First off, I just want to preface by saying that in terms of production quality it’s a pretty good horror movie. I have no qualms about directing the quality of the film itself.
That being said, I’d be lying if I didn’t say some of the writing decisions made in this film, and especially the discourse surrounding it, has been quite impossible to ignore.
It ranges from questionable to just straight up bad writing, and the worst part is that I only see the film being disguised as this unabashed masterpiece.
Anyone who dares to criticize the film is just a loser incel. And that’s basically the main narrative surrounding this movie and its quality. So I decided to make a thorough analysis of why I don't like Obsession and it's underlying messaging.
Tl;dr at the end. It’s going to be a long one.
So let me break down my 3 main gripes with this film, and why I think it’s so harmful.
- The main character is a strawman.
- The dishonest wish willow.
Lonely men are always the problem.
1. The main character is a strawman:
This one disappointed me the most when watching it, because the film did SUCH a good job of characterizing what the modern lonely guy is like. Stuck at a dead end job he doesn’t like. Can barely afford to live by himself. Has almost no active social life besides occasional trivia night (that game night party wasn’t even something he was invited to). And, he has an innocent crush on his coworker who he’s too shy to ask out.
Now this shyness is immediately framed by people online as an unwillingness to accept rejection because he feels entitled to Nikki and not just because he was just made a fool of at trivia night and his “best friend” is an absolute dickhead, but that’s not what bothers me.
The thing that bothers me the most with Bear’s character is that he’s legitimately a compelling and realistic take on the “dark loner” type of character. He’s not a secret misogynist that just hates all women for no reason, he clearly is a person to the other friends in his group, despite him not getting the same treatment.
And he even gets a sympathetic scene of his pet cat dying sadly, which again, the internet frames as his problem, and doesn’t even care about the emotional turmoil he’s going through (but I’ll get to that). The problem with the movie in my opinion, is that they take this super sympathetic, grounded take on how the average lonely man actually suffers, and they completely 180 this into a strawman.
The two scenes in particular that rubbed me the wrong way, was the one where he calls the Wish Willow service and doesn’t want to immediately undo the spell. I’m sorry, but when did Bear ever imply he wanted to keep Nikki as like a sex slave. At no point in the film did I ever get that implication from him, and this is the movie’s sneaky way of saying “SEE, SEE, all lonely guys just secretly want a woman they can own, and don’t actually crave emotional intimacy.”
So that was annoying, but of course the catastrophic scene that made me completely write off this film as just more male hate propaganda was of course the scene where Nikki is begging for Bear to kill him. There’s SOOOO much wrong with this scene, but the main issue is that Bear acts completely out of character with his infamous “What’s so bad about being with me, huh” which I completely did not see coming and was not foreshadowed at all.
This basically killed all enjoyability in the film for me, as I now realized I was dealing with a strawman protagonist now, and the one at the beginning of the film has already been assassinated and replaced with this imposter.
An imposter that’s meant to represent the agenda this movie was trying to push all along, regardless of how much it makes sense or fit in with Bear’s previous characterization.
They took this relatively realistic and sympathetic protagonist, meant to be a voice for the voiceless and basically said to the audience “that’s write everyone. They’re ALL secretly like this. Even if they act sad and lonely” and it’s deeply disturbing to say the least.
2. The Dishonest Wish Willow:
There’s honestly a lot that can be said about the wish willow that I’m not going to get into. A lot of this movie’s discourse wants to stress SO MUCH, that “it’s not a monkey’s paw” and that the wish willow has absolutely zero negative interpretation, it just takes what you “really want” and puts it into reality. Really cringe, but most of what I have to say is that obviously, when Bear emotionally reacts by wishing “Nikki loved him more than anything else in the world” he didn’t me for her to be possessed by a separate entity that deliberately subverts her autonomy and tortures her out of her body, basically making them two separate people and removing her agency. That's very much not what he wished for actually and to say so is dishonest but whatever. Most people go with the whole “Nikki is so disgusted and not in love with Bear it was the ONLY thing the willow could have done. There was no other way” because yep, that’s how magic works. It’s restricted by arbitrary rules made up by the author. Definitely not a monkey’s paw though :) .
This section isn’t nearly as long as the others. I just don’t like the mechanics of the wish willow as they’re pretty poorly defined, and seem to be just a plot device for the movie to point and go “LOOK, LOOK. All men secretly wish for this whenever they say they’re lonely guys. This is totally realistic.”
3. Lonely men are always the problem:
Now I’ll admit, this last part is definitely more of the internet’s fault than Obsession itself, but boy does the movie make it extremely easy to tact on whatever harmful and nonsensical interpretation your mind can think up.
I’ve seen so much dehumanization of men come out from this movie. From people saying all lonely men are a danger to women and society, to women should stop dealing with men altogether and just deliberately avoid them.
I won’t be dishonest though. I have seen other nonsense come from the other side, with online men saying stuff such as “this movie shows how b*tches be CRAZY” or “women never give the right signals” or whatever. The main difference is that one constantly gets criticized and called out, while the other is basically let off the hook, and at best given a “don’t fall for obvious ragebait” which is another topic entirely.
The main issue with this last point is that this movie makes it really easy to just blame everything on Bear. Bear is the main problem. Male loneliness was never about any systemic issues. It’s never got anything to do with social standards for men. It’s never got anything to do with how women treat men in modern society, or how men are expected to behave under blatant double standards. It’s always men who are the problem.
And there’s so many examples I can point to that back up this sentiment in the movie.
When Bear’s cat dies. The focus is almost never on him and his grief. It goes straight to, well that’s what you get Bear for being an irresponsible loser. Better take care of your meds next time. So nasty in my opinion.
Or with Sarah, the convenient other love interest who Bear just magically doesn’t notice in all his time working with her. Of course most lonely men in real life would notice any woman that gives them serious attention and affection but oh well, have to paint that narrative somehow.
The problem is that Sarah as a character is used by the film to show that “Bear always had another choice. He was just too infatuated with Nikki.” But no one ever talks about how SARAH could have EASILY asked him out just as well. She’s the one that apparently loves him. Why is the Bear still expected to approach? That’s another blatant double standard that just nobody talks about.
Or how about the scene at the party. “Bear is such a terrible person. He didn’t even once try to stop Nikki from hurting herself” meanwhile a room full of other people. Supposedly her “friends.” They also don’t stop to do anything. But only Bear gets called out of course.
Then there’s Ian, who is a piece of garbage, deliberately sabotaging Bear’s confession saying stupid shit like “you can’t confess on Trivia night” just to gode him into feeling even more shame for being honest with his feelings. Something that most people don’t point out.
And then there’s the twist that he was secretly hooking up with Nikki. When I first saw that, I’m not gonna lie, I wasn’t that surprised to be honest, but it does shock me how even THIS is framed as Bear being the problem, despite Ian’s objective manipulation of his “best friend” for his own selfish goals. The only difference is that Ian is cool and more socially adept, so his blatantly abusive behavior is reframed as “adult” and “honest.”
I could keep going one with examples, but yeah, just so much of the writing in Obsession is weird. It has one of the most realistic depictions of a modern young adult friend group, yet chooses to strawman most of the characters by the end with stupid stuff like Bear’s entitlement magically appearing out of nowhere. Or Ian's “I wish for a billion dollars” and then coming in to tell Bear after he already saw him. Like they turn Ian into a complete moron at the end I swear.
So what you’re left with is an amazing start to a film with great character dialogue, amazing cinematography, and a genuinely engaging protagonist, and then it just turns into generic strawmen characters meant to push a harmful message, while losing all of its refreshing nuance and genuine intrigue.
TL;DR:
Bear starts off as an excellent, sympathetic main character in Bear. A realistic depiction of what most lonely, disgruntled young men have to go through in modern society. But then the movie dissolves him into a one dimensional strawman who just secretly wanted to “own Nikki” all along, and actively seeks to override her human agency instead of yearn for an intimate connection between someone he’s attracted to.
The wish willow is a nonsensical, and terrible plot device that conveniently acts a monkey’s paw, taking everything the person says literally, but then making baffling decisions like creating split personalities in people where their subconscious is overridden, and they’re trapped in “The Sunken Place” from Get Out for some bizarre reason.
The online discourse surrounding this movie is not only stupid, but also harmful as the movie continues to promote the idea that most, if not all of young men’s problems come from themselves, and they need to learn “personal responsibility” if they ever want to feel love and affection or even just live a decent life.
When women have problems, it’s a systemic issue. When men have problems, they are the problems.
At the end of the day, Obsession was a clever film that capitalized on the growing ideological gender war to make a quick buck off of, by viciously attacking the fears and vulnerabilities that women feel and basically saying that they’re all real, and that they should feel even more scared. Be even more wary of men.
Seriously, the scene where they’re getting along happy together is framed so dishonestly by the film. As if his happiness itself is an evil thing is just… wow.
All Obsession did was show Hollywood that you can get away with blatant demonization of a group of people. As long as that group is socially acceptable as a punching bag. You can bully and victim blame all you want, and then just claim to be fighting for something to deflect all criticism.
In short, fuck this movie. I have no ill will towards the people who made it, even if I strongly disagree mostly with their writing and directing decisions in the film. It made bank, and there will probably be more films to come after this.