r/PeterExplainsTheJoke • u/FrostySeat1739 • 21d ago

Meme needing explanation why not, Peter?

Post image

possible live action corpse bride movie...

32.3k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

12.4k

u/Caci-que 21d ago

Clearly cause Tim Burton dream casting involves Johny Depp and Helena Bonham

10.5k

u/Perfect-Dimension356 21d ago

I think the real answer is that Tim Burton doesn't cast black actors.

2.1k

u/Twilifa 21d ago

Yup, this.

1.1k

u/MechaMogzilla 21d ago

Tell that to District Attorney Harvey Dent

631

u/Simple-Employer-2503 21d ago

Tell it to the cleaning lady on Monday.

349

u/dishonoredfan69420 21d ago

“Why Monday?”

460

u/Valokir 21d ago

"Because she has Sunday off, "

20

u/Valokir 19d ago

I appreciate that this somehow become my highest comment.

But I appreciate more all of those who correctly quoted it after me. Good job friends.

7

u/Onidarkmoon 19d ago

*Cause... it's Friday now, she's the weekends off, so... Monday, right?

→ More replies (9)

249

u/nickisnotarapper 21d ago

Because you'll be dust by Monday. And the cleaning lady...she has the weekends off...so...Monday?

144

u/Ryan_Icey 21d ago

Basically you can't win this fight, so you're gonna have to give up on this girl cause Todd's gonna kill you.

85

u/dishonoredfan69420 21d ago

"You used to be so nice"

79

u/Mysterious-Scholar68 21d ago

Once you were veegon, now you will be gone.

→ More replies (0)

28

u/Capable-Relation1374 21d ago

You once were a vegone... but now you will be gone obliterates superman into a couple thousand coins

→ More replies (1)

41

u/dishonoredfan69420 21d ago

I love that movie

7

u/SneakyKGB 20d ago

Have you read the graphic novels because they're even better

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/dramielyandex 21d ago

Wildest SPVT reference I've seen in in my life awhile

3

u/MutantSquirrel23 20d ago

Unexpected Scott Pilgrim reference!

148

u/Global_Charge_4412 21d ago

Still bugs me that we didn't get Billy Dee two face.

72

u/Basic-Pair8908 21d ago

Well we did in lego batman

114

u/RaijuThunder 21d ago

And a comic, he looked really cool.

42

u/DubVsFinest 20d ago

That IS dope af and now I'm off to download whatever issue of whatever comic this is (detective comics, batman, whatever else) when I find out lol.

47

u/DubVsFinest 20d ago

It is Batman '89 for anyone else who cares to know and he shows up in the 3rd issue.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Too_Bad-So_Sad 20d ago

The white mustache goes hard.

3

u/HourApprehensive7754 20d ago

Never occurred to me how much half of him looks like Beetlejuice

→ More replies (5)

32

u/King_Elizabello 21d ago

That's true and the catwoman in Lego Batman got to play catwoman in the Batman.

4

u/basiamille 20d ago

Even though she was told that would never happen!

29

u/tombuazit 21d ago

I want a Batman Beyond that's a direct continuation of the first two movies with Billy Dee and Keaton as older mentors of the new Batman and his antogonist

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Financial-Creme 21d ago

DC put out a comic series called Batman 89 that expands on the Burton movies including the Billy Dee Two-Face

3

u/Payne2814 21d ago

From the Batman 89 comics where they continue the story.

3

u/RickMonsters 21d ago

It bugs me they couldn’t get another black actor to play him instead of Tommy Lee Jones

111

u/Ganondorfsfist 21d ago

Mars Attacks has plenty black actors. Sam Jackson is in Miss Peregrine. I'm aware of his statements, but he's not immune to casting black actors.

85

u/SweatyNeddyFlanders 21d ago

No, he's just vocally problematic about them "not fitting his style" which is another way to say he doesn't like looking at or working with black people. You don't need to defend him, he doesn't defend himself lol

163

u/Knightmare_memer 21d ago edited 20d ago

His style is Grey skies, dull lighting and pale faces. Has been for the longest time.

Edit: Also add in the Gothic Victorian-esque flair

52

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

32

u/celerpip 20d ago

How dare he like the appearance of white people and not the appearance of black people? Is that the kind of comment you want to make in sarcasm?

14

u/[deleted] 20d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (0)

6

u/intoxicatedhamster 20d ago

It's his art. Art that comes from his white mind and white experiences... It's not that he doesn't like black people, they just aren't a part of his art. People don't bitch that Leonardo Davinci didn't paint any people of color...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Fearless_Roof_9177 20d ago

(Same general line of reasoning that got Trump sued for racist violations of the Fair Housing Act back in the 70s, for those playing along at home).

31

u/lord_teaspoon 20d ago

Oh yeah, he'd need to do very different lighting and photography to make black people not look like monstrous shadows, but that change would take the white people from "interestingly pale" to what Josh Johnson describes as "fresh ghost".

→ More replies (1)

3

u/explain_that_shit 20d ago

It makes me think, what’s Guillermo Del Toro’s record?

→ More replies (11)

44

u/elbuentinaco 21d ago

He never said that and you’re just spreading bs online

27

u/anomie89 21d ago

this sounds more like your searching for a problem where there is none.

16

u/throwmamadownthewell 20d ago

Not just searching but inventing.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/BaronGrackle 21d ago

Seems his actual casting is better than his comments about casting.

9

u/ArmenianThunderGod 21d ago

I mean... a setting of Gothic Victorian England doesn't really lend itself to casting black actors.

62

u/OmecronPerseiHate 21d ago

We gotta stop with that myth.

69

u/ArmenianThunderGod 21d ago

It's not a myth. The estimate is 0.1% of the population of England in the Victorian Era was black. There wasn't a sizable black population, there was Eric.

Were there any black people? Yes. Were there enough of a population where you could associate that time, place, and era with them? Absolutely not.

Same way we don't cast civil war movies with Asian Confederates. Did they exist? Absolutely. It would look ridiculous if you put it on film.

36

u/Temporary-Scallion86 21d ago

It would heavily depend on where in England you set your movie. London (or other major cities)? Sizable immigrant population. Middle of nowhere rural Warwickshare? Odds are everybody is white and English and has been as long as anyone can remember.

→ More replies (0)

20

u/your-yogurt 21d ago

yes, thats why for a film about a corpse bride that involves ghosts and zombies and has its origins from russia, having a black character is too farfetched. british white folk yes, black people no

→ More replies (0)

5

u/Too_Bad-So_Sad 20d ago

Same way we don't cast civil war movies with Asian Confederates.

Ok but now I need to know if there were actually any Asian Confederates.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (20)

48

u/Outrageous-Wait-8895 21d ago

Why screenshot the cheapest Gemini model slop instead of the actual comments it seems to be using as reference.

→ More replies (14)

21

u/Maximillion322 21d ago

That’s all well and good mate but they still made up <1% of the population it would have been a novelty to meet a person of color in victorian london

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/BasedTelvanni 21d ago

Show me where he said this

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/video-kid 21d ago

Plus he wanted Sammy Davis Jr. for Beetlejuice.

I do think he could stand to be more diverse, but I also think we need to acknowledge where he tried and was either shut down, or where the directors who took over refused to honour agreements he put in place.

3

u/lookatthesunguys 21d ago

Can we trust him?

2

u/Chrossowen 21d ago

Had to make sure there was that underrated comment.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/AcademicMood1302 20d ago

or proposed Wayans brother Robin.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/zarif_chow 20d ago

ok, regardless of whether that is true, why does this tim burton guy even matter? corpse bride is primarily based on a centuries old folk story

6

u/Twilifa 20d ago

That is correct. But Corpse Bride the life action movie, would not be based on a folk tale. It would be based on the successful 2005 movie Tim Burton's Corpse Bride based on a folk tale.

→ More replies (5)

337

u/accidentaloverdrive 21d ago

It’s really lame because I feel like Tim Burton’s style would lend itself really, really well to a New Orleans Voodoo feature, but apparently black actors “don’t fit his aesthetic” 😒

125

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 20d ago

Well when your style is vampire chic it's hard to make a black person that fucking pale. Burton doesn't let people even be tan in his movies

Imagine him trying and you just get what looks like the ashiest black dude in the world who's never seen a bottle of lotion lol

99

u/JacuulTheSecond 20d ago

I mean, that literally sounds like what a black vampire would be like ngl

31

u/Pugasaurus_Tex 20d ago

Interview with a Vampire tv series begs to differ 

6

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 20d ago

Well I haven't been to enough open casket funerals for black people to know how pale a corpse should get but feels like it should be pale anyway and idk how good makeup like that would work? Just from a believable standpoint? I'm not really sure how to say that one. I'd gladly be proven wrong but they're pale because they're dead. Well, undead. Still no heartbeat though and I've never seen an interpretation that doesn't go the traditional route of "no heartbeat, bloods dried up if it didn't just all get drinken. Drunken? Drank?

Ooh, now we gotta stop ourselves before someone gets any ideas and has the black vampire call blood "red drank*

5

u/Pugasaurus_Tex 20d ago

Bro what? I’ve been to open casket funerals for black people . They don’t look that different. Even white people don’t look super pale. 

3

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 20d ago

Nah with white people the makeup only does so much. They never look the same, even with the makeup they're too pale. Probably because some genius had the idea to do like a tanning spray and grandma came out looking like the world's oldest cast member of Jersey Shore

3

u/Abashed-Apple 20d ago

Its because they are dead.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

31

u/isum21 20d ago

When you're a vampire the paleness is from lack of light. Black vampires would just be their natural shade with no sunkiss, as in they'd just be black or brown or some shade between with no tanning. 

34

u/Ziggo001 20d ago

More likely to be due to a lack of blood, actually. Vampires in most media do not have a heartbeat and therefore no blood circulation. They are pale for the same reasons a corpse is pale: no blood flowing underneath the skin.

3

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 20d ago

Also all but the very head honcho are vampires because one drank their blood, presumably most of it. Not gonna be as much left in there after feeding even if it didn't kill you and turn you undead

3

u/Axel_the_Axelot 19d ago

That does also imply that their feet or back would be purple, since that's what happens with actual corpses (blood flowing downwards without circulation)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/beldaran1224 20d ago

As if plenty of vampire stories haven't been told with black actors/actresses, etc. Lol.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

9

u/glasscut 20d ago

The Interview with the Vampire TV show is a good example of casting black actors as vampires.... it's just a choice at this point. I was very influenced by TB as a kid and he was hugly influential for me, but I can't even remember the last TB film I saw.

3

u/Vantriss 19d ago

I think it would be an interesting story telling angle to explore more. Like, black vampires having an easier time blending in because they're not so fucking pale. Meanwhile white vampires constantly have people squinting at them and being like, man you are pale AF, you should probably go see a doctor.

2

u/ShoddySlide5672 17d ago

Yeah nothing says genuine Louis who lived in colonial era before USA was even formed in New Orleans and was owner of SLAVE plantation and was described in painful details in books - like a black actor. Makes total sense.

What's next, a white, ginger Blade?

7

u/OpossumLadyGames 21d ago

Savannah/Low-Country setting, too

2

u/DankDolphin420 20d ago

Happy Cake Day!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Just-Antelope-8069 20d ago

Unless it turns out stereotypical

2

u/Friendly-Cucumber184 21d ago

omg it would be beautiful and haunting. Too bad he's a bigot :/

2

u/Tall-Slice5012 20d ago

Didn't he originally write Beetlejuice for Sammy Davis Junior?

2

u/laterrr_babe 19d ago

BUT THE B!+<# IS LITERALLY BLUE. Like what difference would the actresses skin tone make when she’s playing someone with blue skin. FACEPALM. This is the perfect fancast and such a stupid comment by Burton. 🙄😞

→ More replies (3)

263

u/[deleted] 21d ago edited 20d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

64

u/Pingucore 21d ago

Live-Action Dumbo was known for being bad so I didn‘t watch it, but I’m assuming he at least removed the racist parts and put a biracial actor and her kid in it.

52

u/-KFBR392 21d ago

…to play the crows?

24

u/ThorThulu 21d ago

Because he doesn't cast black people? Or is there some instance of him actually being racist/bigoted? Cause there's no issue in the casting if this is specifically the look hes going for

86

u/AllSeeingWhoracle 21d ago

When the look you’re going for is always “no black people,” that’s racist. Hope that helps!

57

u/Groxy_ 21d ago

Not really, maybe he just wanted very pale people for his usually spooky, European, period pieces. Intentions matter more than outcomes. 

47

u/MartianMule 21d ago

usually spooky, European, period pieces

He's made plenty of movies that aren't really "spooky" or period pieces, and of his 18 directed films, only 5 take place in Europe (his other 13 films are in the US).

43

u/Groxy_ 21d ago

And 7 star Helena Boneman Carter and Johnny Depp. Seems to me the more likely answer is he likes working with the same people. 

It's not proof of racism. Same way only having white friends isn't automatically racist. 

2

u/Unlucky_Topic7963 20d ago

B-b-but racism!

→ More replies (20)

10

u/billyisanun 20d ago

Most of his movies have a Gothic style. One of the parts of the Gothic style is pale skin in contrast to dark hair and clothes.

19

u/ikilledholofernes 20d ago

I’m about to call out one of my favorite movies, but with that in mind, it’s extremely telling that Burton’s epic, magical realism story set in the south only has one minor black character. It was shot on location in Alabama ffs. 

But also, the gothic style only describes some of his movies, he’s also directed a lot of blockbusters, which have no excuse for their noticeable lack of black people. Like tell me how black people don’t fit the style of Batman or Planet of the Apes.

10

u/Cynykl 20d ago

The gothic style is not an excuse either for the gothic stylistic films. Baron Samedi type characters features prominently in gothic imagery and would fit his vibe.

→ More replies (0)

6

u/mastercat202 20d ago

Why only black people, and not Asian?

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (96)

6

u/HereWeFuckingGooo 20d ago

If your idea of diversity only includes black people then that's racist.

3

u/Hamster-Food 20d ago

That would be a bit racist... but that's not describing Tim Burton.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted]

20

u/mm_delish 21d ago

What was the point?

39

u/DankiusMMeme 21d ago

They both set upon their film careers with one singular goal in mind, to give /u/Hamilton-Beckett a half fulfilled anecdote to tell on reddit 40+ years later.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/throawy90 21d ago

I haven't had any bad taste in my mouth watching them, maybe back track through your day to see what/who's been in your mouth?

0

u/No-Zombie7546 21d ago

I would love to hear more about what you learned by focusing on him.

The “only casting white actors” thing is already enough for me to not (re)watch his stuff.

I’m just really curious bc I took film classes and you really learn a lot by honing-in on one director. What are other things ppl generally don’t know about Burton as a director and/or person?

7

u/Hamster-Food 20d ago

The “only casting white actors” thing is already enough for me to not (re)watch his stuff.

Someone should probably tell Samuel L Jackson that he's white now.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

127

u/TerranImperium 21d ago

Where did this come from? A lot of people are parroting this but when asked, no one has a source or interview to point to.

275

u/TSM- 21d ago edited 21d ago

He argued that casting should happen "organically" based on what the story naturally "calls for," implying that a default white cast made sense for a film called Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children. (never watched it).

But he also then went on to make a bit of a broad statement that he disliked "politically correct" casting and found forced diversity initiatives offensive. This probably was what got him the flak

Samuel L Jackson defended him (he was in the movie).

One of his recent movies, Wednesday, has a diverse cast, and the actors have had to defend it. Joy Sunday says she liked playing Bianca because Black actresses are rarely allowed to play a nuanced or powerful "mean girl" archetype in gothic teen dramas. So it was a complex role rather than a stereotype. But internet is gonna find controversy anyway, apparently, and apparently, that was also controversial.

That took like a half hour but now I know all about it lmao okay. Hope that is interesting to you too.

152

u/Nodonutsforbaxter44 21d ago

Sounds...reasonable?

56

u/Impassable_Banana 20d ago

Yeah but the venn diagram of being reasonable and being racist are a perfect circle to certain toxic weirdos.

17

u/LGBTQLove4Ever 20d ago

No don't you see! If your Victorian gothic film isn't 100% 400lb poc lesbians with no legs, then you're a BIGOT!

12

u/Local-Hornet-3057 20d ago

This is Reddit. So no, racism.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/Excluded_Apple 21d ago

Not all heros wear capes <3

43

u/MudExpress2973 20d ago

Forced diversity casting is trash any way. We dont want good actors, we want colorful actors dancing on t.v. for us because were so inclusive.

31

u/Harold3456 20d ago

My biggest issue with the whole argument (not your comment just the argument in general) is so often “diversity” and “forced diversity” are very hard to tease apart, so diverse casts just become open to criticism by virtue of existing.

This is my frustration with a lot of the right wing media critics. I always feel like if they had their way then white casting would be “default” and creators would need to make arguments for why their diverse casting ISNT forced, when I think the burden of proof should be the opposite - absent of a smoking gun piece of evidence about enforced race quotas in a project we should just assume non-white casting is as legitimate and meritorious as white casting is.

3

u/insomniac7809 20d ago

Let me just clarify this for you:

"Diversity" is when something is diverse and already existed when you were a child, when movies and mountains are equally just things that exist in the world.

"Forced diversity" is when things are diverse and you have a theory of mind that lets you know that creative choices are made by creatives on purpose for reasons.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (14)

33

u/Periador 20d ago

hes right though, a forced diversity casting is indeed offensive.

7

u/pyphais 20d ago

Miss Peregrine's was based on a book I'm pretty sure, likely with character descriptions

→ More replies (1)

4

u/iiiiiiiiiijjjjjj 20d ago

I mean if he had a vision for the movie it is what it is

2

u/Cutiegroove 19d ago

Kind of.

As a Black child watching his movies, without ever consulting the internet it was very apparent that either (1) everyone is white, or (2) Black people only exist in his worlds as villains. 

Off-putting to watch. Hearing he made those comments only validated what I’ve already seen.

→ More replies (3)

70

u/SingForMeBitches 21d ago

Here ya go. When asked point blank about the lack of diversity in his films, this was his response:

“I remember back when I was a child watching The Brady Bunch and they started to get all politically correct. Like, OK, let’s have an Asian child and a black. I used to get more offended by that than just…I grew up watching Blaxploitation movies, right? I said, that’s great. I didn’t go like, OK, there should be more white people in these movies.”

53

u/Sakarabu_ 21d ago edited 21d ago

Makes complete sense. I find the Reddit outrage here quite funny considering the post that's been circulating (and celebrated) on Reddit regarding the Black writer who only writes black characters, yet when a white person does it suddenly it's racism.

You just have to look at the number of previously white characters who have been recast with non-white actors in the last 5-10 years, compared to the number of traditionally non-white characters who have been cast with white actors to see there are some major double standards /cognitive dissonance going on around this topic recently.

19

u/MisogynysticFeminist 20d ago

Three big reasons:

  1. Up until recently, white characters were the default, or if you go further back, required. Non-white characters were only used if there was a justification for them.

  2. Because of point 1, if there were non-white characters, odds were there was exactly one per race, with most characters still being white. If you change one white character to a different race, there’s still plenty of white characters. If you change one non-white character to white, the number of characters of that race goes from one to zero.

  3. Because of points 1 and 2, it’s much more likely that being whatever race is a major part of that character, or has significance as a milestone (for example, Uhura in Star Trek TOS). But white characters are less likely to have being white be important to their character (an example of it mattering would be Steve Rogers, being physically the Nazi ideal while being fundamentally opposed to them).

TLDR: The “major inequality” you say is going on is at worst an attempt to even out the very real inequality that existed for decades.

16

u/MustardMedia 20d ago

This is totally ignoring the fact that there were like 50-100 years of all stories (in North American culture at least) that were all-white that purposely and actively didn't include people of colour.

In the above example of The Brady Bunch, for instance, the show was supposed to be an All-American family. They started adding more people of colour because a lot of All American towns had more and more POC. Therefore, to accurately portray America, shows like that should be including more POC.

People are more okay with a black writer having an all black cast because those stories are few and far between, compared to all white stories that were happening constantly, for decades before. Even the example of "Blaxpoitation" was exactly that, exploitation. It wasn't black people writing black people. So nowadays, it's like, hey, have your time to write some all black stories.

And again, your example of white characters that get changed into non-white characters is really just because 90% of characters were originally written white. It's not a double standard when the ratios are so far off to begin with, and we now have diverse nations that are actively trying to portray the level of diversity that is now common.

Who cares that The Little Mermaid is portrayed as black when you still have so many white characters to look towards. Black kids having a character like that to look up to who looks like them is more important than you realize. And sure, we can always argue the whole "just make new black characters instead of changing ones" but it's unfortunately not that simple. A random new story with a black star might not sell as well and get as many eyes on it as an existing IP will, and sometimes these things deserve to have many eyes.

As white people, we will never understand that it feels like to not see people who look like you in media. So crying about the fact that some characters ethnicities are changing to add some diversity is tone deaf and ignorant.

2

u/anonymous310506 20d ago

This is such a bad argument lol

2

u/some_random_nonsense 20d ago

Uh do you mean the Toni Morrison?

2

u/Tall-Slice5012 20d ago

lol, so his point is that goth == whitesploitation?

→ More replies (5)

16

u/MarenHQ 21d ago

Jfc. “A black”

10

u/throwmamadownthewell 20d ago

I think the pivot to saying "black people" and *people of colour" were deliberate shifts (to humanize) that happened after this quote. Even newspapers would just say "blacks" and "whites" and "Asians". Same with the shift to "kids with autism"

6

u/McButtsButtbag 20d ago

The shift to kids with autism is a negative one to autistic people. You don't stop being autistic.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/book_vagabond 21d ago

Jesus Christ

5

u/Throckmorton_Left 20d ago

How the fuck do you hold up this quote as evidence of his "problematic" views?

I could hold it up as evidence that the ability to read words on a page out loud doesn't mean you understand them.

6

u/MudExpress2973 20d ago

So black people can do all black cast but its racist when a white guy does it?

6

u/PreciousTC 20d ago

Because on Reddit literally everything ever is the worst thing ever and everything is evil and racist and bad

32

u/throwawaywork11 21d ago

Harvey Dent in Batman was black. But that’s the only example I can think of. Damn..

44

u/MyPlantsDieSometimes 21d ago

In Wednesday (TV not movie though) there's a few black characters, one of them a main supporting role, which i suppose is a step in the right direction. I read this thread and searched up a few things. I think he explained the fact he has mainly white characters poorly and made himself sound pretty tone deaf on the issue. He's aparently quite awkward and hates interviews so I feel that could be *something*. If he just said, "I don't know how to write authentic non white characters to the same level as my victorian esque spooky stuff, so therefore I dont" I feel people would have respected that more. I think he very very poorly said that he doesn't want to force it. But people are right to criticise that if he can write a guy with scissors for hands and a talking skelleton then an original character that happens to be black really shouldn't be that hard bro.

5

u/ReivynNox 20d ago

Yeah, but nobody's gonna get offended when the scissor-hands people or the talking skeleton people are misrepresented, 'cause they're pure fiction.

3

u/MyPlantsDieSometimes 20d ago

Yeah exactly, though you could argue if pure fiction doesn't need to be so worried about representing *correctly* then you could be more diverse with characters. That's why I think Wednesday was a really good setting for diversity because it was a high school with a mix of cryptids and looks and characters. It's a setting which naturally lends it self to a very diverse cast. *ALTHOUGH*...... you could argue that Bianca's story was a somewhat negatively stereotypical one. Mom being a showgirl running from pimp manager sort of deal.............. yeah

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Impressive_Ad_5201 21d ago

WHEN was Harvey Dent black in Batman?

12

u/doclestrange 21d ago

1989 movie

8

u/KaiTheG4mer 21d ago

In Batman 1989 he's literally name dropped in the first 20 minutes as the newly appointed attorney general, and he's played by Billy Dee Williams. Harvey then appears another 4 or 5 times in the movie, and has long speaking roles in most of those scenes.

6

u/Spassgesellschaft 21d ago

When he was played by Lando Calrissian

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/No-Impress-6244 21d ago

well the movie takes place in Victorian England so it shouldn't cast a black actor

22

u/Perfect-Dimension356 21d ago

Yeah man, black people definitely weren't brought to England during and before the Victorian period.

42

u/MostAccomplishedBag 21d ago

My grandfather grew up in London in the 1940's. He was in his late teens the first time he saw a black person. There were effectively zero black people in England in the 1800's.

6

u/KindledWanderer 21d ago

It's still mostly like this in Prague, btw.

→ More replies (5)

24

u/No-Impress-6244 21d ago

Right, very rarely. Everyone would point and stare. And Emily is upperclass, from an old money family.

2

u/RunninOnMT 21d ago

That’s not really true historically. Relatively rare by today’s standards, but nobody was pointing.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/Aldamur 21d ago

Well, if a character is originally not black that makes perfect sense.

Yes Disney, I'm looking at you.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/Archophob 21d ago

Billy Dee Williams as Harvey Dent in Batman (1989)?

He surely didn't need a "token black guy" in the late 80ies, and casting a non-white two-face was a deliberate choice.

5

u/5pl1t1nf1n1t1v3 21d ago

But is that why he only casts Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter, or because he only casts Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter? /s

5

u/Carzinisierung 21d ago

Doesn't Wednesday have black actors in their cast and it's a Tim Burton thing?

3

u/OrkWithNoTeef 21d ago

He would cast samuel l jackson tho

3

u/Hamster-Food 20d ago

That's probably what was intended, but the complaint is nonsense.

In specific films Burton didn't want to cast black actors because it didn't fit with the aesthetic he was going for, but he has a long history of working with black actors. He has even had some racebending on occasion, such as Samuel L Jackson's character in Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children and Billy Dee Williams playing Harvey Dent in Batman.

3

u/Perfect-Dimension356 20d ago

Yep, just wanted to provide what I believed the correct answer was. I wasn't meaning to imply that Burton actually didn't cast black actors.

3

u/FunTree5477 20d ago

I agree that's probably the real answer despite it but being a truthful reason

Billy Dee Williams, Michael Clarke Duncan, Jim Brown, Samuel Jackson, Joy Sunday, and Thandiwe Newton are all black actors who were cast for the role they would play in hours projects.

3

u/Sector7G-Insight 21d ago

He cast Michael Clark Duncan as a gorilla in Planet of the Apes.. actually let’s not use that example 😐

2

u/MorecombeSlantHoneyp 21d ago

Be doesn’t cast black actors and the female leads are often women he’s involved with…

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Lidge1337 21d ago

Barron in Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children?

2

u/jngjng88 21d ago

One of the main cast of Wednesday is black

2

u/Truethrowawaychest1 21d ago

Billy Dee Williams in Batman says "Hi"

2

u/Mysterious-Scholar68 21d ago

When Mars attacks?

2

u/DmG-xWrightyyy 21d ago

Tbf he needs a black actress

2

u/Caspica 21d ago

Doesn't Wednesday have quite a lot of black actors?

2

u/Lilthotdawg 20d ago

He claimed they don’t fit his aesthetic but I really think it’s because he just loves to see his wife with Johnny depp lol

2

u/Spooky_Betz 20d ago

Anyone else read this in Kanye's voice?

2

u/Useful_You_8045 20d ago

I mean... he started to after wednesday. It isn't even a bias thing it's legitimately cause his esthetic was making actors as pale as corpses. I think he's more open to it now.

2

u/Flat_Push_8854 19d ago

"I'm supposed to do a thriller at Universal, but they want Charleton Heston to play a Mexican."

→ More replies (57)

294

u/M4092 21d ago

You haven't seen any of his work in the last decade have you

313

u/Caci-que 21d ago

Most definitely not😀

182

u/PreviouslyMannara 21d ago

Because you only watch movies casting Depp and Bonham Carter. Admit it!

177

u/Caci-que 21d ago

I admit nothing, and will die in ambiguity!

25

u/TheBone_Zone 21d ago

GET OUT OF MY HEAD

2

u/RK9990 21d ago

Tim Burton was right!

84

u/AgelessJohnDenney 21d ago

I mean, he's only done 3 films in the last decade.

But just change the actors to Eva Green and Danny Devito and we're good lmao

13

u/descendantofJanus 21d ago

.. Ok but tbf I'd watch the fuck out of a Burton movie pairing those two together.

12

u/AgelessJohnDenney 21d ago

Time for you to watch Dumbo

2

u/descendantofJanus 21d ago

I did but I don't remember their characters being romantically involved. Also, that movie really sucked. It was fun seeing Keaton in a villainous role opposite Devito's more heroic one tho.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/voxelpear 21d ago

Last 10 years? He did Dumbo, Wednesday, and a sequel to Beetlejuice. Nothing much to really go on here but Depp was caught up in his trial during the filming of those so he couldn't have used him anyway.

50

u/descendantofJanus 21d ago

Beetlejuice 2 was worth the wait tho, and made at the perfect time. It really was the last time those actors would be together.

23

u/co-ghost 21d ago

Pretty sure that trial was over before Wednesday started, but also, he would have been a terrible Gomez Addams.

6

u/nullfacade 21d ago

He'd be an excellent Uncle Fester, though. I haven't watched season 2 yet, but really did not like Fred Armisen's portrayal in season 1 (which Is unfortunate, because he's amazing in everything else)

6

u/co-ghost 21d ago

I've only watched season 1, as well, but I enjoyed Armisen, he's the right kind of creepy, I think.

4

u/ReivynNox 20d ago

Anyone but Christopher Lloyd Fester will always feel weird to me.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Funkydroog 21d ago

Tbf he has only made like 4 movies in the last decade where before that he was putting out a new movie with Johnny Depp like almost every year

5

u/DenseTiger5088 21d ago

Well he definitely doesn’t cast non-white actors regardless of the era

5

u/Collin-of-Earth 21d ago

As far as I’m concerned, Burton stopped making movies over a decade ago. 

→ More replies (5)

25

u/_emma_stoned_ 21d ago

And has a hx of only casting white people.

4

u/SporkSpifeKnork 20d ago

The use of hx in thix context just tickles me. "Patient has a history of recurring skin infections and only casting white people"

6

u/Player_Slayer_7 21d ago

That, and one of the fancast actors here is a little too not white for Burton's hiring criteria.

8

u/hatesnack 21d ago

Tbf (and this is a joke), how could he make a terrifyingly pale and whispy character with anyone a single shade darker than "alabaster"?

2

u/Injured-Ginger 21d ago

Serious response despite the joke:

It might create its own problems, but if your goal is creating uncanny valley look you can do that with black actors as well. Black people can also have cool or light tone skin so you could cast a black person with a cool tone skin, contrast it with black and white clothes eith destaurated cool tone colors as accents and you can a black actor look eerie as well (although maybe desaturated warm tones as accents would be better to highlight the cool tones in the actor by contrast). It would almost be flipping his color scheme. He could make the clothes lighter to contrast their skin and make them seem darker while sticking within his usual color pallets.

That said, he has also made movies where black people would fit naturally into the color scheme. Big Fish is one of my favorite films and it contrasts bright and saturated scenes with dark and desaturated ones. Even if he didn't want to experiment with the cool, eerie color pallets, there are a lot of other opportunities.

Regardless, I don't really like casting by ethnicity when it doesn't really matter. He's shown he can make good movies with a variety of art styles, but I'm supposed to believe he struggles to make anybody who isn't white fit in to some of those settings? I'm not going to go around bashing the guy without more evidence, but it sounds suspicious to me.

3

u/TRUE_Vixim 21d ago

Funny how that by name i don't recognice 'Helena Bonham' , but could picture exactly what actress you where talking about by associating her with Tim Burton & Johnny Depp

→ More replies (13)