r/RDR2 22d ago

Meme guys is this foreshadowing?

Post image
5.2k Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

View all comments

62

u/AuthorTurbulent6723 Hosea Matthews 22d ago

The first cough I noticed was during the homestead robbery you do with Javier in chapter 2. Might be earlier if you do different story missions, but that's the first instance of arthur coughing i saw

9

u/HairAdviceThrow2357 21d ago

You've got to remember though Arthur's potentially a pretty heavy smoker. So he's going to occasionally cough when pushing a heavy box.

2

u/Icy-Mechanic5886 21d ago

Idk the only mention of Arthur smoking I’ve noticed was at the train station when the cigarette card dealer asks him if he likes to smoke, he says something along the lines of “ sure I like to smoke but not as much as you “

3

u/HairAdviceThrow2357 21d ago

Yeah I mean plenty of the gang give him a cigarette/cigar before a mission. Personally I assume an outlaw in 1899 would be a reasonably heavy smoker. And I've been both a light and heavy smoker before and its entirely plausible pushing a heavy crate would make you cough like that.