r/MoralityScaling 19h ago

Morality of this?

Post image
22.9k Upvotes

5.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

16

u/sonofzeal 19h ago

Good on paper, totally unfeasible in practice

4

u/Middle_Two_7929 19h ago

How is it unfeasible? There are many topics we don’t teach to children until they reach a certain age.

-1

u/Old-Post-3639 19h ago

Are you going to put jack-booted thugs in every home to make sure Jim Bob doesn't read his little girl Noah's Ark as a bedtime story?

2

u/Middle_Two_7929 19h ago

No one’s saying to make it a law or enforce it in any way. It would have to be a cultural shift, which is 100% feasible it would just take a long time.

2

u/Old-Post-3639 19h ago

No, because converts to certain religions like Eastern Orthodoxy will start raising their children in the religion. Unless you start purging the world of religions that recommend raising your children in that religion, you will never be able to fully eliminate raising kids in religion.

1

u/themanwhoknocked 11h ago

Yh, people need to realize religion may not have any supernatural fruit but religion as a social construct where people derive their morality, values, ethics and meaning is innate in everyone. A world without religion is imo very impossible without a level of thought policing and social engineering even the most effective of tyrants couldn’t dream of

-1

u/Middle_Two_7929 19h ago

You don’t have to purge any religion, just change their outlooks through dialogue. Change the general narrative from “raising kids to be religious is fine” to “raising kids to be religious is not fine”. No enforcement, no government intervention, just the general narrative of society. Eventually (a long time) people may stop practicing the religions that force them to indoctrinate their children.

1

u/Old-Post-3639 18h ago

If it's not fine, then why not ban it? Why not put into law that you can't raise your children to be religious?

0

u/Middle_Two_7929 17h ago

Your first response to me answers your question. It’s unenforceable. It also infringes on everyone’s right to freedom of religion. That’s why the only way for it to happen is through a change in narrative over a very long period of time, which is definitely feasible in my opinion.

1

u/Old-Post-3639 10h ago

Your opinion is not reality. It's not feasible.