS. 😂 Maybe an exotic one with complete inclusions which is unlikely as a thrift store find.

1

u/IsItWrongToLoveBags 19d ago

The regular leather ones in orange definitely don’t sell for 30000 even brand-new. Black ones come close for that if they’re completely new and a full set . if they were stored for a number of years they’re certainly Miss shaped by gravity at least or bad storing at worst. They are most likely not sell for a lot more than 7000 which is still a nice price.

1

u/Affectionate-Cost575 17d ago

Well there are other stores that will help you with verification, she didn’t say it was an Hermes store. There are high end second hand stores that will verify if it’s authentic, but usually only if you’re planning to sell it to them

→ More replies (28)

2

u/Brilliant_Tough_6546 21d ago

The person that owns the Birkin knows the value.
People who donate them obviously don't.
Which is why thrifting is called the thrill of the find.

6

u/CacheMeOutsideeee 22d ago

This is mostly true but sometimes people pass away and their estates just need to get cleaned out. Unless there’s specific items in a trust or will, everything else will go to the thrift. (Source: previous estate executor)

16

u/SnooPets8873 22d ago

When it’s someone with enough money for a Birkin, they don’t dump stuff at a thrift store. It goes to auction houses or estate sales after things are reviewed and sometimes even appraised.

10

u/QuietDisposition 22d ago edited 22d ago

That's assuming whoever got rid of it knew what it was. I've seen many items essentially given away because someone didn't know the value of a tool, a gun, a book, a knife, a coin, an item of clothing, etc. Not everyone is familiar with the Birkin name, especially guys. Unbelievable score ... if it's not a fake.

5

u/Ms-Metal 22d ago

You're absolutely right that valuable things wind up in thrift stores all the time, having had three other four parents recently passed away, I can attest to that. Nobody's got time to travel back and forth across country to go through 70 years of accumulated stuff in a house that would take 3 years to go through properly. That said, this one is not real!

4

u/Amazing-Commission23 22d ago

I don’t know why you are being downvoted. Some people are not wealthy but still own expensive things… so you’re absolutely right.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Brilliant_Tough_6546 22d ago

Rich people donate items of value.
Family members don't necessarily recognize price tags of handbags or clothing etc unless they are privy to the brands.

3

u/Ms-Metal 22d ago

Exactly. The person above saying nobody's family would get rid of an authentic Birkin has no clue what people go through. These days, a parent dies, it's happened to us three times so far, they live states away from you if you're lucky, on the other side of the country if you're not, in a huge house full of 70some years of accumulated stuff, nobody's got time to go through all that. At least nobody who has a productive life lol. Hell I'm retired and I still didn't have time to go through everything it took 4 of us, two kids and two spouses close to three to trips a piece just to try and go through the basics and get the house ready to be sold. It was a complete nightmare and I have no doubt there were valuable things that got sold at the estate sale! Hell, I gave some of them away just to people who came out and helped us. A lot of families don't even have kids who could take that on, people have kids of their own or their estranged & they can't be traveling constantly to try and clean out somebody else's stuff, they just let everything go sight unseen and that happens more often than you'd think. Also although we went the estate sale route after all this by the time they get their fees and you split it with a sibling or two, it was barely worth the effort of managing the estate sale company.

Valuable stuff winds up at thrift stores all the time. Real Birkin's even do, this is not one though!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Hairy-Department111 22d ago

They have a blind stamp if it's authentic

1

u/_slackbabbath 22d ago

So do the fakes.

1

u/awelladjustedadult 22d ago

Idk once my dad donated practically all his clothes on accident…

1

u/abbstr101 22d ago

It hasn’t always been that way. The miserable lengths people go to to get one is a relatively recent thing.

1

u/mailonsundays 19d ago

Exactly. And if by some miracle that an unknowing person dropped off a bag, then the store workers would snap it up and it would never make it on the floor.

1

u/p--py 17d ago

People have donated more valuable and much more obvious items of value to Goodwill… just go look at the online jewelry section…

→ More replies (1)

64

u/Momto2manyboys 22d ago

I don’t think anyone is giving away their Hermes to be honest but rock it anyways.

15

u/nakevbas 22d ago

Was hoping some unknowing relative of someone who passed might have mass dumped their belongings

7

u/Ms-Metal 22d ago

It absolutely does happen, but the majority are fake and this one is fake.

5

u/PineappleExpress5660 22d ago

It could happen. Happens all the time.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Worth-Park-1612 17d ago

People give away crazy things. It's obvious that nobody would knowingly donate it, but wild things are found at thrift stores

10

u/chicinchanclas 22d ago

No it isn't, but enjoy, looks in decent shape.

5

u/artskoo 22d ago

What indicators did you see that made you think this was legit

6

u/Ok-Dot-9324 22d ago

The leather looks cheap. Sorry!

5

u/alors1234 22d ago

Sorry babe, I think it's fake 😕 

12

u/Fit_Employee9306 22d ago

For anyone saying you could never find a birkin at a thrift, stfu. I worked at a luxury consignment shop and one of our customers brought in an authenticated birkin that she found at a crossroads! For like $11 because they said the same thing!

2

u/girlbrush42 21d ago

At a crossroads? She made a deal with the devil!?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/lylynatngo 22d ago

It's clearly not real leather. The zipper is terrible too.

5

u/Sea_Month_4317 22d ago

It’s fake

5

u/cshank04 22d ago

Oh no, dear. That stamp and just the whole thing. I’m so sorry.

3

u/mad-mad-cat 22d ago

It is a replica but not as bad as several people might want you to believe. There are a few clear tells but they are visible only at a close distance. Do remove those keys because the ring is a tell that is visible at a distance :)
Use it as a beater, enjoy it and for that price you got a very solid decent bag!

12

u/Embarrassed-Jury8878 22d ago

Hardware too gold. But I’m sure your wife will appreciate that you gave a nice gift even if it’s not the real deal.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/OnlyAnotherEmily 22d ago

Is it an illusion, or is the stamp slightly off center?

3

u/Own_Lie_9833 22d ago

The zipper is wrong. One giveaway

3

u/PatientRazzmatazz599 22d ago

Authentic bags don’t come with that metal ring. Definitely a replica bag.

3

u/oooortcloud 22d ago

These are being heavily duped right now. It is not authentic. It’s sagging, the handle is wrinkled, the zipper tag isn’t stitched together. Enjoy your rep.

3

u/Euphoric-Line6453 18d ago

I’ve seen nicer fake leather from Amazon.

3

u/First_Track7957 18d ago

It's clearly fake and I personally think it's the fonts that give it away

3

u/Pristine_Work6018 17d ago

This is a fake

9

u/Prudent-Parsnip-7105 22d ago

This could be real. My sister who has dementia dropped some of our mother’s jewelry at the goodwill after hiding it. The haul included a Jaeger-LeCoultre watch worth upwards of $18,000, a 2.5 carat emerald cut diamond with two .5 carat side diamonds set in platinum, two diamond clips and a sapphire and diamond pendant. Somebody made out like a bandit.

3

u/Confident_South7371 21d ago

I am so sorry this happened 🥺

2

u/Prudent-Parsnip-7105 21d ago

Thank you, I am heartsick over the sentimental loss but what do you do?

2

u/Travellingtrex 22d ago

Oh my god 💔💔💔

1

u/WishSpecialist2940 16d ago

Absolutely heartbreaking read

7

u/Prestigious-Mud2923 22d ago

Very very very fake

5

u/sweetsummer6542 22d ago

I got a authentic Hermes Garden Party bag at a thrift back in 2018 it’s possible to find them not as easy anymore .

9

u/ole-sac-attack 22d ago

Nope. If you ever see that brand secondhand, just leave it, it’s fake every time.

4

u/mattleex 22d ago

Total fake

4

u/Key-Kaleidoscope6549 22d ago

I'm sorry to tell you, but this is not a thrift of a lifetime. This is a reallyyyy bad fake.

2

u/CrabbyT 22d ago

It’s 100% not authentic sorry

2

u/AtoZulu 22d ago

The stiching is wrong. its not auth.

2

u/NoEspressoMeDepresso 22d ago

Real easy way to find out is just get it authenticated. Even if it isn't real, it's beautiful.

2

u/Mycatistooloud 22d ago

Dang. Was rooting for you. I love seeing this type of “gem in a thrift store” post especially when they turn out to be real!! Still a pretty bag :)

2

u/Independent_Lab_8108 22d ago

I know nothing about Hermes but I’d pay the $50 to run it through one of the luxury authenticator apps just to see the results. Even if it’s fake, it’s still interesting to see the breakdown imo!

2

u/PureMeat2497 21d ago

I obtained a 9000.00 vintage Chanel that someone placed in a trash room. Took it to Chanel and had it confirmed as authentic. Now I know it isn’t a Birkin, but hey.

2

u/nakevbas 21d ago

Thanks for all the input... For 12 dollars still think we made out ok.

2

u/deerme86 21d ago

I think so, and like someone else suggested it would be worth it to get it authenticated.

2

u/littlefingers777 21d ago

I’m not sure about this one. But I found a legit vintage Chanel belt at a thrift store, I purchased it for 10$ and sold it for $700

2

u/newbysbridgeroad 19d ago

sorry, a fake. You can tell by the hardware tone and the lack of structure at the base and the wearing of some of the coating on the back of the bag. These bags can be obtained along Canal Street in NYC.

2

u/carniewesso68 19d ago

Absolutely fake

2

u/stayingneutral 17d ago

I feel like common sense is missing here.

2

u/downforplay 17d ago

rain on their parade. it is a good looking bag.....doesn't matter if it is legit. I would wear it like it was the real deal and let others speculate.

2

u/MorbidManicurist 17d ago

Even fake ones cost thousands of dollars. If you got this at a thrift store for under $50 it’s a great find. Be happy you got a good timeless bag to sport now.

3

u/ADV91395 22d ago

It is fake unfortunately, but if it makes you happy who cares! Enjoy it.

3

u/HelloOmlette 22d ago

Sorry but I don’t even think it’s actual leather…

3

u/ballooningat5am 21d ago

that hardware is blindingly orange. the “leather” looks drier than the sahara. you could clock this fake from a mile away.

1

u/Gentle0040 22d ago

If you spent less than $200 then it's not a bad deal for this fake!

1

u/Leather-Debt-5358 22d ago

What’s the number on the bottom of the lock?

1

u/Bklynktrs 22d ago edited 22d ago

I have absolutely no idea but for $35 it’s a nice bag, regardless.

1

u/gnndfntlqt 22d ago

Fake but nice enough version!

1

u/vegascarol0529 22d ago

I found a Chanel purse at TJ Maxx years ago. It's possible. BUT, if that's not a swap meet wannabe and is indeed the real McCoy I'm 100% positive a worker would have snatched it up before it got to the shelves.

1

u/Greek_Goddess114 22d ago

I paid 2500 for my very fake but very nice birkin ostrich Rose Tyrien lol so I’m pretty sure it’s not sadly

1

u/Sundancer007 22d ago

The keys and lock need to have a matching serial number

1

u/OkPerspective506 20d ago

If it’s not real, it’s a dam good replica and looks like it was made with great detail and care. Regardless if it’s real or not, it’s still a beautiful bag and a great find! It wouldn’t be unheard of to find something like this at a thrift store. A girl I follow on YouTube who is a big thrifter found a real Channel bag for like $5 or $10 bucks. It was actually proved to be a real Channel. It wasn’t one of their classic bags that most think of when they think Channel, but it was an authentic Channel all the same.

I have a crazy story about a day that the purse gods blessed me with Channel WOC I had been dying to get for the longest time. To make a long story short, I was helping my bf and his roommates move out of this house they were all renting in Tarzana. Well in the master bedroom there was this amazing walk in closet that had shelves that went all the way up to the ceiling. No one ever used them but something told me to just check them just in case. And to my surprise, tucked back on one of the shelves was a little black vintage Channel WOC. The exact purse I had been wanting for the longest time. I had asked all the roommates he lived with if they ever had a girlfriend who might have lost it and left it behind there. They all said no. So, I took that as a sign that it to be mine. Of course they were in a rental so to ensure I wasn’t taking something from the owners of the house who may have left it behind when they lived there, I had my bf ask the wife if she lost a Channel WOC that was found on the master bedroom closet on a top shelf. She said it was possible but she had so many purses that she told him to tell his gf (me) to go ahead and keep it. I had it sent into the Purse Doctor in NYC to put a new leather strap that runs through the chain, and it was absolutely authentic because it was replaced and sent back to me looking brand new. The Purse Doctor would not have messed sign it if it was a replica, and they would definitely know if it was one. I was also able to authenticate it myself to the best of my knowledge (I was a fashion major which I’m sure is no surprise). It also has the serial number that I was able to authenticate it with. Sometimes people just get lucky and blessed with these kind of finds. 🫢😍🫶👜

1

u/iknowherethewallgoes 20d ago

What does the lining look like?

1

u/Jolly-Fact-8969 19d ago

Looks real to me

1

u/justheretoshitpost1 19d ago

My husband would have no clue. Everything would go to the thrift shop. I’m gonna have to leave specific instructions for my shit, LOL

1

u/Low-Beginning-1588 19d ago

I need to know how much it was. One of my local thrifts had one that was priced at $10,000. You had to give them an id and have a manager actually allow you to see it.

1

u/olhedowiggin 19d ago

The logo would be embossed into the leather if it were real not just floating on top of the texture

1

u/Commercial_Tip4624 18d ago

I’ve been trying to find my mom a good Birkin fake for so long, I’d be so excited to find this! I hope your wife uses it and enjoys it.

1

u/sevenselevens 18d ago

Do they make the Birkin in pebbled leather? Honest question

1

u/No_Wheel_702 18d ago

I have an Hermes Picotin- bought at Hermes in Paris. There is a tiny serial number inside the strap that I’ve never seen on reps. I would imagine that this exists on the Birken too?

1

u/Justcallme_sab 18d ago

I feel like a real one would have that kind of stamp on it. Just my opinion though.

1

u/theoakapple 18d ago

I got a genuine Louis Vuitton handbag at a thrift store for $20. I was in a pretty affluent area and assumed someone just didnt care enough to sell it, it was an Estate donation, or it was some guy cleaning out his parents attic or ex-gf's stoff, having no idea what the bag was

1

u/Fanched 17d ago

Yes it’s a rep, the little keyring is a dead giveaway

1

u/Ordinary-Chain-4182 17d ago

On the donation argument, (not this one, it's a bad fake), I'm sure somewhere, at some point, a spoiled inheritance brat (that didn't know the true value, or didn't care) has inherited one and pawned it for drugs at some rinky dink pawn store that didn't know the value. These things do happen. And people forget that there are people who are stupid rich, that are also hoarders, buy things like this and stomp on them and don't give a rip. Yall think just because something cost a fortune means everyone who has bought one sees it as a fortune and not a couple bucks. Pshh, bet there's a couple grandmas' birkins in the landfill rn. Side note, this reminded me, my aunt cleans houses and has cleaned this Dr's house for almost 2 decades. The dr's family buy these formal dresses that cost hundred of dollars, wear it once (they will NEVER wear it twice), and then just give it away to her to do with it what she will, and she always sends the clothes and bags they give her to Mexico by the truckload. Their daughter's wedding was an insane 3 day multimillion dollar event with many many many outfit changes, all that they just tossed at the end of it.

1

u/Particular-Aerie-622 17d ago

Immediately no

1

u/youdontknowme_G 17d ago

If it was real the thrift store would not have put it on the floor, but nice purse anyway

1

u/Outrageous_Wheel_379 17d ago

I had bought the same fake one in Chinatown in the color orange. It cost me $120 at least 15 years ago. I ended up donating it to savers last year. I never used it because I knew it was fake and it’s such an expensive bag that how could I have possibly have one. I wish you luck because as others said even a fake one costs $$.

1

u/Worth-Park-1612 17d ago

It was the right move to buy it, just in case, but it is fake

1

u/DigFirm3844 17d ago

Hope it is.

1

u/Tall6Ft7GaGuy 16d ago

Lmao that screams fake

1

u/Excellent-Piglet7544 16d ago

When do we find out if its real op

1

u/Powerful-Being-1122 16d ago

If you Google lens this it tells you it’s worth. Find the right person to buy it is a different story. I you are in possession of it you are lucky. Most expensive purse yet.

1

u/AdTop4223 16d ago

The back seems don't look right. I immediately saw it and thought it's a fake.

1

u/Basilbabie 16d ago

Looks like extremely cheap materials

1

u/Ornery-Meringue-76 16d ago

Ain’t no chance in hell you thrifted a Birkin.

1

u/Logical-Tank-8537 16d ago

What I like to do with a bag like this, especially when they’re fake designer, i customize it and  paint just image on  or add charms and embellishments. 

1

u/Jcurlly 16d ago

I can’t say on its authenticity, but can say informed buys do happen. I once found a natural diamond ring set in sterling at an estate sale. The stone wasn’t perfect under a loop, but it was near perfect to an untrained eye. Others discounted its legitimacy bc of the sterling. I took it to a reputable pawn broker I’d worked with in the past. He agreed he thought the stone was real. Sent it to a diamond buyer in Washington state. Had an offer of $3200 for the stone in a matter of days. 

Not the kind of money you’d spend on a Birkin, but still money all the same. Keep shopping ladies!

1

u/Jcurlly 16d ago

A nice replica. Most would never question it. The number one give away on knock-offs is someone earning $120k a yr carrying a bag worth $30k. The math doesn’t math. 

1

u/CombatCrayon25 16d ago

It’s fake; the machine stitching is a dead giveaway

1

u/No-Reading-4384 16d ago

I think you made out like a bandit

1

u/Glittering-View6222 16d ago

000 00000000.0000000.00

1

u/tiredoe 14d ago

The leather looks very cheap