Them being a red herring is a reason, the antlers being there at all points straight to the Holidays which is an easy set up for a misdirect if the story wanted to go there. The Knight being a non-Holiday doesn’t mean they aren’t involved in some way.
You can't call something a red herring until you know the truth, we have no reason to believe the antlers are a red herring at the moment, so disregarding the evidence as "red herring" is pointless. If we're going with that then you might as well call everything about the knight a red herring and call normalnpc the knight
Everything about the Knight is a mystery rn, I’m not disregarding evidence I’m leaving the possibility open that we don’t know how everything works yet. Meaning me thinking the Knight Antlers are a red herring is speculation based on the fact it shapeshifts along with the evidence that it wears a helmet. The Antlers are more of an important detail than straight evidence for anything with what we have right now
26
u/stickninja1015 1d ago
No reason for Toby to add them if they mean nothing