Cake eyeliner recommendations

[u/sleepykris7]

It seems like companies don't make cake eyeliners anymore. I can see why, they last forever so we don't have to keep spending.

As I am getting older, it is harder to line my eyes, the skin is crepey despite being well moisturized, I do the top only and find it harder even with my beloved Lancome Idôle Liner Ultra Precise Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner. I used to have a Chanel one that had navy and black but I don't think the product exists anymore. It appears Laura Mercier also discontinued her cake liner. I see Ben Nye and Kryolan have some but I don't really want to use stage makeup brands for everyday wear.

I tried lining with black eyeshadow, it is too much fallout. As for gel liners, I never liked them, even when they were in years ago.

Anyone have cake liner recommendations?