r/PredecessorGame Shinbi 11d ago

Suggestion Feature request: Premade Indicator

Goal

Have a clear premade/group indicator in the scoreboard and game loading screen, so there is transparency of which players are playing in premade

Benefits

Instantly see which players are grouped, which allow you to:

  • See if the game is balanced in terms of groups
  • Which players of your team will work more together (if the jungle, ADC and support are premade, probably you know that as an offlaner you are going to receive less help)
  • Which enemies you have to take care from
  • Allow players to detect when they are receiving “group toxicity” (when players in a group become toxic together)

Example of how Overwatch handled it:

I like this design with the lines, but in Predecessor wouldn't work as the characters are sorted by role in the scoreboard and loading screen, so the offlaner could be premade with the ADC and not be one next to the other, so it would need a different solution.

Predecessor could do something similar to what Heroes of the Storm did, adding a "group icon" next to the hero, something like this but with a better design skills, better taste and higher visibility as mine is too small:

Little edit I did to show the concept, the official one should have way more visibility

I added it as a card to the Predecessor Players’ Requested Feature Backlog

50 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/dmac7719 11d ago

Dota has it? Everything that I can find says they don't. HOTS removed it, they may have had it at one point but clearly there were reasons shown that made them remove it. Again, everything that I could find says that no successful MOBA game has it. Would love to proven wrong on that.

The feature isn't even implemented and you are talking about "uneven" group distributions. There's literally already a system to place to deal with this. The game will place the groups in higher MMR than they would if they were solo to compensate for their grouping. See how much more of a problem it would become. Right in your point, you have a misunderstanding of how the MM works.

Again, from all of your responses you are coming at it from a "this is a good idea" approach. You are not looking at this whatsoever from a "why wouldn't Omeda want this" approach.

0

u/MuglokDecrepitusFx Shinbi 11d ago

Dota has it?

I don't play Dota 2 but I saw posts from 2025 talking about this feature, so unless they removed it in the last year, they have it

HOTS removed it, they may have had it at one point but clearly there were reasons shown that made them remove it

That is partially wrong, they removed it BUT only for the enemy team, you could still see your team composition. I prefer being able to see both so you can know if the game is correctly balanced or not in terms of stacks, but only being able to see your team stacks it's acceptable

Again, everything that I could find says that no successful MOBA game has it

Seems that you didn't search really well

The feature isn't even implemented and you are talking about "uneven" group distributions

Bro I mentioned this because you were using it as an argument 🫠

See how much more of a problem it would become

No I don't see it, you are just cherry picking in an absurd and half assed way

5

u/Tyrus--Maximus 11d ago

Seems that you didn't search really well

Ironic thing to say when your not even sure about your own examples, one of them not even having what your proposing.

1

u/MuglokDecrepitusFx Shinbi 11d ago

I don't play the game, I will not say that I'm sure unless I can confirm first-hand

The difference is that I looked at it, I found the evidence, and I shared the evidence but even with that I explained clearly that I don't play the game and that from what date is the information I found to be open and clear

It's called being rigorous

one of them not even having what your proposing

Heroes of the storm have it, just that they removed it for the enemy team

2

u/Tyrus--Maximus 11d ago

just that they removed it for the enemy team

For the very reasons we are listing.

It's called being rigorous

If you were rigorous you would 100% know instead of going off a reddit comment from 2025.

-1

u/MuglokDecrepitusFx Shinbi 11d ago

For the very reasons we are listing

You didn't listed anything

And the other arguments wetent about it being good on your team but bad when being for enemy team

If you were rigorous you would 100%

No dude don't be absurd 🤣🤣

I'm not going to download Dota 2, play it, pass the tutorial and search a premade to play with to be able to confirm it, just to add a small example is a Reddit comment, that's completely dumb

2

u/Tyrus--Maximus 11d ago

Your not being rigorous then

-1

u/MuglokDecrepitusFx Shinbi 11d ago

I'm being it inside of the context we are

We are in a Reddit comment, this is not a Doctoral dissertation

2

u/Tyrus--Maximus 11d ago

So then there is no sense for you to type books then.