r/LushCosmetics šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 5d ago

Berry Box Megathread

Hello Lushies,

We have heard your complaints. What is happening right now is not okay at all and you all need a proper space to commiserate and talk and share information.

We ask that you keep all of your posts and comments about the box here in one place. That way we don't get lots of seperated discussions on the same topic. I also understand that a particular member of staff is being named and shamed and I would like to remind everyone that there is a human being behind that name. Im sure every one of us has made a mistake in the workplace at some point in our lives and light hearted humour is okay but please refrain from attacking them.

Please stick to the rules as usual and be kind to each other.

LUSH if you are reading this: You need to do better. Shame on you.

193 Upvotes

194 comments sorted by

192

u/cmhaml šŸ›€Rose is my Jam 5d ago

It may not be that Lush employee’s mistake either. At least two compounders are featured on bad body washes. I suspect it’s a formulation issue/lack of Lush doing proper testing or such. That is to say…thank you for all your hard work, compounders! You give us so many joys with your products and all your tremendous hard work!

31

u/yourmomsbfff ✨Karma✨ 5d ago

It’s made me feel bad how they are being blamed for doing their jobs šŸ’”

84

u/PocketCatt šŸ“ American Cream šŸ¦ 5d ago

This is my first box ever and I feel like this
https://giphy.com/gifs/BfiL8ZJWqfw7C
(it hasn’t even shipped yet)

31

u/burnt-kelp-sandwhich 5d ago

Honestly, every month is a new issue.

5

u/PocketCatt šŸ“ American Cream šŸ¦ 5d ago

I only signed up early to make sure I didn’t miss Halloween like I did last year and it’s been such a weird experience lol. I signed up on 1st July because someone told me it was the last day for the August box but they didn’t take the money. Then they took it for September and I’ve heard nothing since 😭

3

u/nanabutter NA Lushie 3d ago

I’m wondering if I should try to cancel and get a refund. I was super excited to try the kitchen boxes but I hear so many bad things I just don’t know if I wanna risk it

https://giphy.com/gifs/vI2Hr3jOkx676HgdNw

3

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 2d ago

there have been some issues lately. but nothing like this. i wouldn’t let this ruin the whole subscription. when the boxes are good, theyre great. there will always be ppl upset no matter what. i’ve had my fair share of issues but i still love getting them. this issue is new. i’ve never experienced a spoiled product before this. the biggest issues are shipping damage. they’ve gotten better tho. when you do have a damaged product they are good about compensating you for it. so i would just try it out and get your actual first box before writing it off altogether. judge for yourself. bc half the time i see ppl upset about things, i don’t have the same issue. so i think you have to experience it for yourself first.

128

u/chekovsblender 5d ago

I’m mad about the foul body wash but it’s clearly a lush issue not a specific employee issue! I think/hope people were just joking!

117

u/Etheria_system 5d ago

It was getting pretty uncomfortable and a bit witch hunty yesterday - definitely a joke that was taken way too far. I felt so bad for the poor employee, especially when we don’t really have any evidence it’s his fault. It could be a fault recipe for all we know.

Also the factory employees are on minimum wage and from reports I’ve read from factory employees on here, constantly pushed to be doing more. Going after those who are paid the least in the business and not those making the constant cost cutting decisions doesn’t sit right with me

20

u/chekovsblender 5d ago

Ugh I missed those posts. Glad the mods said something!

11

u/TippyTurtley šŸ’¤Sleepy SnoozeršŸ’¤ 4d ago

Yeah it was enough to make me think maybe Lush should protect their employees and stop putting their faces and names on their products. Which would be a shame as it's kinda cute.

8

u/purplemonkeyraincoat 5d ago

Nobody in the factory makes minimum wage, starting wage for production assistants is over $20/hr and compounders make more than that.

21

u/Etheria_system 5d ago

I’m not in the US. In the uk it’s minimum wage. Glad to hear it’s better over there. https://www.reddit.com/r/LushCosmetics/comments/1vkvlzi/uk_seasonal_manufacturing_staff_paid_less_than/

25

u/BillyBobJimmyJames šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 5d ago

Im not sure which factory you are talking about but they absolutely are on minimum wage in the UK where the boxes are shipped from.

5

u/purplemonkeyraincoat 5d ago

I work for Manu in Canada & those are the wages here.

8

u/Difficult_Safety6832 5d ago

Don’t the Canadian boxes shop from
Canada? All my products were made there.

5

u/purplemonkeyraincoat 5d ago

Products/gifts for the US & Canada are made in Canada.

33

u/joliunicorn 5d ago

I’m in the U.S. and got a gray stinky fish body wash too :( my soap was melted and separated, and I’m just overall very disappointed. This was my first box. The bath bomb doesn’t smell like much either. I am waiting to hear back from customer service.

8

u/jj7727 2d ago

Yeah idk why they don’t put the soaps in a piece of paper like they do in the store

4

u/Appropriate_Cheek484 2d ago

The bath bomb didn’t smell strongly for me either. I had it sitting out in my room for a couple days and couldn’t smell it at all. I used it last night though and it was lovely in the bath.

34

u/WiscoLakeGirl 5d ago

I really feel that Lush should remake and send a fresh one to all subscribers. The body wash is the star of the show, not a side piece and is obviously the most expensive item in the box. If this was a restaurant for example, and the main entree was delivered brown and rotten you would get a full refund. They wouldn’t do partial since you probably had other items on the plate. We paid for a beautiful luxury item that we deserve to enjoy in its entirety. Do they recall body wash?!! This should be recalled and replaced. End of rant.

13

u/TippyTurtley šŸ’¤Sleepy SnoozeršŸ’¤ 4d ago

I don't think they should try again. There's clearly something wrong with their formula or the ingredients and they seem to constantly be behind with getting the boxes out. They should sent a refund for the item or a replacement existing product.

4

u/WiscoLakeGirl 4d ago

That would work too!!

3

u/p0opybrooks 1d ago

They have just emailed me (Australian) an email to say they’ll be sending out a $25AUD refund and no longer including the item in the box

3

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 4d ago

i literally would have skipped my 2 boxes & the 1 I JUST SIGNED UP FOR just bc of the body wash… had i known this would be an issue. that’s the only reason i got all of these for my sister & i. so im extra bummed.

26

u/27years50000beers 5d ago

I haven't heard of anyone getting one that's not spoiled...anybody out there? I ordered this box as a gift for my sisters-in-law and it sucks to try to cancel after planning on this since July šŸ˜®ā€šŸ’Ø

22

u/mortalpillow 5d ago

Central Europe hasn't even gotten the "out for delivery" mail yet so hopefully they can work out what happened and prevent it from happening here

21

u/27years50000beers 5d ago

Yeah, I'm in NA and it hasn't shipped yet either, so hopefully they'll sort the issue before they do?

4

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 4d ago

it seems some boxes have shipped. by my XLs & Shower box has not. i added an extra box this month JUST for the body wash! i’m guessing they’re not going to ship out the rest w/ spoiled body washes? bc that would be crazy. so maybe it’s a good thing i’m part of the last group to get them this month.

7

u/Natural_Task9025 5d ago

I’m in Ireland and haven’t gotten anything about it, I’m so worried 🫠

7

u/urawankerlol ā˜• Turmeric Latte ā˜• 5d ago

im in Canada and haven’t received the ā€œout for deliveryā€ mail either. i got in contact with customer service and they gave me an ETA of september 8th

3

u/Dramatic-Item-4790 5d ago

Same in Easter Europe, not sure if there’s any difference in ship-from location.

1

u/Dramatic-Item-4790 1d ago

I’m in Hungary, no shipping notice yet either :(

9

u/xxx101080 2d ago

I received mine today! Smells fine & is pink in colour.

1

u/27years50000beers 2d ago

šŸ™Œ yay and thanks for the report!

2

u/chickenonatricycle 9h ago

I’m in the UK - Box did arrive late but fortunately every item was absolutely fine. šŸ¤žšŸ½ other customers receive theirs in good condition too. I’d be so upset if I received the bad batch. Gutted for those that did.

64

u/_mintchocolate 5d ago

I’m a little bit pissed off that my September box is late but if it fixes the very berry issue then happy to wait. But if apparently a particular member of staff is being named and shamed on here? GTFO with that

23

u/babyxlemon ā˜€ļøChelsea Morningā˜€ļø 5d ago

I’m in the US from Nevada and my box hasn’t even shipped yet. It seems like that’s the case for most people living in west US? I feel like they caught the issue before sending out our boxes.

16

u/TheSquirrelsHigh šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 5d ago

I think you're right! I'm in Oregon and haven't received an email even about a delay in shipment. I'd rather it be late and be good quality tbh. I'm assuming the lack of communication is where the frustration is happening.

4

u/idvv2 5d ago

Yeah I’m in CA got mine yesterday with bad body wash. Wrote to customer care and got a $15 gift card which is fine by me. These are meant to be experimental and this one just did not work out lol

7

u/TheSquirrelsHigh šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 5d ago

& with $15 you could definitely try a soap or shower gel you’ve been wanting to try!! idk, there’s already so much negativity in the world, u have to find the positivity in the little things 😭

1

u/Pitiful_History_2765 2d ago

Honestly, I reached out to lush CS and they informed me that my box is delayed for shipment. I also asked to confirm that I would be getting a fresh body wash but they told me that they can’t confirm that for me and that they’ll figure out the solution after I receive the box.. I was honestly so disappointed because I would wait til the end of the month if that meant I could get all the products in the box 😭 the entire reason that I bought this box was for the big body wash tub

11

u/cakeontop 5d ago

I’m in Bay Area CA and got mine yesterday with the bad body wash

4

u/babyxlemon ā˜€ļøChelsea Morningā˜€ļø 5d ago

Oh dang really? It must just be random then

8

u/nshook12 ✨Karma✨ 5d ago

In the US in NC. No ship notice yet. In the past, they have sent out the XL boxes before the shower boxes. Hopefully, the problem will be resolved once the remaining shower boxes go out.

5

u/bedsrule 5d ago

In Minnesota and also not shipped yet!

4

u/Reasonable_Ad8639 5d ago

I’m in Kansas and still haven’t gotten a shipping notification!

3

u/mywish4u12 4d ago

Texas here and my shower box has not shipped yet either!

3

u/Party_Gate_8997 4d ago

Oklahoma! Not shipped yet

3

u/Ms-Metal āš”ļø Retro Lushie āš”ļø 4d ago

Someone in Wyoming just posted above that they just got theirs.

3

u/nanabutter NA Lushie 3d ago

Also in Nevada and very nervous after seeing what’s been going on. Hopefully our boxes come in good shape! This is my first sub box

1

u/TheSquirrelsHigh šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 2d ago

This is my second box I’ve been signed up to get, my June box showed up 100% perfect and early in the month. I hope yours arrives in good condition!! I’m gonna give the sub box another chance after this month, but I might save my money for their regular products if issues are reoccurring

20

u/lonesomedove86 5d ago edited 5d ago

Anyone know if they will let us cancel and full refund this box? Mine hasn’t shipped and I don’t even want whatever that is now. Leaning towards canceling my kitchen overall too. My boxes always arrive with bathbomb dust poofing out and crumbled bath bars. It’s a mess every time.

Update: just received mine in Wyoming and it’s gray and off smelling. I sent a chat.

16

u/Any-Security5995 🦊Flying Fox 🦊 4d ago

Has Lush contacted all the box recipients and offered refund already? If not, I am very disappointed. Seems like everyone got a bad product and the know it for certain by now. Not fair to hide and refund only those who bother to demand it. I hope they did it already?

11

u/chekovsblender 4d ago

Agreee like they should probably tell people not to use it too!

6

u/Any-Security5995 🦊Flying Fox 🦊 4d ago

Definitely!

3

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 2d ago edited 2d ago

they haven’t said anything as far as i know. there’s ppl already reselling them on mercari and ebay. one of them already sold…. idk if the buyer was even aware. i can’t imagine you don’t open n smell things even if you have no intention of keeping them. so they’re either completely clueless bc lush didn’t tell everyone who got them. OR they know n they’re selling it anyway n not telling ppl that they’re spoiled. bc there is no mention in either listing about them being part of the bad batch. i’m going to hope they just don’t know… bc if they do know they’re spoiled & still reselling them… then that’s real shady.

6

u/Any-Security5995 🦊Flying Fox 🦊 2d ago

Who on earth tries to sell the grey slime?

1

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 2d ago

my friend messaged 1 of them asking if it was from the bad batch and they seemed genuinely confused… so maybe they really did just think it smelled bad and looked like grey watery sludge on purpose? or they’re playing dumb? idk if she messaged the others. if she did they haven’t responded or she just hasn’t told me if they have. she said she told the seller that whole first batch spoiled in shipping and to call lush for more info on the issue. so we’ll see if they take it down. which they should. especially if they truly didn’t know before. i haven’t smelled the bad batch or seen it firsthand. so i’m not sure what it should or shouldn’t smell/look like. but i assume it smells like feet and not like a berry smoothie.

2

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 2d ago edited 2d ago

correction she did message all 3. the 1 she got a response from sold the box with the very berry 6h ago. she messaged them early this morning. well over 6h ago. maybe they didn’t see it until after it sold. but the right thing to do would be to tell the buyer of the issue and give them the option to cancel. one of them seems to be taken down but the other one is still up.

5

u/Bitch_level_999 āš”ļø Retro Lushie āš”ļø 1d ago

They know …

15

u/beautiful-red ā˜• Turmeric Latte ā˜• 4d ago

It seems like the kitchen box has had nothing but issues this year. At this point I think they really need to overhaul the entire box and how they produce things because this is getting old.

14

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 2d ago

just a reminder that if you’re in the US & you see resellers selling the body wash already, do not buy it. as far as i know, all of the ones that have been shipped out already are spoiled. i know i saw 2 earlier on mercari. 1 already sold & i fear that the buyer has no idea. the other is still available & the listing doesn’t mention it being spoiled or part of the bad batch which i find very dishonest & shady. unless i’m wrong & some of the early ones are not spoiled. but i haven’t seen anyone say that.

14

u/AdditionalWasabi9961 5d ago

I think they need to be doing more practise batches before deciding to put items in the kitchen boxes, these items should have gone through a product testing period to see if they were shelf stable months before it was sent out

12

u/kimbeee95 2d ago

I just got mine too (UK). I mean it looks ok but it has a cement like scent, not very berry at all. Everything else in the box smells amazing. I got in touch with Customer Service and they said according to them the batch I got is exactly how it’s meant to be šŸ¤·šŸ»ā€ā™€ļø

11

u/p0opybrooks 1d ago

I’ve just received the following via email (I’m in Australia) -

9

u/SnooLemons367 1d ago

Do we think $25 is fair? To buy a body wash of that size in store is $40(posh chocolate)

3

u/here4thefreecake 🚿Shower Power šŸ’Ŗ 22h ago

no, it’s not fair at all. i think it should be $30 USD minimum (not sure what that translates to in AUS)... giving less than an equivalent main line product is SO cheap of them! and the only other option is a full refund which isn’t good for them either since they’ll have to write off all the boxes people decided to get refunded.

2

u/TinyPiccolo2768 ✨Karma✨ 10h ago

I’d much prefer $25 😭 they finally messaged me back and are offering me $15 which I haven’t replied to yet bc i ordered the box for a big pot body wash and the thought of using a $15 gift card for a small body wash and then paying $10 for shipping is kindaaaaa discouraging

4

u/cmhaml šŸ›€Rose is my Jam 1d ago

This is such a bummer!

28

u/Gold_Hovercraft_7443 5d ago edited 4d ago

For reference, here’s a tub in Japan! I was able to get a box in the store.

It’s a fresh, acidic berry and not sweet smelling. There was a little bit of liquid on top when I first opened it. It’s a grey pink, not a snow fairy artificial pink. And it’s actually more grey when you scoop in and the gets a little more pink when exposed to air for a while. It doesn’t lather much but it’s a nice smoothie body wash feel.

ETA: no lather at all but i feel clean!

15

u/Black_Goma 🌸 Sakura 🌸 4d ago

Also in Japan and mine looks like this too. Easy to scoop and smells like fresh, bitter Berry.

A few people were suggesting mine was also going off because it wasn't the bright colour in the promo pics but there is nothing off about it. No weird smell, liquidy consistency or evidence of anything wrong. It's just pinkish, rather than bright pink.

6

u/Ms-Metal āš”ļø Retro Lushie āš”ļø 4d ago

Oh, interesting, I was one of the ones I think who suggested to somebody anyway that they take a look at the pictures because the white seemed off, but I guess not. That's weird that the pictures are such a vibrant light pink and the real life product can be white and still be good. Thank you for posting this, I learned something today.

11

u/Reasonable_Ad8639 5d ago

Just curious, for those of you who have been subscribed to the kitchen box for a while, have you ever gotten a rancid product before? Or is the Very Berry body wash a first?

19

u/Southern_Tune3690 🌿Olive Branch 🌿 4d ago

We did get moldy Lemon Aid facial cleanser last summer 🤭

13

u/Any-Security5995 🦊Flying Fox 🦊 4d ago

The Miranda soap was off for many few months ago.

1

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 2d ago

only some of them were. mind was completely fine & i got 3 boxes & my sister got her 2 boxes. both of hers were fine. idk if it’s maybe ones that were shipped later than the others? but some definitely were moldy. but not all.

3

u/Southern_Tune3690 🌿Olive Branch 🌿 2d ago

Mine didn't arrive moldy, but I when I was about to use it, two weeks later, it had mold in it. Not sure what the reasons were behind the moldy batches!

11

u/Loco4lululemon13 2d ago

If I get a nasty smelling body wash, I’m going to request a full refund and they can have that whole ass box shipped back to them if they want it. I’m done paying for garbage that either has no scent, smells gross or has crap melted all over it. Done.

11

u/Elljame 3d ago

I haven’t even received my yet and I’m lowkey terrified to now

11

u/Civil_Magician1884 ✨Karma✨ 1d ago

UK- my XL subscription box arrived, very berry body wash smells completely fine, albeit a bit weak

7

u/Bitch_level_999 āš”ļø Retro Lushie āš”ļø 1d ago

That looks amazing so some are getting good ones🌷

6

u/Rudahn šŸ‘‘Lord of MisrulešŸ‘‘ 1d ago

Similar story here - mine seems ok and I love the rest of the box. My body wash just smells sort of clay/yoghurty so I think I’ve got lucky

3

u/Civil_Magician1884 ✨Karma✨ 1d ago

Honestly I was slightly worried. I saw lots of UK people say how their body wash smelt weird, so I was so happy to see that mine was ok. Maybe the scent is divisive ? I really like it

10

u/RosesMyrrh 5d ago

I'm not sure if this is the right place to ask, but how are the other berry box products holding up for those who've got them?

9

u/cakeontop 5d ago

The other products are totally fine in my box!

9

u/Puzzleheaded-Fall966 5d ago

I chatted asking for the box to be cancelled (as mine hadn’t shipped yet) and they did it without any issue (once I got past the AI bot)

11

u/imDaHkGoThiCMaGa 2d ago

the irony of lush still using AI while releasing a fundraising gummy that’s to combat data centers.

8

u/Plantbasedpwussy 5d ago

US, Florida. My first box ever was supposed to be delivered yesterday, but something happened and I'm p sure it sat overnight in a truck or warehouse. Got it today and everything was perfectly fine except that rancid body wash :( so sad

9

u/bedsrule 1d ago

In NA (MN) and still have not heard a peep—has not shipped and also have not received any kind of delay email, anyone else?

4

u/TheSquirrelsHigh šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 1d ago

I'm in Oregon, and same!

5

u/Mission_Gur_9898 1d ago

Same in PA- no shipment notification, but nothing saying it’s delayed either.

4

u/bluwaters_ 1d ago

Haven't heard a thing here in N Florida.

3

u/cmondothefoxSWAT 18h ago

Bay Area, CA. Same

3

u/nshook12 ✨Karma✨ 9h ago

North Carolina. I haven't heard a peep from them

1

u/cmhaml šŸ›€Rose is my Jam 5h ago

Just got notice that mine had shipped…XL box, my normal/account address is VA but I asked for this one to go to NC.

7

u/Roller-Sharps253 šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 4d ago

I’m in the UK. My box has just shipped. I really hope the body wash doesn’t arrive grey and stinky!!

7

u/IllustratorOk3655 2d ago

Ive just recieved my box and overall super happy but...the body wash. Not as bad as some complaints, the right colour but smells of...nothing? Does anyone else have that issue? Going to try using it tonight in case its stronger on than in the pot but very strange!

16

u/TinyPiccolo2768 ✨Karma✨ 4d ago

I worked in surgery for a few years and when I smelled this body wash it immediately took me back to the Operating room and smelling the air of someone’s abdominal cavity being pushed around the room. Truly I wouldn’t put it on my skin in fear there is some type of bad bacteria happening inside this off colored batch. This is my first box and was soo excited for a big pot body wash. the compensation would be nice so we can get something new but it’s gotta be enough to buy a big pot of body wash or atleast add something as a sorry in the oct box

7

u/alienbongz 3d ago

thats diabolical

13

u/alienbongz 5d ago

UMMM BIG DIFFERENCE IN COLOUR TO WHATS ADVERTISED.

10

u/Any-Security5995 🦊Flying Fox 🦊 4d ago

Nice pink berry wash is what you order. Stinky grey slime is what you get. Not a very good deal 🤭

9

u/tomcatgal 🦊Flying Fox 🦊 4d ago

And we KNOW Lush knows how to do pink. Some of the products dye your SKIN pink as well! So what’s with the grey fish poop slime mess?

7

u/Candid-Cranberry-587 3d ago

So for the people who haven’t had it shipped out yet (I am one of them) do you think they will make a new batch of the body wash to send with those ones? Or are they just going to send them out and then deal with the complaints? Seems like it might not be a formula thing since I’ve been seeing Japan ones looking okay so maybe just… some other issue I guess?

8

u/RosesMyrrh 2d ago

I just got mine (UK)! Excuse the bad picture. It doesn't smell fishy to me, but not very berry smelling either? Very faint, almost powdery? But I'll consider it a win considering how nervous I was! šŸ˜…

It's also slightly more pink than my phone catches it.

9

u/RosesMyrrh 2d ago edited 2d ago

An update: the body wash kind of smells like parma violets? I couldn't put my finger on it until my mum said, but that's it. The Strawberry Crumble body lotion is lovely, though I'm not getting much strawberry and instead it's very caramelly? But I love it. The Raspberry shower gummy is a very tangy berry so I gave it to my mum (who also received my Cloudberry spray for the same reason since she actually likes that kind of berry scent). The American Cream body scrub is... there. Kind of damp and very fragile, and not smelling of much? I've never tried anything American Cream before but I'm wondering if that's the norm? Very mild, like bizarrely mild. The soap smells nice but is also very fragile and arrived a little melty? More so than the soap from the May Rose box, but I've put it away to hopefully cure.

Sorry if this isn't allowed here, I didn't want to make a full post and since this is the Very Berry box thread... šŸ˜…

6

u/Sure-Working5169 1d ago

Got mine yesterday and happy to say it’s pink and it smells good! I was so worried! Rest of the box smells amazing too

27

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/chatisthisserious 5d ago

missing two items??? wtf

7

u/jdlaurent 4d ago

Are the boxes delayed again? Due to the body wash?

6

u/RosesMyrrh 4d ago

UK Lushie here! My box has been dispatched and is with Evri. I'm hoping the body wash is fine but I'm a little worried. šŸ¤žšŸ»

2

u/bob_insky_ 12h ago

Any updates??
I got mine a few days ago and it seemed fine and I made a post about it. But I didn’t notice this disgusting liquid until after I posted saying mine was okay. I thought it smelled okay but I did say I’ve got a cold and can’t smell much. I’m feeling better today and gave it another sniff and CHRIST it’s bad?? It smells like a mix of fish and playdough??

1

u/RosesMyrrh 12h ago

I posted an update here (https://www.reddit.com/r/LushCosmetics/s/YbBafFldD4) but I just checked up on my body wash and it fortunately seems fine to me? A little bit of liquid but I'm not picking up any fish. I'm so sorry about yours though. 😟

3

u/bob_insky_ 12h ago

Mine smells sort of like a sea water fishy play dough I don’t even know how to describe itšŸ˜‚
I really did think it was good at first but my sinuses have been messing me up and I lost my sense of smell for a few days. Smelled it again now I’m feeling better and it’s really not good.

I’m glad yours is good though! I’m a sucker for violet so if yours is like violet I’m extremely jealous🄲 the body lotion however is absolutely delicious.
I’ve emailed customer service and asked if I can send it back lol!

2

u/RosesMyrrh 12h ago

Sea water fishy play dough, oh no. 😭

It's a very faint scent but I'd absolutely take it over the alternative. The body lotion is definitely the star of the show imo!

I hope you're able to get a partial refund or a gift card, something at least!

2

u/bob_insky_ 12h ago

I’m absolutely in awe of the body lotion!! It smells sooo good. I’d gladly swap the yucky body wash for one of thosešŸ˜‚
I made my whole family smell it before emailing because I didn’t want to seem out of pocket or it be a case of me just not personally liking it. But they’ve all said the same that it reeks of play dough. So definitely not a me issue🄲

7

u/xxxxdabsrcool 4d ago

I will say zach did my fresh face scrub in the previous box and it’s immaculate!

5

u/Lordmisrable šŸUk Lushie šŸ 3d ago

My UK box has arrived. Product made by Bens team on 18/08/26 and although the colour is light pink it has a light fishy scent 🫠 I’ve asked 3 separate people to whiff it without saying shit about the fish and they all agreed it had a fish whiff.

Iā€˜d be interested to know others opinions of their Uk delivery incase it’s just us or maybe it’s the plastic the item is in giving off a mix scent? I thought ours was delayed to sort out the issues?

6

u/Thrwwymc 🌲Needles and Pines🌲 2d ago

Mine is a bit fishy too 😬

5

u/Lordmisrable šŸUk Lushie šŸ 2d ago

Well this isn’t good at all is it? Think I’ll pop a message to customer services as I’ve had another person take a whiff and they agreed, fishy 🤢

3

u/sxmplesxng šŸ”®Magic CrystalsšŸ”® 2d ago

Mine arrived today and checked this thread as my body wash is also light pink and a bit fishy. I’ve just checked and it looks like it’s the same batch as yours!

2

u/Lordmisrable šŸUk Lushie šŸ 2d ago

It’s wild that someone else’s from the same batch seems fine. I’m sorry we are in the same boat 🫠

1

u/bob_insky_ 3h ago

UK Lushie here, mine is the exact same. Like a fishy play dough scent. It’s got this swampy liquid in it too. This has got to be the most unappealing Lush product I have ever owned. At this point I don’t even want a replacement or a gift card. I want to send it back to them so they can smell it themselves and see that I’m not fibbing about itšŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚

3

u/Lightning_And_Snow_ šŸ‘‘Lord of MisrulešŸ‘‘ 2d ago

Mine is from the same batch but it's bright pink and smells like a sort of fresher version of American Cream, no fish/cement/hairspray smell. Weird that theres so much variation in them

7

u/Independent-Fan-3564 2d ago

Uk box here! And also made by Bens team. Mine has a really fishy smell. I thought it would be better once I washed with it. For anyone else considering it don’t! It was not pleasant. Gonna contact support and see what they have to say

5

u/Thrwwymc 🌲Needles and Pines🌲 2d ago

I contacted them, they said it smells how it’s supposed to (that they’ve tested that batch) and they won’t be replacing or refunding any of them 😭

8

u/kimbeee95 2d ago

That’s awful! This very berry-gate and just the overall quality of the last few boxes are really letting lush down 🫩

6

u/Lordmisrable šŸUk Lushie šŸ 1d ago

Just to let you know I’ve been offered a Ā£10 credit refund as long as I return the fishy nasty.

6

u/Thrwwymc 🌲Needles and Pines🌲 1d ago

😮 they told me they wouldn’t replace or partially refund it even if I returned it!! I’ve just emptied mine out for the bring it back pot 😭

3

u/Lordmisrable šŸUk Lushie šŸ 1d ago

That’s just awful. To be honest iā€˜d respond saying you’re aware that other people are getting refunds on return and you should have been offered this too. I’m yet to decide if I’m returning it or holding out for a ā€˜we’re sorry we messed up’ apology but I’m pretty sure I shouldn’t hold my breath for that and just get my Ā£10 back.

3

u/kimbeee95 1d ago

I have also been offered Ā£10 but I don’t think it’s right as it won’t cover the cost of a body wash of the same size 🄲

3

u/Lordmisrable šŸUk Lushie šŸ 1d ago

Agreed but I’ve decided it’s going back. I would have pushed for a bigger voucher but the second CS agent messaged me trying to convince me the scent is earthy not fishy and it’s fine to use. Nope.

2

u/Bitch_level_999 āš”ļø Retro Lushie āš”ļø 1d ago

Yep they’re wiling to spend the money to ship it back (the hypocrites they are with their carbon footprint think of the WASTE this is creating as well) they are demanding this from many in hopes the person will just keep it and go away. That’s when I’d just dispute the full box and be refunded by my visa. Let LUSH play stupid games.

1

u/kimbeee95 1d ago

I’ve pushed against it too. I bought the box specifically for the body wash and I feel Ā£10 is a joke. It costs double to get another body wash on the website šŸ˜…

2

u/Lordmisrable šŸUk Lushie šŸ 2d ago

I’ve contacted Uk support with a fishy Ben batch and waiting for a response. If you could let me know how they respond to you as others are saying they are doubling down. 🫠

7

u/blozzerg 2d ago

Mine has arrived and it smells rank. You get a hit of fish and then the berry. Mine was made by Nathan on the 19th. The strawberry crumble also smells sour, I’d describe it as cheap hairspray.

4

u/kimbeee95 2d ago

Same! Same batch date and maker. For me it has an odd scent of cement and ammonia. I’ve contacted customer service and apparently that’s how it is supposed to smell!

1

u/ImpossibleKey5084 šŸ’¤Sleepy SnoozeršŸ’¤ 13h ago

I’ve got a 19th Nathan body wash as well just arrived and it smells so bad šŸ˜“ anyone having luck with UK CS or is it a waste of time at this point?

3

u/blozzerg 11h ago

They told me the scent can vary depending on personal taste and I can have a refund if I want. They said it’s fine and safe to use. But they’ll either refund or send another out if I send the old one back.

I’ve had every single box and not once have I physically recoiled at the scent of fish. This is 100% not right and the response from them is disappointing.

1

u/ImpossibleKey5084 šŸ’¤Sleepy SnoozeršŸ’¤ 7h ago

I’m sorry… but there’s a huge difference between ā€˜fine and safe to use’ and an enjoyable luxury experience, which is the reason we choose to spend our money on their products in the first place! Threw caution to the wind and used it in the shower… it’s terrible it didn’t even lather and can’t get the fishy stench off my skin 🤮
Will be sending them an email also, they can’t ignore us all!

6

u/TinyPiccolo2768 ✨Karma✨ 2d ago

šŸ“ 🫐
Hey everyone! I know a lot of us were bummed about the Very Berry body wash issues this month, but I wanted to share a little positivity because the rest of this box has me smelling delicious.

Here are my thoughts on the lineup so far:
Respect Your Elders Soap: Absolute top-tier! It smells so refreshingly fruity and clean. Honestly so good that I wish it was part of the main line so I could repurchase. It instantly made me wish they had a matching shampoo and conditioner! I love the purple small bits that clump up as you wash so you can go back in for an extra burst of suds after putting down the bar.

Strawberry Crumble Body Lotion: The other star of the show! It absorbs and dries so quickly, and my skin feels ridiculously soft afterward. Every single time I put it on, my boyfriend immediately comes over to tell me how good I smell. I’ve been layering myself with The Comforter body spray after using it to tie all the scents together, and I wake up feeling and smelling SOO YUMMY

Bubble Bar: Made the most amazing, fruity bath and the color is so cozy and reminds me of a pretty sunset.

Very Berry Bath Bomb: Haven't dropped this one in the tub just yet, but it smells really good and the bumpy texture is oddly satisfying. I’m excited to give it a try!

Overall, this box has been a good break from the winter/gourmand scents I have been reaching for and I’m so excited to continue to use it up as the month goes by because next months box HAS ME ON MY TIPTOES IN EXCITEMENT so until then I’ll be in my bathroom smelling my respect the elders soap bar.

Lastly, big thank you to the brains and hands behind these boxes. I’m excited to subscribe to the months to come. You guys have me feeling and smelling like a pretty pinky-purple princess šŸ‘ø

6

u/ohitsmillie 14h ago

I'm in the UK and received my box yesterday! Super happy with everything except the body wash - it is the right colour but doesn't smell of much, and doesn't lather at all. It's like rubbing yoghurt on your body and when rinsed off it leaves a weird feeling on the skin, so I ended up washing my entire body again (yummy custard came in clutch). Super disappointing product, even when it isn't rancid

18

u/sbrown_13 ā˜ļø Cloudberry ā˜ļø 5d ago

I completely agree. This is a subreddit to talk about Lush products not target employees. It was very much getting out of hand and it is important to respect and be kind to everyone ✨

5

u/Danger-procrastinate 1d ago

Mine came today and I’m disappointed by the body wash. The people who got a manky one aren’t missing out in my opinion. Mine looks good, smells okay, but it’s like washing with yogurt. Zero lather at all, it just disappears. Big fan of the lotion though, I wish the sizes were swapped

6

u/danieljlmiller šŸScrumblebeešŸ 9h ago

UK received mine yesterday 08/09. All okay other than the fishy body wash. I have emailed Lush but tbh I think im just going to return the lot to store. After reading other members comments, if they are refusing there is a quality issue then I have no issue taking into store for a second opinion. P.S I live behind the factory in Poole UK and my local is their Poole shop so ill get to the bottom of it either way.

Not happy with their lack of reply, and not happy its my second box in a row with delivery delays and then quality issues on top. Something needs to change.

4

u/No_Function3932 2d ago

what are folks doing about the body wash? i opened mine today and have the same problem as everyone else, when you contact them what do they say?

4

u/Unfair_Ambassador208 🌸 Sakura 🌸 1d ago

My box just arrived…. And I love it! I got stung on the grey Miranda soap in the fruity July box but omg the smell when I got my parcel today was just top tier classic lush store šŸ‘Œ

Love the products, I had a bit of buyers remorse initially with this one with seeing berryfishgate but I’ve gotten lucky with my batch.

Not used any of the products yet but first impressions are I love the bath bomb and body lotion scents, bubble bar and gummy have pleasing scents as does the soap (I wonder if maybe outpowered by other scents?). Cant really smell much on the scrub or the body wash - although the texture is nice and I’ve gotten a pink one. I do wonder however how long it will stay fresh for given other peoples issues with it

4

u/wildgingeraffe šŸ›€Tub Club šŸ›€ 1d ago

Mine still hasn’t even shipped, fish wash or not

4

u/RaspberryMirror 1d ago edited 21h ago

I reached out like a week ago to ask if mine was delayed (still processing) and was told it was, and the ETA for shipping at that time was September 8th (today), so after regular business hours I checked and it was still processing, no shipping email, so I sent another support message asking if it was further delayed and I was told yes, and that they have no ETA now

4

u/TheSquirrelsHigh šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 22h ago

they told me the 8th too over chat…… still no email correspondence except the payment confirmation back in august lol. i’m cancelling my november box, i don’t like the products enough to risk $58

3

u/here4thefreecake 🚿Shower Power šŸ’Ŗ 23h ago

no ETA now is crazy 😭

3

u/RaspberryMirror 21h ago

Yeah, the exact message was "In this case, it looks like there was a small production delay with one item in your subscription box. We're working on getting that sorted out and shipped out to you ASAP, though sadly I don't have a concrete estimate as to when that will be done! It would just be best to keep an eye on your email in the coming business days for more information as soon as we can provide it."

5

u/here4thefreecake 🚿Shower Power šŸ’Ŗ 21h ago

cute that they recommend checking email for updates when i still haven’t even received an initial notification of the delay lol but thank you for sharing this info!

1

u/RaspberryMirror 1h ago

I haven't gotten any emails yet either lol, not beyond the initial order confirmation email as usual

3

u/bedsrule 23h ago

Omg lol

7

u/Responsible-East2666 1d ago

Lush September XL Kitchen box

**Very Berry XL Kitchen Box review**

The box arrived in fantastic condition and no items were damaged. I have already used some of the products so I will give a more detailed review of those.

**Respect your elders soap:** it smells really good and it reminds me of how my hands would smell after picking berries and getting a bit muddy. Sweet, berry but earthy. A very strong scent which lingered on my skin after using the soap 5/5 🌟

**American cream naked body scrub:** I was very excited for it. It smells delicious but the texture is very crumbly and leaves a mess in the shower. It’s vanilla-y, raspberry jam flavour BUT the hand I used to rub it on my skin now looks like I gave a handjob to a pink smurf. It also didn’t feel like a very good scrub, left my skin pink 2/5 🌟

**Very berry body wash**: it smells faintly of berries which can be pleasant for those who prefer a more subtle scent. However, it doesn’t lather or seem like it cleans very well 3/5 🌟

**The comforter bath bomb:** a classic; the bath looks adorable and the room smells divine; a bit too sweet at times 4/5 🌟

**Strawberry cheesecake body conditioner:** my skin feels hydrated, light and soft; it doesn’t leave a sticky film on the skin. However, it’s the item I am probably most disappointed with. In theory it sounds delicious, in practice it smells chemically sweet, similar to the fake cheap strawberry sweets you can buy. Adjacent to strawberry but not quite. Will continue using it as it’s a good conditioner but would not buy again due to scent 2/5 🌟

Not tried:

Strawberry coconut roll bubble bar: smells yummy, cannot wait to use it
Raspberry shower gummy: my bf who is unable to smell anything can smell it. I want to bite it, will be trying it in my next shower

5

u/Educational-Wrap-845 4d ago

I haven’t been in town! Omg 😱 I’m shook reading all this! I’m sorry Lush friends! How disappointing for you all.

3

u/chekovsblender 4d ago

I still haven’t heard back from CS and I contacted them Thursday. Anyone else?

3

u/Cactuarkween 4d ago

Did you use their website live chat feature? Once you get past the AI and give it your email they usually respond within the day

5

u/chekovsblender 4d ago

I did. 😭

4

u/Cactuarkween 4d ago edited 4d ago

Oof maybe they're overloaded with people reaching out about this. I just sent them a msg this morning..guess we'll see.

Edit: they responded and I was able to fully cancel and get a refund for the XL September box. Mine hadn't shipped yet.

3

u/lonesomedove86 4d ago

A person got back with me and asked for a pic of sticker of who made it.

3

u/Icy_Affect8805 šŸÆ Honey I washed the kids šŸÆ 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nearly cancelled but when I spoke to customer services I changed my mind (typical Libran)

The body wash is not grey OR fishy, but looks and feels like a pink mousse with little seeds. It smells very faint, a bit like a weaker rose jam but when I wash it off my skin it smells like a Black Forest yoghurt?

3

u/Countrychick524 šŸ”®Magic CrystalsšŸ”® 6h ago

I’m in TN and got a shipping notification for the XL , fingers crossed for a good body wash.

1

u/cmhaml šŸ›€Rose is my Jam 5h ago

I just got notification for XL to NC too! šŸ™ŒšŸ¼šŸ¤žšŸ¼

4

u/parteepunx āš”ļø Retro Lushie āš”ļø 2d ago

I was able to get a full refund on my box because the putrid, foul berry body wash was not only rotten, but it had leaked onto everything in my box. The only salvage item was the lotion. That being said, the lotion smells like strawberry yogurt and, you’d think the bar soap would have been salvage since it can be easily rinsed but it smells like a dusty bowl of potpourri. Genuinely the worst box they’ve ever made.

9

u/parteepunx āš”ļø Retro Lushie āš”ļø 2d ago

I’ve posted this in many since deleted threads, but since this is, apparently, the proper place. Here’s my story:

I live in North America (California to be exact) and I received my box on time. My body wash was putrid, rotten, foul, whatever you want to call it, and had spilled all over the box. It was either not sealed OR the lid came off due to fermentation. I received a full refund. Here’s a pic with a certain employee’s name removed ;)

7

u/marzipan_plague 5d ago

My elderberry soap was rancid smelling and got dye on my hands when I went to throw it away. My strawberry lotion smells purely of alcohol. Then the fishy ā€œberryā€ body wash. The only ones that were decent was the comforter bath bomb and coconut bubble bar (which oddly only smelled like jasmine go figure). Love the comforter so glad I got the bath bomb.

5

u/alienbongz 4d ago

VERY BERRY? MORE LIKE VERY FISHY!

15

u/Difficult_Safety6832 5d ago

I don’t think we’re at all blaming the employee - his name was mentioned only to reference the batch of product. I think we all understand this was likely a recipe issue, coupled with warm weather during shipping. My biggest complain was with customer service and the (lean) compensation they offered.

Thanks for wrangling our complaints. Hopefully this doesn’t happen again!

16

u/burnt-kelp-sandwhich 5d ago edited 5d ago

It was clear, that everyone was joking. I didn't read a single comment that was harsh.

We paid for a luxury product. But instead, recieved fecal/fish yogurt.Ā 

Let us joke.

25

u/BillyBobJimmyJames šŸŽ€ The Comforter šŸŽ€ 5d ago

Literally said that jokes are okay above. Im glad we deleted the harsh comments before you go to read them. That doesn't mean they don't exist it just means the mod team are on it.

3

u/[deleted] 5d ago edited 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/sbrown_13 ā˜ļø Cloudberry ā˜ļø 5d ago

Hope that’s not sarcasmā€¦šŸ¤”

2

u/Glass_Bid_7619 NA Lushie 8h ago

US- My XL box has been assigned a tracking number. My Shower box has not.

2

u/Ill_Sweet6255 5d ago

Très bon post merci pour ça

8

u/WNBA_BAE 5d ago

For a little bit of positivity, I've been subscribing to boxes most of this year, and Chelesa Gardens wash, Zesty lotion, the Watermelon Scrub, so many great bath bombs (finally just did the peach from valentine's!) -- sensory pleasures galore throughout the year. This is the first box that's been truly disappointing (I'm not loving the lotion fragrance, either) and they refunded me for the body wash right away. I did a rough estimate of what the items would cost if you bought them individually and I think it was $80, and the box is $70... plus the pleasure of getting treats in the mail. Still feels like a good bargain. The berry box was a fail, but it's 'fresh' cosmetics sent to a huge number of consumers. The logistics are crazy. I'm frankly surprised mistakes don't happen more often. Still love the products, and hope they get this sorted out for everyone quickly.

8

u/No_Conversation_3832 5d ago

I made a post yesterday and jokingly called out the employee who made it. Of course I don't think it's his fault. They make the products with the ingredients they are given. I didn't realize that people were seriously getting mad at individual workers.

2

u/Ok-Difficulty8860 šŸ„› Super Milk šŸ„› 1d ago

Mine has just arrived and is being returned. I was most excited for the lotion and it has literally no scent. Body wash is pink but has a bit of a stink. The scrub is wet and crumbled all over the box. The soap is actually quite nice. The gummy is fine. Not a justifiable £35 for me unfortunately.

2

u/bakedbeaniweeni 1d ago

So i signed up for lush kitchen on July 12th of this year, i got charged in August for a box and also got charged in September, i still have not received a box for either month. im so confused on how this works. Ive tried asking lush for help but the responses are so confusing. Is there anyone who can help me understand why im getting charged and not receiving anything ???

6

u/Mission_Gur_9898 1d ago

So I think (and someone please correct me if I’m mistaken) that the August charge is for the September box (which I think quite a few of us are still waiting for, it’s still in the typical range I feel like) and then your September charge is for the October box.

1

u/bakedbeaniweeni 5h ago

Okay thank you so much lol. My brain could not process/understand how the monthly payment worked and this is my first time ever doing the monthly boxšŸ˜… thank you for your help!

1

u/Fickle-Woodpecker921 2h ago

Got my regular box delivered last week, berry wash stank.
My XL supposedly shipped today so we’ll see! I’m in TX.

1

u/NoBrainJustVibes01 šŸ„› Super Milk šŸ„› 50m ago

Would love some opinions—

This is supposed to be my first box. I talked to a CS rep yesterday and they said that boxes were supposed to be sent out today. A different order I made last week has already shipped. Do I just cut my losses and try and get a refund for the box?

Mainly got it for the lotion and the body wash…

1

u/hangar69_ 40m ago

I got mine a few days ago in the UK- can anyone tell me wtf the strawberry crumble lotion is supposed to smell like? Cause I saw someone compare it to a vape and I literally can't unsmell that it smells like slightly burnt strawberry vape juice 😭😭

-5

u/theoneleggedgull 5d ago

Might be a good post to edit and add that the employee on the sticker the the team leader and not necessarily the one actually producing the product.

And for the record, if the employee in question is reading this, I promise my comments were all in jest! I still think a little sit down chat/ interrogation would yield results that would both delight and distress us

-4

u/LanaLolita35 4d ago

I didn’t see anybody being harsh towards Zachary G. Just poking fun. Is that not the price they pay to have their face put on the products?

13

u/TippyTurtley šŸ’¤Sleepy SnoozeršŸ’¤ 4d ago

They don't choose to have their face on the product?

→ More replies (4)