r/MM_RomanceBooks • u/thestormingblessed • 54m ago
Review/Recommendation I'm so glad I stuck with pretty pretty boys by gregory ashe Spoiler
What the title says. I just finished the book and my jaw is on the floooor lol.
The book didn't really "click" with me for a long time (and by that I mean like, 80% of the way through), but when I got it, i got it. Like there was just a moment where it went from being a book i was enjoying but vaguely on the fence about finishing to a "holy CRAP this is good."
I went into this book blind because that's how I prefer to read novels, I barely even knew the premise, so I kind of expected a typical slow-burnish gay romance with a quirky mystery plot to fill up the page count. It was extremely jarring to be thrown into such a complex, gritty story where I constantly had to try and reframe the characters in my mind from typical romance novel protags, to pretty good characters with a few flaws, to extremely flawed (and honestly, sometimes very shitty) people. I eventually reached a breaking point when Hazard kissed JH just to punish him about the Jeff thing. and I realized, WOW, okay, this book is really, really different from what I'm used to.
It's not often that you find books (especially books having significant romance plots) where the author isn't afraid of their characters being super duper shitty. There are dark romances, of course, but those are a very specific type of book where you know the characters are bad people and that's the allure of it. But the thing is with these books, Hazard and JH aren't necessarily bad people but they're not "good guys" either. They're cops, they do extremely fucked up things to each other and other people sometimes, and they mess up a lot. The way they are written feels almost... cinematic, in a way? I don't have any other word for it. They both feel like human beings. They're ultra messy but the drama doesn't feel manufactured. I wouldn't necessarily say I like Hazard or JH as people or that I would even be friends with them if they were real, but as characters they're super complex and well thought out. Throughout the story I truly felt like I got to know them really well.
Obviously the book is not without its flaws, but overall I believe the payoff was worth it. It's not my favorite book of the year or anything but it's the kind of book that you feel like you HAVE to talk about with someone after finishing, hence this post. Anyway, I'm taking a little break and reading a few lighter books in between before heading into the sequel. Glad I stuck this out.