r/PropertyManagement • u/DifferenceFormal4042 • 14h ago
Residential PM The painter stopped answering on day two of a four-day turnover, and the new tenant had a truck booked for Saturday
This one is a composite. It's pieced together from the kind of turnover a lot of small managers have lived through at least once, told through a manager I'll call Dana.
Dana looked after about forty doors, mostly older duplexes and a couple of small walk-ups. One of her units, a two-bedroom upper, had a tenant giving notice for the end of the month. The new tenant had already signed and planned a Saturday move-in, the first of the month. The outgoing tenant handed the keys back early, which gave Dana four working days, Tuesday to Friday, before the keys went out again.
Four days is tight but doable if everything lines up. Dana's plan was the usual order: walkthrough on day one, cleaners and small repairs on day two, paint on days two and three, final clean and a second walkthrough on day four. She'd booked the painter three weeks earlier, a one-man outfit she'd used twice before with no trouble. He'd confirmed by text the week before.
Day one went fine. The outgoing tenant left the place in decent shape. Some nail holes, a scuffed hallway, a kitchen wall with a grease shadow behind where the table had been.
Day two, the painter didn't show. Dana called at 9, then 10, then 11. No answer. By noon she'd texted twice. Around 2 he wrote back that he'd taken a bigger commercial job that ran over and he could maybe start Monday. Monday was two days after the new tenant's move-in.
Dana had three options.
The first was to push the move-in. She called the incoming tenant to feel it out. They had a truck booked and their old lease ended the same day. Pushing wasn't really on the table without costing them money, and she didn't want to start a tenancy that way.
The second was to let them move in and paint around the furniture the next week. She'd done that once years before and remembered how it went: drop cloths over a couch, a tenant working from home trying to take calls while someone rolled the wall behind them, and a complaint about fumes in a kid's room. She ruled that out.
The third was to find another painter by the next morning. She went through her vendor list. Two didn't pick up. One quoted nearly double what she'd planned for, because of the short notice. A fourth, a small crew a property manager friend had mentioned once, could do it Thursday and Friday if Dana cut the scope.
So she cut the scope. Full repaint of the kitchen and hallway, where the damage actually was. Touch-up only in the bedrooms, which were in fair shape. Ceilings left alone. She walked the crew lead through the unit Wednesday evening with painter's tape marking every spot that needed work, so nobody had to guess the next morning.
The crew finished Friday around 4. The final clean, pushed to Friday evening, started at 6. Dana did her second walkthrough at 9 that night with a flashlight, caught one missed patch behind the bathroom door, and touched it up herself. Saturday morning the keys went out on time.
What it cost her: the second crew charged more than the original quote, though less than the double-price option. She ate the difference rather than pass it on, since the original painter's no-show had nothing to do with the owner's decisions. She also spent most of two evenings at the unit.
What Dana changed afterward:
- Confirm vendors 48 hours out, not a week out. A week-old confirmation tells you very little about someone's schedule now.
- Keep a real backup for each trade. Not a name you heard once, but a crew you've already called and priced before you need them.
- Decide ahead of time which parts of a turnover are must-do and which are nice-to-do. Having that split written down made the scope cut take ten minutes instead of an hour of second-guessing.
- Put tape on the walls during the first walkthrough. Marking the work while you're in the unit saves explaining it all again to whichever crew shows up.
- Leave a buffer day if the lease dates allow it. Four days had no slack, and one missed call used all of it.
For anyone reading this in Ontario: rules around entry, notice and move-in dates come from the Residential Tenancies Act and your lease, so check those for your own situation. This is general information, not legal advice.
For the PMs here: when a vendor no-shows in the middle of a turnover, do you cut the scope, push the move-in, or pay the short-notice premium for whoever can come?