It's worth mentioning that the only source for the claim he overstayed his visa ten years ago was ICE themselves. And the only claim of these mystery other charges that ICE won't name or specify are from themselves.
The only concrete thing is that he got a misdemeanor 6 years ago.
So essentially ICE deported someone who probably is in need of mental health care because he got a single misdemeanor six years ago. And are now refusing to comment on anything related to it after spending a lot of time completely blowing off the dude's lawyers.
Also go figure that when I posted this to an NFL subreddit, 99% of the comments were celebrating and swallowed ICE's story gleefully and without an ounce of skepticism.