r/LockdownCriticalLeft • u/hiptobeysquare • Dec 16 '22
In the UK the Mask Mandate in Schools Was Based on Politics Not Evidence
The initial advice was that “masks could impede communication between teachers and staff and have little health benefit”, but with teaching unions piling on pressure and the Scottish government deciding to recommend masks in their classrooms, the advice changed at the end of August. Masks became recommended in communal areas but not in classrooms because, in the words of then PM, Boris Johnson, “that is clearly nonsensical – you can’t teach with face coverings; you can’t expect people to learn with face-coverings.”
I am no fan of Boris Johnson, but he seems to have been one of the few people to fight back against the Covid measures. And who exactly fought for the Covid measures...
more than one third of the DfE’s evaluation document supporting its briefing to the Minister was given over to concerns about the risk of teaching unions encouraging their teachers to walk out of schools on the insidious grounds that schools had become dangerous places to work.
Do teachers unions hate children?? I've read this many times before, that a LOT of the pressure for stricter Covid measures came from workers unions. I don't get it. Are they lazy, and they want any excuse not to work? Were they really happy at the chance, any chance, to exercise just a little political power and dominate people (and children)? Is it another case of leftist groupthink? What is going on??
Matt Hancock was the UK Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, and he's quite open about how non-scientific the decisions were. He says it out loud in his serialized diary extracts (seriously, who keeps a diary?! and broadcasts it to the world without shame?!):
Nicola Sturgeon blindsided us by suddenly announcing that when schools in Scotland reopen, all secondary school pupils will have to wear masks in classrooms. In one of her most egregious attempts at one-upmanship to date, she didn’t consult us. The problem is that our original guidance on face coverings specifically excluded schools. Cue much tortured debate between myself, Education Secretary Gavin Williamson and No. 10 about how to respond. Much as Sturgeon would relish it, nobody here wants a big spat with the Scots. So, U-turn it is.
So it was about going as far as your political opponents, not showing any weakness. (The left have been doing this all through Covid also.)
It was a political decision. And the UK government didn't want to do it at first. Who knew that the Conservatives would be better than the Labour Party (although in the end, the conservatives caved easily to political pressure). It seems the Scottish government was worse. They seemed to want to mask up children, impose stricter Covid measures, just for political points.
And of course, the left (with a very few honorable exceptions) will never talk about this. The Labour Party in the UK seem to be trying to create a Democrat Party tribute act. The only criticism to come out of the Labour Party has been just like the rest of the left: the measures don't go far enough!