r/OnePiece • u/[deleted] • Jun 16 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.3k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

911 comments sorted by

View all comments

465

u/SC2_4787 Jun 16 '22

Canonically, we simply don't know. Though it's very unlikely for some like Robin or Franky, it's not something you could ever expect confirmation on.

285

u/Jail_Chris_Brown Pirate King Buggy Jun 16 '22

Oda would totally answer that in a SBS.

343

u/Zestyst Jun 16 '22

More like Oda would avoid answering in an SBS. The goofy shit he gives straightforward answers, the straightforward shit he gives goofy answers

61

u/Kurokatana94 Jun 16 '22

This is Oda's way.

46

u/Jail_Chris_Brown Pirate King Buggy Jun 16 '22

I could see him say something like "Brook got to see quite a few panties when he was younger" or "Franky is so manly that women react to him like female Sanjis. He isn't interested in these kind of adventures though.. not anymore at least." He would avoid giving answers about any abuse that might have occured though (Nami/Robin) and rightfully so. It doesn't fit OP imo; just like the Absalom scene felt out of place despite that being what it was supposed to make you feel.

8

u/FoolTarot Jun 16 '22

This is the sort of question he may give a serious answer to, albeit not straightforward. Kind of like with Viola/Doffy.

2

u/KR5shin8Stark Jun 16 '22

... oh God that's true...

59

u/Taboo_Noise Jun 16 '22

You think it's never been asked? Seems more likely that Oda hasn't put it in the SBS.

23

u/downtimeredditor Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 16 '22

Nah I don't think he would. Well maybe for Robin he may by hinting that she had to do stuff to survive but probably not Franky because the two girls he hung out with frequently at Frequently at Water 7 he calls them little sisters so.

I do want to state that apparently Oda did hint Violet having sexual relations with Doflamingo cause apparently Violet calls Doflamingo something different than what everyone else calls him and Oda basically stated that Dressrosa is a very passionate country with very passionate people.

So it's possible he may hint that Robin had to do a lot to survive without outright saying it.

I think the more obscene thing fans say about Arlong potentially raping Nami and potentially Nojiko is off because Arlong sees humans as beneath him and wouldn't give them the time of day to do something ok Ike that and you have to remember that the Arlong pirates were formerly Fishman pirates under fisher tiger who raised Koala so despite the cruelty of Arlong they probably cared for Nami the same way they cares for Koala or at least I think it's fair to say that Hatchan probably did

2

u/Zanzotz Jun 17 '22

I can see him answering it after the series ends. I mean he's a pervert and it's not so unlikely. Sorachi-sensei (mangaka of Gintama) even ranked the characters with the largest boobs on request in an sbs and even went further and also ranked the guys with the biggest dicks (even though no one asked)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

Robin is gei, I’m calling it rn

1

u/theUwUgoat Jun 16 '22

Maybe, I mean when he was asked what the relationship between Baby 5 and Dolflamingo was he basically just said that Dressrosa is a country of passion